Due to the apparent problem some members are having with the quality/ferociousness of game other members are posting, should sticter guidelines be established.

Question:
Should the admin staff of the ARF establish guidelines for the content of pictures of game that members of the site have killed on their hunts?

Choices:
Only record Book Quality animals should be displayed on AR.
Only DG should be displayed on AR.
Any animal that anyone killed and is proud of should be allowed.

 

Here is my comment.

Hey Scott

1. Beautiful rifle ( would it happen to be in the 257 Bob?)
2. Fine picture quality
3. According to my definition, if you can get more than one meal, then it's big game.
4. Bet he was mighty tasty
5. Sure looks a lot like east Texas dirt. Bet it came off your own property

Best

GWB

PS: Enjoyed the pix, post more when you have a mindto.

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
Hey Scott

1. Beautiful rifle ( would it happen to be in the 257 Bob?)
2. Fine picture quality
3. According to my definition, if you can get more than one meal, then it's big game.
4. Bet he was mighty tasty
5. Sure looks a lot like east Texas dirt. Bet it came off your own property

Best

GWB

PS: Enjoyed the pix, post more when you have a mindto.

Thanks GW. It is my 257R. He was the only legal deer I saw last year on my land in East Texas. Antler restricted county and I didn't see a monster so I took the funny looking deer with a nub on one side. He was the tastiest deer I've had in some time. Not sure if it was the processor in Mount Pleasant or the deer.

I am just not real sure anymore. I mean there is not a lot of mass to the antlers and surely that animal would not be considered dangerous in the "real world" of "Real Hunters".

I looked for this picture for about 10 minutes before I found it. It was no where near a feeder nor behind a fence, (the picture that is).




Does that qualify as hunting?

Best

GWB

Here's what I have to say about it:

I see the situation, I just do not see the problem.

Small, big game!



GWB

Anyone going through a rough patch really owes CHC a big thanks for his continuing series of Sad Sack posts. Proving that things could be worse, is an honorable calling.

quote:

Anyone going through a rough patch really owes CHC a big thanks for his continuing series of Sad Sack posts. Proving that things could be worse, is an honorable calling.

Your meaningless comments are always appreciated.

Please enlighten me as to why anyone being proud of something they killed and wanting to share it with others is a "BAD" thing?

Can you do that in a reasonable manner?

Or are you saying that anyone that kills anything that is not a certifiable "Trophy" should not be proud of what they did and under no circumstances should they post pictures of it on an internet forum.

What message are you trying to get across here?

Strange what has happened to this place

I voted #1

quote:

Please enlighten me as to why anyone being proud of something they killed and wanting to share it with others is a "BAD" thing?

Once you have seen 10 photos of run of the mill dead deer, bear, antelope, pig, squirrel, etc etc. You have pretty much seen them all. You might be proud of what you shot... great! But I certainly don't need a photo in order to imagine what it might look like laided out dead in the dirt.

Its like having to look thru other folks skiing holiday snaps. mildly entertaining for the first 60 seconds. After that the boredom levels start to increase exponentially. Wow! More snow aye!

quote:

What message are you trying to get across here?

Just cos you can............doesn't mean that you should.

Anyone can be an asshole when there is 500 miles or more of internet between them and you.

I have a photo of me and two fawn antelope I'll post when I get home.

You don't need 500 miles or more of internet between folks for one of them to be an asshole.

Don't rush home on my account. I can figure it out.

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
I looked for this picture for about 10 minutes before I found it. It was no where near a feeder nor behind a fence, (the picture that is).




Does that qualify as hunting?

Best

GWB

It does Geedub, great photo man!

Intriguing.

Start a thread that attracts some sensible responses.

Notice that Jools posts .

Watch the thread deteriorate into a shitfight .

Observe that Jools is at the centre of said shit fight.

Lose interest in any thread that Jools has input.

Disappointed in how the world now works ..:-(

quote:

Lose interest in any thread that Jools has input.

But not disinterested enough not to post....

So who's tossing the shit and who's merely expressing a POV?

Disappointed that you don't seem to know the difference ....

quote:

Originally posted by Jools:

Once you have seen 10 photos of run of the mill dead deer, bear, antelope, pig, squirrel, etc etc. You have pretty much seen them all. You might be proud of what you shot... great! But I certainly don't need a photo in order to imagine what it might look like laided out dead in the dirt.

I can see your point. Looking at vacation photos of your friends can be a little boring sometimes but you oooh and ahhh anyway to be polite. At least 99% of people would do that just to be polite. Here on the internet, you can choose not to look. If you do look, the only thing you need to do to be polite is not make a negative comment. You can even make no comment and be polite. Seems like fairly simple task for an educated open minded gentleman.

Hope this isn't too ordinary to view and doesn't bore anyone. Maine cow moose 2011. Here you go:

To me, any moose is a trophy, same with elk. I am still happy that I killed one with a rifle. Getting one with a handgun or bow would be really special.

Thanks, CHC!

Whitworth, you look to be a pretty substantial fellow, and that definitely is more than enough meat for one meal. I would certainly call that big game.

What did that beast weigh?

GWB

quote:

Originally posted by scottfromdallas:

quote:

Originally posted by Jools:

Once you have seen 10 photos of run of the mill dead deer, bear, antelope, pig, squirrel, etc etc. You have pretty much seen them all. You might be proud of what you shot... great! But I certainly don't need a photo in order to imagine what it might look like laided out dead in the dirt.

I can see your point. Looking at vacation photos of your friends can be a little boring sometimes but you oooh and ahhh anyway to be polite. At least 99% of people would do that just to be polite. Here on the internet, you can choose not to look. If you do look, the only thing you need to do to be polite is not make a negative comment. You can even make no comment and be polite. Seems like fairly simple task for an educated open minded gentleman.

Scott

I do as a routine follow the course of action you advise. However in this particular occassion the OP did pose the question. I replied to that question.

Normally when being shown vaction, hunting successes, baby photo's I simply make the appropriate noises for the firt few then make my excuses to go visit the bathroom, or go check on the dogs/boiler/bbq/stew pot/sunset, etc. On internet forums I just skip to the next post unless something worth comment catches my eye as I scroll down. I try to always be polite, even when making a negtive comment. Personally I don't mind comments either positive or negative. They help the conversation along and add a touch of flavour. As long as they are polite.

I guess I'm just not the sensitive type!

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
Whitworth, you look to be a pretty substantial fellow, and that definitely is more than enough meat for one meal. I would certainly call that big game.

What did that beast weigh?

GWB

Around 800-lbs -- big for a Canadian cow moose. We got lots of meat from her......

That would make quite a bit of sausage, ground meat and cutlets.
If you don't mind saying did you have it processed and into what cuts/products?

Also, I must have missed the story of that hunt. Could you link to it here or PM me I would certainly like to either read or re-read that story.

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
Whitworth, you look to be a pretty substantial fellow, and that definitely is more than enough meat for one meal. I would certainly call that big game.

What did that beast weigh?

GWB

Around 800-lbs -- big for a Canadian cow moose. We got lots of meat from her......

I bet you did.

Could have done without the moose on a noose photo. But would have liked a photo showing how close or how far away you were when you popped a cap in its ass and a note saying wheather it took more than one.

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
That would make quite a bit of sausage, ground meat and cutlets.
If you don't mind saying did you have it processed and into what cuts/products?

Processing an 800lb carcass is one hell of a chore if you don't have the necessary equipment. I worked for a short spell in an small abattoir/game dealers. Sheep/pigs/smaller deer species were no prolem. Beef cattle and big woodland red deer were heavy going.

quote:

Originally posted by Jools:
I guess I'm just not the sensitive type!

Good to hear.

Perhaps I can share a couple thoughts, maybe they will breeze on by, maybe not.

A wise man years past, postulated that "It is better to hear the rebuke of the wise, than for a man to hear the song of fools." Ecclesiastes 7:5 I don't claim to be wise, maybe a wise-ass........
but you get my drift.........

When I read your sig line I think of certain Brit, Winston Churchill IIRC, rather than Ms. Mier. Seems he made a statement about a certain fellow of his acquaintence. It goes something like this "A modest man, who has much to be modest about"
Yet from your posts I would say that the term hupselokardia" would apply much more than "meekness" or modesty.

Best


GWB

quote:

Originally posted by Jools:

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
Whitworth, you look to be a pretty substantial fellow, and that definitely is more than enough meat for one meal. I would certainly call that big game.

What did that beast weigh?

GWB

Around 800-lbs -- big for a Canadian cow moose. We got lots of meat from her......

I bet you did.

Could have done without the moose on a noose photo. But would have liked a photo showing how close or how far away you were when you popped a cap in its ass and a note saying wheather it took more than one.

Deal with the photo, Jools, but the state weighs them and this was a photo of that process. First shot was about 100 yards and lethal (double lung), but I shot until she dropped. Moose tend not to react......

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
That would make quite a bit of sausage, ground meat and cutlets.
If you don't mind saying did you have it processed and into what cuts/products?

Also, I must have missed the story of that hunt. Could you link to it here or PM me I would certainly like to either read or re-read that story.

Geedubya -- we took her to a butcher as I had to get on the road back to the south. I split meat with the outfitter as I don't have the freezer capacity for so much meat. I got steak off of her -- lots of steak!

Glenn -- PM heading your way.....

quote:

Originally posted by Jools:

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
That would make quite a bit of sausage, ground meat and cutlets.
If you don't mind saying did you have it processed and into what cuts/products?

Processing an 800lb carcass is one hell of a chore if you don't have the necessary equipment. I worked for a short spell in an small abattoir/game dealers. Sheep/pigs/smaller deer species were no prolem. Beef cattle and big woodland red deer were heavy going.

No doubt.

Most of the stuff we shoot is 300 lbs. and under, consequently it can be handled rather easily. I've skinned and quartered five or six fair sized hogs and once a half dozen rams at one "sitting". By the time I was finished I knew I'd "been there".

I do know that by the end of the season I'm much more proficient at getting the job done than at the beginning. Funny how going even a month without performing the ritual dulls the senses.

Best

GWB

I keep two freezers in my garage. I bet that would have filled them both and then some. Boned out that would probably have been around 240 lbs of "meat". That could be turned into an easy hundred pounds of jalepeno cheese salami and link sausage, not to mention all the other stuff.

Ya done good.

Best

GWB

There was about 350-lbs of meat, Glenn! Not enough freezer space in my house!

Check your PMs.

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:
There was about 350-lbs of meat, Glenn! Not enough freezer space in my house!

Check your PMs.

The moose in Russia were similarly vast, I have some video of me skinning one somewhere wherein I could have actually crawled in the rib cage to cut the fillets out.

They butcher in the field there and carry the bits out on cut saplings.

Nice moose there Marko, despite the "ordinary" picture.

The Russians love liver by the way and there's a hell of a lot of it in a moose...

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
I keep two freezers in my garage. I bet that would have filled them both and then some. Boned out that would probably have been around 240 lbs of "meat". That could be turned into an easy hundred pounds of jalepeno cheese salami and link sausage, not to mention all the other stuff.

Ya done good.

Best

GWB

You must of never eatin Moose meat.No way I would turn that into sausage.I reserve that for speed goats and old boar bear!!!

quote:

Originally posted by Ghubert:

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:
There was about 350-lbs of meat, Glenn! Not enough freezer space in my house!

Check your PMs.

The moose in Russia were similarly vast, I have some video of me skinning one somewhere wherein I could have actually crawled in the rib cage to cut the fillets out.

They butcher in the field there and carry the bits out on cut saplings.

Nice moose there Marko, despite the "ordinary" picture.

The Russians love liver by the way and there's a hell of a lot of it in a moose...

Amir,
did I miss your story also. Guess I need to start reading more and posting less.

Best
GWB

quote:

Originally posted by Geedubya:
A wise man years past, postulated that "It is better to hear the rebuke of the wise, than for a man to hear the song of fools." Ecclesiastes 7:5 I don't claim to be wise, maybe a wise-ass........
but you get my drift.........

Nope!I hear you flapping your gums, but thats about it.

quote:

When I read your sig line I think of certain Brit, Winston Churchill IIRC, rather than Ms. Mier. Seems he made a statement about a certain fellow of his acquaintence. It goes something like this "A modest man, who has much to be modest about"
Yet from your posts I would say that the term hupselokardia" would apply much more than "meekness" or modesty.

I wouldn't know its all "greek " to me.

What I do know is only a fool takes himself or anyone else for that mater seriously.

quote:

Originally posted by Ghubert:

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:
There was about 350-lbs of meat, Glenn! Not enough freezer space in my house!

Check your PMs.

The moose in Russia were similarly vast, I have some video of me skinning one somewhere wherein I could have actually crawled in the rib cage to cut the fillets out.

They butcher in the field there and carry the bits out on cut saplings.

Nice moose there Marko, despite the "ordinary" picture.

The Russians love liver by the way and there's a hell of a lot of it in a moose...

Thanks, Amir! What strikes me the most about their size is how tall they are.

quote:

Originally posted by Whitworth:
Deal with the photo, Jools, but the state weighs them and this was a photo of that process. First shot was about 100 yards and lethal (double lung), but I shot until she dropped. Moose tend not to react......

Worry not I have dealt with the photo.

I am told by my scandinavia friends that they(moose) are pretty dumb.