The Accurate Reloading Forums
S&W M57.... Can this be repaired
22 April 2020, 06:51
Uncle GrinchS&W M57.... Can this be repaired
Found the 41 Mag for sale on another forum and wondered if this can be repaired...
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
You can replace the bushing; Brownells has them; but will never get the stake marks out of the frame, short of tig welding them up; which would be dumb.
They are supposed to be staked with one round punch from the front; guess his got loose and all he had was a two pound ball pein hammer and a big center punch.
Looks like bubba hit the punch close too the FP hole; if it does not hang up on that,
Just shoot it as is.
22 April 2020, 15:27
jeffeossoHey Tom,
if one stake is good, 57 must be better? not even restaked old valve seats on a lawnmower should look like this!
22 April 2020, 15:52
p dog shooterIf it shoots I just use it has it is.
22 April 2020, 17:13
clowdisIs that staking or cratering around the primer? Can't believe someone would do that with a staking tool.
"Peace is that brief glorious moment in history when everybody stands around reloading".
22 April 2020, 17:44
Uncle GrinchFound out seller said he believes it’s gas cutting due to hot loads. My mind says stay away.
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
22 April 2020, 18:10
Fury01If that is gas cutting...there was lots of leaking primers!!!!
"The liberty enjoyed by the people of these states of worshiping Almighty God agreeably to their conscience, is not only among the choicest of their blessings, but also of their rights."
~George Washington - 1789
I assume he is not the original owner/shooter.
27 April 2020, 05:39
eagle27Leave it as it is and fill the staking or gas cutting holes!!! with a metal epoxy suitably coloured to match the blued steel. It is really only cosmetic.
27 April 2020, 18:29
AFRICAN LEADWOODI would check out the rest of it and not worry too much if it were sound and the price right.
I have marks like this on a fairly low round count revolver that seemed to leak primers no matter what. Brass was not readily available here and the brass was probably a bit loose, but the point is loads were not particularly heavy. Things are not always as they may seem. Calibre is 475 Lin in case someone wondered.
28 April 2020, 18:36
Doug WHopefully he shot better than he center punched/staked. lol
30 April 2020, 00:32
AtkinsonThat isn't gas cutting,not even close...Someone went stake crazy..I would just replace it and stake it properly..Perhaps send it to S&W..no big deal but I couldn't live with it as is, but that's just me..
Ray Atkinson
Atkinson Hunting Adventures
10 Ward Lane,
Filer, Idaho, 83328
208-731-4120
rayatkinsonhunting@gmail.com
Too late for that; the original staking was a round circle which is barely visible in the photo; if you punch out and replace the FP bushing, the staking will still be on the frame.
No cure; shoot it and forget about it.
30 April 2020, 09:30
NormanConquestI agree. If you are still adamant, then for your next chore, try putting toothpaste back in the tube. I'm sorry, that was rude. Just enjoy your 41 as is. It is a great revolver + calibre.
Never mistake motion for action.