25 February 2012, 11:25
montea6bCartridge ID quiz...
See if you can tell by shape and proportion what these two cartridges are:
25 February 2012, 20:05
montea6bquote:
Originally posted by Big Bore Fan:
left: .30-06
right: .50BMG
BINGO! First one out of the chute... I guess that was too easy for this crowd, eh?

I just added the .50BMG to my (cartridge) collection last week and was struck by the similarity in proportion to the .30-06. Here they are relative to one another:
25 February 2012, 20:12
Jerry LilesTry comparing a 40 mm Bofors round with the .22 Hornet. Except for size they are nearly identical.
Jerry Liles
25 February 2012, 21:02
montea6bquote:
Originally posted by Jerry Liles:
Try comparing a 40 mm Bofors round with the .22 Hornet. Except for size they are nearly identical.
Jerry Liles
So what does that say for cartridge "design"? Just find something that works and scale up or down, right? (or neck up/neck down...)

26 February 2012, 03:16
BobsterIf I am not mistaken, you can compare a .222 Rem, 7x57 Mauser, .30-06, and a 50 BMG to get the same result.
27 February 2012, 01:03
kcstottThat was John Brownings style. If it ain't broke don't fix it.
The BMG is case and point.
01 March 2012, 00:34
Big Bore FanBasically, it was easy. the .50 bmg and .30-06 are unmistakable.
Martin