quote:Originally posted by onefunzr2:
..Rooger...Rooger
quote:Originally posted by gumboot458:.quote:Originally posted by Big Bore Boar Hunter:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by GS:
Velocity would be close, but probably not better. The 458 will usually take a 24" barrel to get close whereas the 416 ruger makes do with a 20". The 458 is also a standard action,
The 400 gr 416 bullet has a higher sectional density than the 400gr 458, making it a better choice for critters that need full length perforation.
Nothing wrong with the 458 though; however, for DG and the like, I would stick with a 450 gr or above. A 480 gr bullet would still be pretty magical for a stopping round.
Sometimes there are hard and fast rules, sometimes guidelines, and more often than not, personal preference.
John
.
.
. Now I,m not picking on you John .. But the 400 gr .416 bullet @ 2400 fps is NOT preferable to a 400 gr .458 bullet @ 2400 fps .......... Not only do some 400 gr .458 bullets expand to around an inch diameter . but they penetrate like crazy .............
. I have shot LOTS of 400 gr bullets in the .458 Win and Lott . and they are absolute killing machines ..my 458 has a 19.5 " barrel and with book loads I get 2400 fps .....................
Since Barnes dropped the 400 gr X bullet from their line of X and TSX bullets . The best ( probably was to start with )option is the 400 gr GS HV bullet , and the North Fork ... For heavy game .... If I was going to Africa to hunt Cape Buffalo my 458 with 400 gr bullets would be my prefered bullet ..... However actually there would be 300 gr Xs in my rifle , just to see if in fact Cape Buffalo arn,t elephants ........ Since people say the 9.3x62 works on C.B. and my 300 gr .458 loads penetrate as deep or deeper . I think I'de be in the chips ..............
quote:Originally posted by CAelknuts:quote:Originally posted by gumboot458:.quote:Originally posted by Big Bore Boar Hunter:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by GS:
Velocity would be close, but probably not better. The 458 will usually take a 24" barrel to get close whereas the 416 ruger makes do with a 20". The 458 is also a standard action,
The 400 gr 416 bullet has a higher sectional density than the 400gr 458, making it a better choice for critters that need full length perforation.
Nothing wrong with the 458 though; however, for DG and the like, I would stick with a 450 gr or above. A 480 gr bullet would still be pretty magical for a stopping round.
Sometimes there are hard and fast rules, sometimes guidelines, and more often than not, personal preference.
John
.
.
. Now I,m not picking on you John .. But the 400 gr .416 bullet @ 2400 fps is NOT preferable to a 400 gr .458 bullet @ 2400 fps .......... Not only do some 400 gr .458 bullets expand to around an inch diameter . but they penetrate like crazy .............
. I have shot LOTS of 400 gr bullets in the .458 Win and Lott . and they are absolute killing machines ..my 458 has a 19.5 " barrel and with book loads I get 2400 fps .....................
Since Barnes dropped the 400 gr X bullet from their line of X and TSX bullets . The best ( probably was to start with )option is the 400 gr GS HV bullet , and the North Fork ... For heavy game .... If I was going to Africa to hunt Cape Buffalo my 458 with 400 gr bullets would be my prefered bullet ..... However actually there would be 300 gr Xs in my rifle , just to see if in fact Cape Buffalo arn,t elephants ........ Since people say the 9.3x62 works on C.B. and my 300 gr .458 loads penetrate as deep or deeper . I think I'de be in the chips ..............
Since you guys want to compare 400 grain bullets and which penetrates better, I'll throw in my personal preference, for whatever my .02 is worth. I wouldn't prefer either, I'll stick with my .416 Hoffman that gives me 2505 fps using a 400 gr. Trohpy Bonded Bearclaw or Sledgehammer Solid. THAT is a penetrating round, and as Jack Carter (founder of TBB) once told me, 'it's one hell of a killing machine.'