THE ACCURATERELOADING.COM MEDIUM BORE RIFLE FORUM

Accuratereloading.com    The Accurate Reloading Forums    THE ACCURATE RELOADING.COM FORUMS  Hop To Forum Categories  Rifles  Hop To Forums  Medium Bore Rifles    Which has more poop: 358 Win or 9X57?

Moderators: Paul H
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
Which has more poop: 358 Win or 9X57?
 Login/Join
 
One of Us
posted
Loaded to equal pressures (say 52,000 CUP), which round gives more velocity, 358 Win or 9X57?


Matt
FISH!!

Heed the words of Winston Smith in Orwell's 1984:

"Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right."
 
Posts: 3296 | Location: Northern Colorado | Registered: 22 November 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Just pure speculation on my part, but since the 9x57 has a little more powder capacity, I'd say the 9x57 would probably be the winner.

In comparing similar bullet weights in both cartridges:

I believe the original Winchester ammo spec for the .358 Winchester was a 250 gr bullet at 2250 fps. According to a reprint of a Mauser inter-war catalog that I have, the 9x57 was loaded with a 247 gr bullet at 2296 fps. (Some other sources say 2310 fps. Kynoch loaded a 245 gr bullet at 2150 fps.)

The 9x57 Mauser
http://www.african-hunter.com/9x57_mauser.htm

-Bob F.
 
Posts: 3485 | Location: Houston, Texas | Registered: 22 February 2001Reply With Quote
One of Us
Picture of Alberta Canuck
posted Hide Post
In my rifles, the 9x57 is clearly more powerful than the .358 Winchester when handloaded to everyday working max. As already mentioned, the 9x57 has more case capacity. Same size case head*, same size bullet*, 51 m/m long case for the .358, 57 m/m long case for the 9x57.

(* At least within a couple of thousandths of an inch.)

Or,better yet, you can load to the same performance at lower pressures, in the 9x57.


My country gal's just a moonshiner's daughter, but I love her still.

 
Posts: 9685 | Location: Cave Creek 85331, USA | Registered: 17 August 2001Reply With Quote
One of Us
Picture of El Deguello
posted Hide Post
quote:
Just pure speculation on my part, but since the 9x57 has a little more powder capacity, I'd say the 9x57 would probably be the winner.


Yes, of course! The same difference that exists between the 7X57mm and the 7mm/'08, the 6mm Rem and the .243 Win., etc., etc. The 57mm case wins every time, albeit by a very narrow margin!


"Bitte, trinks du nicht das Wasser. Dahin haben die Kuhen gesheissen."
 
Posts: 4386 | Location: New Woodstock, Madison County, Central NY | Registered: 04 January 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Tex21
posted Hide Post
And I'll add that the 9x57 has a little more class than the 358 Winnie, albeit, but a slim margin...


Jason

"Chance favors the prepared mind."
 
Posts: 1449 | Location: Dallas, Texas | Registered: 24 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of packrattusnongratus
posted Hide Post
Jason, Jason! Have you ever looked hard at the Savage 99? I can say there are guns with equal class. But not many that outclass the 99. Certainly none in the lever guns I have handles, not even the 1886 Winchester. Just a pet peeve of mine. I have however handled a Euro made gun in .358, Double set triggers, butterknife bolt handle, .... It was a case of buyers remorse there. I didn't buy it! boohoo And was remorseful. Still, it had no more class than my 99 brush gun in .358WCF.
 
Posts: 2140 | Registered: 28 May 2002Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
Would it be unwise to build a 9x57 with a .358" bore/groove diameter rather than the original .356" bore. I don't see why not. Do you? Even if, for some odd reason, I had to use ammo with .356" bullets, I don't see why it wouldn't shoot. I would load my own anyway.


Matt
FISH!!

Heed the words of Winston Smith in Orwell's 1984:

"Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right."
 
Posts: 3296 | Location: Northern Colorado | Registered: 22 November 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Tex21
posted Hide Post
Matt I've pondered this question myself and the conclusion I came to was no.

There's only .002" difference and I can't seem to find a supply of .356" bullets anywhere. .358"'s however are plentiful and I doubt your reloading dies would notice the difference.

Were I to build a 9x57, I'd go with the commonly available .358"'s.


Jason

"Chance favors the prepared mind."
 
Posts: 1449 | Location: Dallas, Texas | Registered: 24 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of z1r
posted Hide Post
This is one instance where, if I were building a gun, I'd opt for the .358 winnie as components are much cheaper. That includes dies, cases, and reamers.

I agree that the .358 and a Savage 99 would be a super combo.




Aut vincere aut mori
 
Posts: 4865 | Location: Lakewood, CO | Registered: 07 February 2002Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
Tex21,
when i had my reamer ground for this cartridge i had it made with a removable pilot. i have a 35 cal barrel that i am making one for myself so i can use a larger assortment of bullets.
max
 
Posts: 981 | Location: Shenandoah Valley VA | Registered: 05 January 2005Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
A pre-64 Winchester model 88 would have enough class for me as well. Ninety-nines are classy though.


Matt
FISH!!

Heed the words of Winston Smith in Orwell's 1984:

"Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right."
 
Posts: 3296 | Location: Northern Colorado | Registered: 22 November 2005Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
I think that a lot of people, such as myself, appreciate historical rifles and cartridges, and like to see them revived. I think the 358 win is a great round, but the 9X57 was as well in it's day. A 9X57 (or most any classic pre-war cartridge) made up on an old DWM or Oberndorf action with classic mauser lines just makes my heart piter-pater. To me, the 358 Win belongs in a CRF model 70 or model 88. These have their own romance as well. To each his own.
quote:
This is one instance where, if I were building a gun, I'd opt for the .358 winnie as components are much cheaper. That includes dies, cases, and reamers.


Matt
FISH!!

Heed the words of Winston Smith in Orwell's 1984:

"Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right."
 
Posts: 3296 | Location: Northern Colorado | Registered: 22 November 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
I agree with ColoradoMatt. There's practicality and then there is the history, nostalgia and romance. I like the history, nostalgia and romance aspect also. A practical alternative to the 9x57 would be either the .358 Winchester or the .35 Whelen. I already own a .35 Whelen and a 9.3x62 so I would really have no need for a 9x57. But, there would just be something sweet about a nice little custom Mauser rifle chambered for the 9x57 Mauser cartridge. Yes, it's madness!!! Cool

-Bob F.
 
Posts: 3485 | Location: Houston, Texas | Registered: 22 February 2001Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by BFaucett:
But, there would just be something sweet about a nice little custom Mauser rifle chambered for the 9x57 Mauser cartridge. Yes, it's madness!!! Cool

-Bob F.

Like this one?
 
Posts: 985 | Registered: 06 February 2005Reply With Quote
Moderator
Picture of Paul H
posted Hide Post
If I was building a short action, I'd go for the 358 win or 350 Rem mag, and in a long action I'd go for the whelen.

If however one has a fine X57 parent mauser, the 9X57 would be a neat round to load. Falling between the 358 win and 35 whelen isn't a bad place to be!


__________________________________________________
The AR series of rounds, ridding the world of 7mm rem mags, one gun at a time.
 
Posts: 7213 | Location: Alaska | Registered: 27 February 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
HP,

No thanks, I'll pass on that one. Too tacky.

-Bob F.
 
Posts: 3485 | Location: Houston, Texas | Registered: 22 February 2001Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by BFaucett:
HP,

No thanks, I'll pass on that one. Too tacky.

-Bob F.

Bob, I am fairly uneducated on custom rifles, but I don't see where the rifle is tacky (other than the tablecloth it is on).

It is certainly not the classic American style, but it looks like it has all the ingredients of a classic German sporter: action panels, DST, small schnabel tip, butterknife bolt handle, RK pistol grip, hex/round barrel, matted full-length rib, drop leaf rear sight, nice oil finish, nice semi matte blue.

Is the German style something you don't like, or is there something actually incorrect about that rifle?

And what is that little metal tab sticking out of the forearm?
 
Posts: 985 | Registered: 06 February 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Tex21
posted Hide Post
Only interested if it comes with the Elvis Stars 'n Bars... animal


Jason

"Chance favors the prepared mind."
 
Posts: 1449 | Location: Dallas, Texas | Registered: 24 February 2004Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
For the record, I think the classic German style is cool and I am not ashamed to say it. Cool
 
Posts: 985 | Registered: 06 February 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
HP,

I have nothing against classic German styling. I just don't like the looks of that particular rifle. Just my personal opinion, nothing more or less. In general, I like the looks of a classic Type A or B Mauser rifle.

Something along these lines:



-Bob F.
 
Posts: 3485 | Location: Houston, Texas | Registered: 22 February 2001Reply With Quote
One of Us
posted Hide Post
I have a handful Mexican mauser actions and I think the 9x57 would be a perfect fit in one.
 
Posts: 49 | Location: California | Registered: 04 January 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
quote:
And what is that little metal tab sticking out of the forearm?


On the under side of the barrel there is a tab with a slot milled into it. A wedge goes thru the forearm side plates and the barrel tab, effectively pinning the barrel to the stock. A very meticulous way of "bedding" the barrel to the forearm. The wedge must be removed for disassembly.

It is a shame that particular rifle has been modified for a cheap scope mount, especially the bolt handle. I'm sure it was much nicer in its original shape, and can probably be restored.
 
Posts: 2036 | Location: Roebling, NJ 08554 | Registered: 20 January 2002Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of z1r
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by BFaucett:
I agree with ColoradoMatt. There's practicality and then there is the history, nostalgia and romance. I like the history, nostalgia and romance aspect also. A practical alternative to the 9x57 would be either the .358 Winchester or the .35 Whelen. I already own a .35 Whelen and a 9.3x62 so I would really have no need for a 9x57. But, there would just be something sweet about a nice little custom Mauser rifle chambered for the 9x57 Mauser cartridge. Yes, it's madness!!! Cool

-Bob F.


I like history too, that's why i have this fine little rifle in 9.3x57:



Since I also have Mausers in 9.3x62, 8x60, 8x57, 7x57, 7.65x53, 6.5x55, and 8x68S. I feel I have enough rifles chambered in "exotic" cartridges thus requiring, for the most part "exotic" thus expensive components. Like I said, if I were building one in .35 caliber I'd opt for the .358 cuz sometimes it's nice to be able to feed the rifle inexpensively. I'd just tell everyone I have a 9x51mm and be done with it.

If I had the chance to pick up a nice "original" 9x57 I would but, I would not build one.




Aut vincere aut mori
 
Posts: 4865 | Location: Lakewood, CO | Registered: 07 February 2002Reply With Quote
  Powered by Social Strata  
 

Accuratereloading.com    The Accurate Reloading Forums    THE ACCURATE RELOADING.COM FORUMS  Hop To Forum Categories  Rifles  Hop To Forums  Medium Bore Rifles    Which has more poop: 358 Win or 9X57?

Copyright December 1997-2023 Accuratereloading.com


Visit our on-line store for AR Memorabilia