Go | New | Find | Notify | Tools | Reply |
One of Us |
Here's one response in regards to a lion bullet choice. Harry Selby; When my .416 Rigby was away in London to be rebarrelled it took a long two years to get bach to Botswaa as it had to travel through South Africa and politics came into play. In its absence I used a Win Model 70 .458 and as long as the ammo was absolutely fresh ad had not been lying around in the sun I had no complaints. I found that an excellent load for lion was the TBBC 400 gr. semi spitzer. The petals opened up very well creating a very large wound and the 400 grainer increasrd to velocity to close to .416 Rigby Cheers and Good luck. http://forums.accuratereloadin...121093211#6121093211 Roger ___________________________ I'm a trophy hunter - until something better comes along. *we band of 45-70ers* | |||
|
One of Us |
I thought I might have to repost this. This is an email Harry asked me to post for him back in 2010 in regards to some questions from the gallery. This is pasted as it came to me. Harry Selby: "I did err is stating that the accident to the .470 happened in 1950/51.... just a slip up... after all we are talking about sixty years ago.... it should have read 1949/50 I think. I took Bob and Harriet Maytag and Bob and Ginny Ruark in 1951....using the Rigby .416. In the latter part of that year I went to the States and eventually Kodiak Island where I shot a Kodiak bear. Rigby was in no way to blame for the delay in getting the .416 Rigby back to me.... they accomplished the job... rebarreling (barrel from Austria) and a complete stock refurbish in good time. (by that time there was no blueing left on the metalparts and the stock finish was all gone) (See Pic of three Selby Rifles) When Rigby's tried to ship the rifle back to me a woman in the government department responsible to imports / exports blankly refused to issue an export permit as the rifle would pass through South Africa and there was an embargo on all arms to SA at that time... Telling her that it was destined for Botswana cut no ice (I am sure she was just plain 'Anti Hunting') (I even produced a letter from the Botswana police to the effect that the rifle was registered in Botswana.... no luck) Eventually Paul Roberts went over her head to the minister and got the export permit sorted out. It did not take three years as has been claimed.. I am not left handed... I do everything right handed except that I shoot from my left shoulder...maybe my left eye is the 'master eye'. Cycling the bolt was no big deal, I merely lowered the stock slightly, gripping the pistol grip with my left hand and with my right hand worked the bolt.... fast enough... in any case I prefer one or two precisely aimed shot to a fusilade of random rapid fire I have always thought of the magazine held four cartridges... maybe my memory played tricks on me!!! but when Rigby did the work on the rifle they replaced the original magazine follower which was much shorter than the box with a full length one....It was more robust and heavier as well...I think it came from a Brno 602 action.... maybe this prevented Layne Simpson closing the bolt over four cartridges. Maybe I also realised this when the rifle came back from Rigby' but have forgotten about it. I will refer this to a gunsmith friend of mine for his opinion. The inscription on the mag. plate was done by Rigby at that time of re-barreling and the date 1949 was either the date the rifle was despatched or perhaps the date it was entered on my Firearms Certificate in Nairobi. I seem to recollect that Paul Roberts said he would use the date it left Rigby's. The .458 did me well enough but to even suggest that I had become attached to it and sold the Rigby .416 as a result is laughable... it is like comparing chalk and cheese. I sold the Rigby .416 as I was approaching the time I would plan to retire and the Rigby was offered a very good home by a client and his wife with whom I had been on safari a number of times and had become close personal friends. I preferred to do it that way rather than have the possibility of the rifle winding up under some auctioneer's hammer one day!!!! I have done the same with some of my other rifles.... sold them to old clients who have become close friends over the years. Movement of firearms is becoming more restrictive in most parts of Africa and I preferred to see my precious rifles in good homes elsewhere. It took a whole year to get an 'in-transit permit' for another rifle of mine to pass through South Africa a while back.(less than 12 hours in SA) If I remember correctly the rifle was sent to Rigby's sometime in the early eighty's and I immediately began using the Rigby as soon as it came back. One of the safaris I did with it was John Wootters '.416 Safari' in 1987.. John Wootters, Jack Carter (of Trophy Bonded bullets) and Paul Roberts of Rigby's were testing Jack's TB ammo. on Buffalo. We had in camp two Rigby .416s... Pauls's and mine. one .416 Hoffman (Jack's) and John Wootters' .416 Taylor. (Petersen's Hunting August 1988 by Wootters.) I also took the Rigby to Tanzania ( Maswa, Moiowase, Ugalla, Monduli) for a four week safari with TGTS later (I forget the year ) and due to the chaotic customs handling of rifles at the Nairobi Airport lost it for over a month...eventually it turned up in Maun ...intact.... fortunately. Incidentally as soon as.416 bullets became available I had no further ammo worries.... I was getting fairly low until that happened though. By turning the belts off ..460 and .378 Weatherby cases, resizing them carefully and then fire forming. ....they worked well enough. When factory loaded Rigby 416 ammo became available I usually chose Federal although I used mainly hand loads. Remember a PH does not use a lot of ammo.... hopefully..... so a couple of boxes lasted a while. I just like the feel of a broad trigger and by adding the shoe suited me well.. I did the same to some of my other rifles. I never used a sling. it can get one entangled in the bush. I carry a rifle over my right shoulder gripping the barrel in my right hand. I estimate that over a fifty five year career I have used .470s for four years and a .458 for maybe six to eight years. The Rigby .416 was always my weapon of choice and if I was to start a hunting career all over again the first rifle I would acquire would be a Rigby .416. P.S. Layne Simpson's article described the rifle well but it contained many inaccuracies which I am sure did not originate with Joe Coogan... he would have known better. I did not start my career with Ker & Downey Safaris. I started with Percival and 'African Guides" Donald Ker was using a Dodge Power Wagon not a Land Rover when he ran over my .470. I did not rush back to Nairobi for another rifle, the safari was just about over anyway and on its way back to Nairobi. Gunbearer Kidogo was recommended to Ruark not by Hemingway but by an American by the name of Russel Aitkin who had hunted with Frank Bowman. Layne also claimed that I never used the rifle again after its return to Botswana NOT SO I used it for a number of years. He mentions the bluing worn off the barrel.....that wear took place after it came back to Botswana chasing buffalo and tracking lions. P.P.S. To conclude I might mention that after I had used to Rigby .416 for a couple of years and came to appreciate its qualities I decided to do something about the dimensions of the stock to suit my desire for a very powerful but handy rifle for my purpose as a professional hunter. To me the stock was a bit bulky, especially in the forend area and pistol grip (I really like a slender pistol grip). Being handy with tools I very carefully shaved the stock down in the areas I considered 'bulky' until I came up with what I considered just right for me. The recoil was lively but I could not give a fig about that... I wanted a very powerful rifle I could swing like a twenty gauge. So infact the stock dimensions of this rifle probably differ from any rifles coming direct from the Rigby shop. Naturally all chequering was removed and not having the skill or the tools to re-chequer I merely gave the carefully sanded and filled surface a good oil finish The stock remained thus for a number of years ... (see pic of Selbys rifles on safari) until I moved south and an excellent gunsmith in South Africa rechequered the stock for me. When Rigby worked on the rifle, they cleaned up the chequering again and worked on the overall stock finish in addition to a complete re-bluing job. I apologise for the rather lengthy response hopefully covering all queries.... in-fact I feel rather like a baboon being debugged by the rest of the troop." | |||
|
One of Us |
I remember when this was first posted _____________________________________________________ A 9mm may expand to a larger diameter, but a 45 ain't going to shrink Men occasionally stumble over the truth, but most of them pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing had happened. - Winston Churchill | |||
|
one of us |
Bullet placement is far more critical than ballistics performance. Loved the last line on the quoted post. Kudos to Phil. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ColdBore 1.0 - the ballistics/reloading software solution http://www.patagoniaballistics.com | |||
|
One of Us |
Well I think that article by Selby pretty well says it all. The 458 was only a stop gap while his 416 was in transit back to him after rebarreling, he found the 458 only okay if using fresh ammo that had not lain around in the sun for any length of time and if starting his career over again he would go for the 416 Rigby straight up. Selby also says in an another article that "In time I abandoned carrying soft nose bullets for the .416, for the ones available from Kynoch tended to breakup. The only possible use for a soft-nose bullet would be lion, and I found that the.416 rolled lions over with a solid pretty well anyway". Now this is, all from an "expert". I don't think Selby is a good example to use in support of the 458 Win Mag | |||
|
one of us |
Push come to shove Harry preferred the 375 to any other caliber, for one thing, the lack of recoil, and he was a good shot..He told me that more than a few times..as have many well known PHs..Most used them for their personal hunting, but they used a back up big bore for guiding clients..another fact not fiction.. The bottom line if one can shoot and uses properly constructed bullets and places the shot properly all ends well, the same thing applies to the 600 N,E. Ray Atkinson Atkinson Hunting Adventures 10 Ward Lane, Filer, Idaho, 83328 208-731-4120 rayatkinsonhunting@gmail.com | |||
|
One of Us |
There are two kinds of gun experts: 1st expert does it... 2nd expert writes about it! _____________________ Steve Traxson | |||
|
one of us |
A third type of expert is the most common and is the one who's friend heard about someone who read about the subject and told him. He is also happens to be the most knowledgeable "gun expert" in his neck of the woods ! Anyone who claims the 30-06 is ineffective has either not tried one, or is unwittingly commenting on their own marksmanship Phil Shoemaker Alaska Master guide FAA Master pilot NRA Benefactor www.grizzlyskinsofalaska.com | |||
|
One of Us |
Shortly after the 458 was released I remember some issues about the powder not properly burning, resulting in lower velocities. I think the cause was a combination of sustained high temperatures (as in Africa) and the fact that the powder was compressed. This ring a bell with anyone? Of course, many "experts" have never forgotten this even though with current powder technology it's a non-issue. Also when the 458 was first announced some people were pissed at Winchester for not just releasing the full length version (ie, the 450 Watts). At that time "short" was "in" for Winchester and that may have influenced their decision. I think these same people have just never forgiven Winchester. 500 grain 45 caliber bullets at 2,000 ft/sec have worked since the 450 Nitro appeared in 1898. So unless Jurassic Park becomes a reality that standard is not going to change. BTW I admit to not being an expert. | |||
|
One of Us |
I don't think you can categorize all experts into two kinds, many genuine gun experts are one and the same who both did it and wrote about it. A few spring to mind, Jack O'Connor, Elmer Keith, Pondoro Taylor, JA Hunter, et al. Frustratingly some do it but won't write about it and of course that is entirely their prerogative but we are the poorer for it. Harry Selby springs to mind. | |||
|
Powered by Social Strata | Page 1 2 |
Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
Visit our on-line store for AR Memorabilia