THE ACCURATERELOADING.COM BIG BORE FORUMS


Moderators: jeffeosso
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
Scout pattern DGR? Login/Join
 
one of us
posted
I'm curious if any of you with african experience have tried the scout scope idea on your big bores. I have been using a 2X on my deer rifle for many years and am very happy with it, so am considering the same for my 458 Lott project. Any disadvantages? I know Art Alphin had this as an option on his A-Square rifle but don't know how popular it was.
What do you think?
 
Posts: 25 | Location: Detroit,MI | Registered: 30 January 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
I have used the scout scope system but not on a DGR. Mine is on a Garand "Tanker". The scout scope system does not work for ME as I am right handed/shouldered and left eye dominate. Thus I must close my left eye to see through the scope with my right eye, which negates the advantages of the scout scope. So for me it is not an advantage, but does allow for a scope on a Garand. However for a person without MY eye situation the scout scope is a great idea for a DGR. When I left shoulder the rifle with a scout scope I can see the advantages it offers.[I tried to get an eye sugeron to switch my eyes but he refused. ] For those who haven't tried it do not knock it. PS this is where the idea came from for red dot sights, not only on rifles but on IPSC pistols. All the winners in IPSC use some type of "optical" sight.
On a DGR the scout scope can not hit you in the face.
Plus it does not interfear with ejection or reloading of the rifle. If you have hunted with it and like it I see no reason not to use in on your DGR, as long as recoil does not break the scope. I would use QD mounts for the scope, on my Garand I used the Leupold mounts with the posts on the rings and the levers in the base, they are very strong. I would have quality iron sights installed and zeroed of course. For DGR I MUCH prefer a wide V over anything else. Im no stranger to peep sights [Service Rifle and Palma competion] but for DG I will take the wide V every time.
 
Posts: 16134 | Location: Texas | Registered: 06 April 2002Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Andre Mertens
posted Hide Post
This one may be suitable.

WWII K98 + 21" Delcour bbl. in 9,3x62 + Butler Creek stock and Ching sling + Leupold 2X EER in sunk in Burris mount. I use it for drive hunting in foul weather when I'm reluctant to expose my 9,3x74R O/U.
 
Posts: 2420 | Location: Belgium | Registered: 25 August 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of HunterJim
posted Hide Post
Eric and I have indeed agreed to disagree on this one.

I have been doing a lot of whitetail deer hunting in Canada, and bush veld hunting in Africa with my scout. My experiences have convinced me that for my hunting the conventional mount works better. Your mileage will vary with your hunting style.

Africa usually has plenty of light for shooting except for things like leopard after dark.

By the way my .450 Ackley was an A-Square model.

jim
 
Posts: 4166 | Location: San Diego, CA USA | Registered: 14 November 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of HunterJim
posted Hide Post
LocalHand,

I have had two such rifles: a .416 Rem Mag and a .450 Ackley Mag. I also have used the Steyr Scout extensively hunting, and another .308 Win scout. The two big bore "scouts" are sold, and the Steyr Scout I now use with a low-power variable mounted in conventional position (a more general purpose rig I have found).

I also did two rifle courses at Gunsite, the first under the legendary Jeff Cooper himself. I was a devotee of the scout scope for general hunting use, but I am not anymore.

The big bore rifles had ghost ring rear sights and post front sights, and I had QR mounts for the scout scopes. This configuration will work until you hit the physical limits of the scope mounting or the scope itself. The forward mount scope is vulnerable to light from behind you, I suggest a big hat at least to shade the lens. The typical long eye relief scopes don't have the optical performance for dark targets in shadows, say like a Cape buff. I don't know a cure for this, except more scope closer to the eye.

If you limit your use to middle of the day in strong light you will not observe these effects.

jim dodd
 
Posts: 4166 | Location: San Diego, CA USA | Registered: 14 November 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of BigBullet
posted Hide Post
LocalHand,

I beleive it was A-Square that made some rifles specifically for this pattern. They were DGR built on an improved Enfield action, some were fairly large bore. (like .500" and better) They did not seem to catch on very well and had some bad press due to light gathering, and field of view type deficencies.

BigBullet
 
Posts: 1224 | Location: Lorraine, NY New York's little piece of frozen tundra | Registered: 05 July 2003Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Slingster
posted Hide Post
Quote:

I also did two rifle courses at Gunsite, the first under the legendary Jeff Cooper himself. I was a devotee of the scout scope for general hunting use, but I am not anymore.






Jim and I have similar pedigrees training-wise, and we respectfully disagree about the Scout Scope. I've not had the problem with behind-the-head lighting that he described, but nevertheless I admit that it is an issue with the forward scope mount. I see the controversy as one of differing trade-offs by different users with different preferences. I'm willing to accept the deficits of the Scout Scope in order to gain its advantages, whereas Jim's calculus tips him to the other conclusion. Different strokes for different folks; neither is wrong, and each is right for his particular set of trade-offs.



Having said all that, while I've not used a Scout Scope on a heavy, I do have the .308 and .376 Steyr Scouts and a Clifton custom Scout, plus a number of "demo" guns for my Ching Ring Scout Scope mount. I'm also thinking of putting a Scout Scope on my Marlin Guide Gun. I've taken game in bright sunlight and in near-darkness with my Steyr Scouts.



I've long thought that a 1 to 1.5X Scout Scope with a German post reticle makes sense on a DGR (with suitable iron sight backups, of course), and one of my "someday" projects is to make up a .458 WM "Heavy Scout" to try the concept.
 
Posts: 1079 | Location: San Francisco Bay Area | Registered: 26 May 2002Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Thanks to all of you for your insights. Just what I was hoping for. I've not had the low light problems hunting in MI, but the backlight is something I will have to investigate (not alot of bright sunshine in november deer woods).
Eric, your sling has interested me for some time. I 've used the center mounted swivel on several rifles for years and you seem to have eliminated the the only downside to its use. Whose nylon model do you recomend? Or are you producing your own?
 
Posts: 25 | Location: Detroit,MI | Registered: 30 January 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Slingster
posted Hide Post
Quote:

Eric, your sling has interested me for some time. I 've used the center mounted swivel on several rifles for years and you seem to have eliminated the the only downside to its use. Whose nylon model do you recomend? Or are you producing your own?




I've only approved the nylon Ching Sling from The Wilderness in Phoenix, AZ. It's serviceable, but to be honest, leather works better because it has more body and drape. For that you have the choice of Galco or Langlois Rifleleather.

The Safari Ching Sling is only made by Galco.
 
Posts: 1079 | Location: San Francisco Bay Area | Registered: 26 May 2002Reply With Quote
  Powered by Social Strata  
 


Copyright December 1997-2023 Accuratereloading.com


Visit our on-line store for AR Memorabilia