The Accurate Reloading Forums
Subjective question about actions...

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/19810984

14 May 2003, 06:09
bobvthunter
Subjective question about actions...
I realize that this question is somewhat subjective and the answer will be based in far more opinion than fact, but here goes... If you were going to have a "classic" .35 Whelen built what action would you build it on? A .270 is easy, you close you eyes, think .270, and a pre-64 M70 comes to mind (at least mine), but in the same proverbial excercise I can't think of the classic action for the .35 Whelen. The one that comes to mind most frequently, but far from every time, is a 1903 Springfield. What would your classic .35 Whelen look like?

Just to make you think,
Bob
14 May 2003, 06:14
HunterJim
Bob,

Mine is on an M98 Mauser action. It looks "right" especially with the aperture rear and post front sights. [Wink]

jim dodd
14 May 2003, 07:26
Dago Red
Mine is on a 1917, looks just right with the 26" barrel and blond stock. However, the action that comes to mind is the 1903 or an 03a3. In fact, I am keeping my eyes open for a good deal on a sporter 03 or 03a3 to have another one built off of for my stepfather. (he gave me his as I love the 1917's, he prefers 03's so I figure if I find one I will have one built for him).

Red
14 May 2003, 14:04
<whisler>
I like the mauser look, but what action available today would be good for this conversion, a turk?
the Persians? ? ? ? ?

If not a Mauser, then what???
14 May 2003, 14:26
45nut
a classic 35 Whelen would be on a 1895 Winchester.
14 May 2003, 14:27
<Axel>
I think Springfield M1903 with a G&H patterned stock and side mounted QR scope.

Axel
14 May 2003, 14:51
craigster
I have one on a Mauser and one on a Springfield. The Whelen is a classic American cartridge and the Springfield is a classic American rifle. I really like the Springfield. [Cool]
14 May 2003, 15:01
KurtC
I think this says it all. ACGG#18
14 May 2003, 15:24
Idared
There are a few classic cartridge rifles everyone should have. [Smile]

270 Winchester- Definately a pre-64 model 70 Winchester
7X57- Mauser 98. It is permissible to call it a 275 Rigby also. [Big Grin]
30-06- Definately a 1903 Springfield made at the Springfield Armory
35 Whelen- As someone above stated it should be a 1903 Springfield and be patterned after the Griffin & Howe style.

I have one of these done and the other three in transition. It is a great collection. [Wink]

[ 05-14-2003, 06:28: Message edited by: Idared ]
14 May 2003, 16:23
GrandView
Griffin & Howe Springfield........definitely.

Lyman 48 if open sights....G&H sidemount for glass.

The discussion is closed.

[Smile]

GV

Griffin & Howe Springfield
15 May 2003, 01:55
bobvthunter
Idared,

That's my dream rifle collection! I'm working on aquiring the actions to have the rifles built. And if I ever decide to quit being a proffessional student and enter the real world someday I might have the money to have the guns built!

.270 - built on a pre-64 M70
7x57 - built on a M98 Mauser or derivative thereof
.30-06 - I'm leaning toward pre-64 M70 with this one too, although the 1903 would be appropriate as well (perhaps more so)
.35 Whelen - I'm leaning toward the 1903 for this one, but obviously haven't made up my mind since I posed the question

The only thing I will add is a Savage 99 in .300 Savage. I'll keep this one original. It'll be a nice rifle for these northeastern woods. The others listed above will cover anything else I have a desire to hunt.

Now that's my idea of a classic rifle collection!

This has been fun and interesting. Keep 'em coming!

Bob
15 May 2003, 02:39
Borealis Bob
I had one built over the winter on an FN '98 action. Turned out very well.
15 May 2003, 03:14
54JNoll
For me a 35 Whelen would be on the Springfield 1903 action.

Funny thing is ...

That is exactly what I am having built.

Double heat treated Springfield 03 with a Lothar Walther barrel in 35 Whelen. Jack is doing the metal work and Chic is going to do the stock work.
[Big Grin] [Big Grin]
15 May 2003, 05:16
TSAS
Axel's got it right...
15 May 2003, 06:04
<eldeguello>
Bob, I believe you ar right. The 1903 Springfield! That's exactly what COL Whelen would have built!!

[ 05-14-2003, 21:05: Message edited by: eldeguello ]
15 May 2003, 12:16
Dago Red
Would somebody post pictures of the Griffin and Howe design stock? I don't know as much about all of this as I would like to.

thanks

Red
16 May 2003, 03:22
<the-moleman>
There's a really nice G & H Springfield in .30/06 over on Gunsamerica:

http://www.gunsamerica.com/guns/976306042.htm

Shows the shape of the cheekpiece pretty good and a Leupold 3X in the sidemount. Classic.

Kurt
16 May 2003, 04:07
GrandView
quote:
Originally posted by Dago Red:
Would somebody post pictures of the Griffin and Howe design stock?

I posted a link in my previous post in this thread, Red.

Here's another....

http://www.griffinhowe.com/gunpics/ACF146.jpg

These are both earlier G&H stock versions than the link moleman posted.

GV
16 May 2003, 05:58
<eldeguello>
Excellent pictures...
16 May 2003, 22:59
Stu C
With everyone throwing in their classic action/cartridge combinations I thought I'd throw in mine - .222 on a Sako L 41. Just as classic as the Whelan on a Sprinfield '03.
19 May 2003, 04:40
Dan@Montana Rifle Co
Bobvthunter, I may be biased [Smile] but I think you should start out with a Model 1999 Montana Action. Solid action, modern design and stocks are readily available [Smile] You can check them out by going to www.montanarifleman.com

[ 05-18-2003, 19:44: Message edited by: Dan@Montana Rifle Co ]