The Accurate Reloading Forums
My opinion on Bennelli

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/944100465

03 November 2006, 18:29
Jim Kobe
My opinion on Bennelli
Now, not to really start an argument here, well maybe a little, I think you all know my feeling about these things. I am an O/U guy.

In the last week and a half, I have had three of these "things" in the shop for repair. To a man, all three guys said "...I love my bennelli..." I will stand by my conviction, If you own one, it ain't a matter of "if" it is a matter of "when" it's gonna give you some crap.

I think I will modify the old saying:
"If it's got tires, txts or it's a bennelli, it's gonna give you trouble"


Jim Kobe
10841 Oxborough Ave So
Bloomington MN 55437
952.884.6031
Professional member American Custom Gunmakers Guild

03 November 2006, 18:32
adrook
A buddy has a 20ga Montefeltro that I have shot some. Wasn't all that impressed, I'll stick with my Auto 5.
03 November 2006, 19:22
RogerR
Mr Kobe

What problems do you find? I thought Benelli was one of the better actions. I know the guys that shoot 4 or 5 cases a week (cleaning the boilers at the power station) found the 1100's lasted about 6 months, the Benelli's last about 4 years. They are all ugly as hell, and as with any auto action they need to be cleaned occasionally. They are easy to take down and rinse out(The plastic really builds up shooting at that rate.) The pins don't break and the parts seem to be hardened properly so they wear well. The plastic stocked M1's hold together well, especially with the heavy loads. (I think they use a special industial 3 inch load at 3 3/4 dram ; 1-3/4oz of very soft lead).

Roger
03 November 2006, 20:09
yeti
Boiler cleaning's an appropriate task for a plastic pogo-stick shotgun.
03 November 2006, 20:28
butchloc
shotty guns come in 2 type those with 2 barrels and all the others BOOM clap mgun dancing
04 November 2006, 00:27
JMJ888
quote:
In the last week and a half, I have had three of these "things" in the shop for repair.


Which model? That is kind of like saying I had three Fords in my shop last week but if one was a Pinto then it clarifies a bit.

We exclusively use Benelli M1 Field models in Mexico and have approx 35 in armory. These guns are mostly used as rentals and as long as we clean them every now and again they function well. That is with subpar quality Mexican manufactured ammunition and in hot dusty conditions.

Given the high volume and high temperature shooting the Benelli's have offered the best comprimise between cost and reliability. Brownings are decent but some of the cheaper autos tend to give in to the rigorous shooting.