The Accurate Reloading Forums
Argentine v. Sears FN

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/879108151

03 November 2004, 11:16
ArthurOlds
Argentine v. Sears FN
Ok, for arguements sake, and since it is election day and all, here is a question: you have a nice 1909 Argentine and an equally nice FN (aka Sears 50)...you want to build a .30-06 to go with a .375 Whitworth...a pair to use "on trips," so to speak...Which to choose???? Any reasons??? Thanks for the information....Arthur
03 November 2004, 11:31
z1r
Since you want a pair, the Sears 50 would match the Whitworth cosmetically. They would/could be near twins.

Assuming both actions were equally sound, and that the 1909 was a DWM, I'd pick the 1909. Just my preference.
03 November 2004, 12:06
Marc_Stokeld
1909. For one reason, I very much prefer the thunb slot in the military action.
03 November 2004, 12:12
Customstox
Arthur,
I would pick the 09. Why? Because I have 9 or 10 of them and if I had one FN, right now it would be the only one and I would hate to see it "gone" so to speak. Okay, if I had the 09 pile whittled down to a one on one situation, I would go with the FN, because I like the looks of the action without the thumb slot.
03 November 2004, 12:33
Dago Red
Chic,

I bet they all have gorgeous wood on them too, damn showoff, rubbing my nose in it. Not right, you should send half those 09's to me!

I have two FN's, they are very pretty (although I found out recently one of them is the one with the hole spacing such that I can't get off the shelf bases) but I personally prefer the argentine, I love the way they look, I have a pristine action sitting in the safe waiting for some money and a plan. (meaning some time in the far far distant future.)

Red
03 November 2004, 13:40
Idared
I would pick the FN first also, unless the lack of a c-ring bothered you too much. You really can't go wrong with either.
03 November 2004, 14:18
Customstox
Red,
No the 09's I have are in a drawer and are only actions at present. Just eggs and flour waiting to become a cake, lol.
03 November 2004, 19:33
TC1
My favorite is the 09, but I could be perfectly happy with either.

Terry