"Which Muzzleloader?"

A Henry Ball Limited Edition Savage ML 10 II. Stainless w/ a Laminated stock.

"Why?"

Because it is simply the strongest Muzzleloader on the market, You can shoot smokeless or Black Powder, it is one of the most accurate MLs out (Shoots sub MOA groups), and it is a pretty good looking rifle.

Good Luck!

Reloader

If you werent worried about money which muzzle loader would you buy and why?

I was going to say the original Edward Marshall rifle but I'd want a shooter, so put me down for something completely handmade - hand forged lock, welded iron barrel, and all - by the likes of Eric Kettenburg http://www.firelocks.com/page2.html

a h&h 4 bore breech loader designed to shoot conical style bullets of at least 1600 grains

and a matching 10 bore to go with it shooting a 1100 grain conical

but i have a 700 nitro so it really dosnt matter i have all the fire power id ever want

I'm totally with Reloader on this.

"A Henry Ball Limited Edition Savage ML 10 II. Stainless w/ a Laminated stock." I would also have a Bushnell Elite 4200
4-12AO and add the same touches I put into mine, a Simms
recoil pad and mercury recoil reducer. Just DO NOT like to
be punished the way some of you apparently do!

Either I've got no taste or I'm easy to please. I have a Lyman Plains rifle in .54 caplock and I'm happy with it. I figure if I can punch holes in a 3 lb. coffee can @ 100 yds.(on the bench, mind you), that suits me jes' fine.