https://www.newsday.co.zw/thei...s-community-pushback


Zambia’s cancellation of hunting tender faces community pushback

Business Digest By Emmanuel Koro | 9h ago

Zambia’s ‘Kenyan-style’ moment-of-madness-cancellation of legal international hunting tender was recently denounced ruled as illegal by the country’s high court, creating local hunting communities’ hope that uninterrupted international hunting will return in 2024.

Largely influenced by the animal rights extremist fundraising NGOs who lie that international hunting destroys wildlife populations, some African countries have been fooled and green-washed to ban or restrict international hunting at the expense of wildlife and habitat conservation, including socio-economic development.

Yet, international hunting is supported by the Convention on International Trade In Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora as a scientific wildlife management measure that crops out ageing bulls that are unimportant to wildlife breeding, without decreasing wildlife populations.

Almost nowhere in pro-international hunting and wildlife-rich Southern Africa has a senior government official ever single-handedly cancelled a legal and approved hunting tender as happened in Zambia recently, compromising the wildlife, habitat conservation and life-changing socio-economic benefits supported by international hunting revenue.

Without the powers and mandate to cancel legally agreed international hunting tenders, the permanent secretary of Zambia Ministry of Tourism and Arts, Evans Muhanga recently cancelled legally approved hunts in the Southern African country’s prime 19 hunting blocks.

Negatively impacted by this decision, the Zambia Community Resources Board Association that represents rural hunting communities, teamed up with negatively affected four hunting companies (Mopane Safaris Limited, Kwalata Safaris Limited, MVU Safaris Limited and Ntengu Safaris Limited); calling for the reversal of permanent secretary Muhanga’s illegal decision to cancel the legally approved hunts in Zambia’s 19 prime hunting blocks.

These companies together with the Zambia Community Resources Board Association said that permanent secretary Muhanga’s decision was null and void and breached sections 7,48,54 and 57 of the Zambia Department of National Parks and Wildlife Licencing Committee Act No.14 of 2015 which gives the power to cancel hunting concession agreements to the Wildlife Management Licencing committee.

A Lusaka High Court judge, Sharon Newa, ruled that permanent secretary Muhanga’s 4 May 2022 decision, was illegal because only the procuring entity, which is the Zambia Department of National Parks and Wildlife Licencing Committee has the jurisdiction to cancel hunting concession agreements.

Meanwhile, permanent secretary Muhanga declined to answer media questions e-mailed to him asking whether he acted under the influence of animal rights extremist fundraising NGOs to cancel approved hunts in the country’s 19 prime international hunting areas.

Appointed to be accountable to and serve the interests of the Zambian public, one of the questions that permanent secretary Muhanga also didn’t answer includes this one, “Do you regret your actions to illegally cancel the international hunts as a moment-of-madness?”

Some Zambian citizens used social media platforms such as Facebook to protest against permanent secretary Muhanga’s illegal cancellation of hunts. One of the protestors said that the cancellation of legally approved international hunts in Zambia 19 prime hunting blocks resulted in job losses in hunting communities for trackers, cooks and drivers etc. It also meant the loss of business for safari hunting companies that operate in Zambia’s 19 prime hunting blocks.

Responding to media questions probing the cancellation of the international hunts in Zambia’s 19 prime hunting blocks, the Chairman of Zambia Community Resource Boards who is also a direct beneficiary of international hunting because he attended a South Luangwa school that was renovated using international hunting revenue, Dr Rodgers Lubilo said, “For two years we have had no safari hunting in prime areas in Zambia not because of international hunting ban but our own local politicians.

“The hunting communities took the Government to court and we won the case.

“There was international hunting in some hunting blocks but not too much.

“So we hope next year(2024) full scale hunting can resume.”

Meanwhile, the Zambia Community Resources Board Association, President George Tembo said that the hunting industry did not perform well in Zambia during the 2023 hunting season because “it did not include all the game management areas(GMAs)/ hunting communities.”

“This has limited the potential of the hunting industry for the past two years,” he said. President Tembo said that the Zambia GMAs are wildlife-rich.

“In some of the GMAs where the hunting concession agreements are still running, the communities have benefited socio-economically from the following projects supported by international hunting revenue: the construction of schools, health posts, boreholes, solar pumps, modern technology-driven agricultural projects, police posts houses and offices etc.,” said President Tembo.

He said that other community projects supported by international hunting include poultry, savings groups and livestock farming.

“Our prayer is to have all the Zambian hunting or GMAs operational as soon as

possible before the opening of the 2024 international hunting,” said President Tembo.

With Zambia’s President Hakainde Hichilema’s administration having recently publicly declared that it intends to adopt the ‘Kenyan-style’ anti-international hunting and anti-ivory trade model to boost its tourism industry, it remains to be seen if international hunting will continue in Zambia.

Zambia’s illegal cancellation of legally approved international hunting coincided with the election into power of Zambia’s President Hakainde Hichilema who succeeded pro-international hunting and ivory trade, President Edgar Lungu who worked supportively around such issues together with the presidents of Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe.

A November 2022 article published by Zambia Today cited sources within the

Zambian Government saying, “Kenya’s tourism industry grew exponentially when that country banned hunting.

“The authorities(Zambian Government) will announce a ban on game hunting in preference for the Kenyan model of photographic tourism which the same sources contend rake in more revenue.”

In November 2023 the Kenya Association of Travel Agents and the Travel Agents Association of Zambia(TAAZ) signed a strategic partnership deal to boost growth in their travel industries.

“It signifies a concerted effort to unlock the full potential of our tourism sector,” said Hamida Malik, Chairperson of TAAZ, exclusively focusing on photographic tourism and signalling Zambia’s departure from a wildlife economy growth path that includes the lucrative and life-changing international hunting industry.

Meanwhile, wildlife experts have observed a catastrophic decline in wildlife

population in Kenya, arising from its 1977 international hunting ban. In stark contrast they noted an ongoing increase in wildlife populations of SADC countries, including Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, Zambia and Zimbabwe that have not banned international hunting.

A professor of the US-based University of Florida Centre For African Studies, Brian Child said that since the 1977 hunting ban, Kenya’s wildlife has declined by 60% and “is being replaced by cattle.”

This means that the land that was previously set aside for wildlife conservation is being taken up for cattle production.

“In Southern Africa wildlife has increased by 600%,” said Professor Child, illustrating that where international wildlife hunting is taking place and rural communities are benefiting, it creates incentives for them to conserve wildlife.

Koro is a Johannesburg-based international-award-winning environmental journalist who writes independently on environmental and developmental issues in Africa.

Get it together Zambia!

You are a big black eye in the hunting and conservation community!!

Good God, what a complete goat rope. I’m very glad I hunted Zambia extensively back before any of this tomfoolery.

That said, there was a closure back before I started as well. Think it was for three years?

Waiting on getting my trophy's out. Hopefully soon.

What a goat f&@k. Three weeks before the first show and this is going on .

Yeah, Butch was there last week & he told me it sounded like it will open up again. I guess his contacts know something.......

Tentatively penciled in hippo/croc/buff in September but won't send a deposit. Will talk with Werner at DSC.

quote:

Good God, what a complete goat rope. I’m very glad I hunted Zambia extensively back before any of this tomfoolery.

Amen. A fantastic hunting destination run by easily corrupted fools and and clowns. Think they would learn from Kenya and Botswana but the bribes and pay-offs usually outweigh common-sense for the country as a whole.

Ever met a government official who is NOT taking bribes??

They don’t exist.

In America you call it DONATIONS.

And do the bidding of those giving bigger donations!

NGOs have always been used as uncontrolled bribers.

The CIA has used them in many places!

And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

I had a WhatsApp message from an outfitter friend in Zambia this morning, he says that about 50% of the concessions are still open (including his), he isn’t real optimistic about the closed 50% reopening very soon.

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

Saeed-

When I was in Ivory Camp, in the Okavango Delta, the camp manager told me that some of the photographic people were paying upwards of 2500.00 a day in the Delta. I’m not saying that’s true, but that’s what she said.

quote:

Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

Saeed-

When I was in Ivory Camp, in the Okavango Delta, the camp manager told me that some of the photographic people were paying upwards of 2500.00 a day in the Delta. I’m not saying that’s true, but that’s what she said.

Steve,

The outfit we used for our Galapagos trip charges $15K for a 14 day trip that includes the Okavango.

LINK

Guys,

Only 9 Zambian GMA's were involved in this tender process. This is not something new and has going on for over a year. The court battle that ensued from this has been settled so we are hoping that everybody will be up and running in '24.

Zambia is not going off line for International trophy hunting.

Mark

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

Of course it is.

If thats really where the money was, no country would have sport hunting. They would follow the money, as they all always do.

Anyways, a country can have both. There is no need to ban hunting to have photo tourism.

This will have no effect on privately owned properties I assume?

quote:

Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

Saeed-

When I was in Ivory Camp, in the Okavango Delta, the camp manager told me that some of the photographic people were paying upwards of 2500.00 a day in the Delta. I’m not saying that’s true, but that’s what she said.

No surprise at all. The high end camps in the Delta easily cost over $1500 per person per day. Went there on a photo safari after a Caprivi hunt 4-5 years ago and the prices are eye watering.

quote:

Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
And the idea that photographic safaris bring in more money is just pure bullshit!

Saeed-

When I was in Ivory Camp, in the Okavango Delta, the camp manager told me that some of the photographic people were paying upwards of 2500.00 a day in the Delta. I’m not saying that’s true, but that’s what she said.

Yes, but there are only few areas where a photographic safari company can offer an experience which can make it viable for a business charging such prices. No one will pay a dime to go on a photographic safari in Luano or West Petauke, to name some.

quote:

Originally posted by MARK H. YOUNG:
Guys,

Only 9 Zambian GMA's were involved in this tender process. This is not something new and has going on for over a year. The court battle that ensued from this has been settled so we are hoping that everybody will be up and running in '24.

Zambia is not going off line for International trophy hunting.

Mark

Not going offline, but the big hunting shows in the US are right around the corner, so this issue not being sorted yet, is definitely hurting them. If it gets sorted later though, I bet there will be some really good deals on offer.

Folks,

I've spent 76 days over 3 long safaris in Zambia and hunted or visited 9 different areas there. None of them particularly on the Luangwa would be suitable for photo safaris in my mind. There just isn't enough game in open country to be of interest to high end photo operations. There are photo lodges on the Luangwa but they do their tours in the North or South Luangwa.

Mark

quote:

Originally posted by MARK H. YOUNG:
Folks,

I've spent 76 days over 3 long safaris in Zambia and hunted or visited 9 different areas there. None of them particularly on the Luangwa would be suitable for photo safaris in my mind. There just isn't enough game in open country to be of interest to high end photo operations. There are photo lodges on the Luangwa but they do their tours in the North or South Luangwa.

Mark

Mark-

It’s not rocket science to correlate the closure of GMA’s to international hunters not being confident enough to drop a “big” deposit, that you might fight hard to get back.

IIRC, Chanjuzi is directly across the Luangwa from either South or North Luangwa NP?

If there is adequate game in those parks, the river poses no boundary.

Nothing personal Mark, just seems not a good time to confidently book Zambia. These African governments are so unpredictable, who knows what might happen.

I think you understand how fond of Zambia hunting I am. I want nothing more than a successful, robust, long stretch of hunting.

To add- If I’m an outfitter in one of these area’s, I’m probably not going to attend shows on the if come. Bad for all parties involved.

Merry Christmas,

Steve

quote:

Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:

quote:

Originally posted by MARK H. YOUNG:
Folks,

I've spent 76 days over 3 long safaris in Zambia and hunted or visited 9 different areas there. None of them particularly on the Luangwa would be suitable for photo safaris in my mind. There just isn't enough game in open country to be of interest to high end photo operations. There are photo lodges on the Luangwa but they do their tours in the North or South Luangwa.

Mark

Mark-

It’s not rocket science to correlate the closure of GMA’s to international hunters not being confident enough to drop a “big” deposit, that you might fight hard to get back.

IIRC, Chanjuzi is directly across the Luangwa from either South or North Luangwa NP?

If there is adequate game in those parks, the river poses no boundary.

Nothing personal Mark, just seems not a good time to confidently book Zambia. These African governments are so unpredictable, who knows what might happen.

I think you understand how fond of Zambia hunting I am. I want nothing more than a successful, robust, long stretch of hunting.

To add- If I’m an outfitter in one of these area’s, I’m probably not going to attend shows on the if come. Bad for all parties involved.

Merry Christmas,

Steve

According to the DSC app, there are 9 companies registered that are from Zambia . Only 2 on the SCI app.