I will say it. I said it when he wrote his Dobbs opinion directly contradicting his position at confirmation.

This man and anyone like him has no business being a Federal Court of Appeals Judge nor Supreme Court Justice.

https://amp.kansascity.com/new...rticle285747461.html

quote:

Originally posted by LHeym500:
I will say it. I said it when he wrote his Dobbs opinion directly contradicting his position at confirmation.

This man and anyone like him has no business being a Federal Court of Appeals Judge nor Supreme Court Justice.

https://amp.kansascity.com/new...rticle285747461.html

Remember when Supreme Court Justices didn't solicit cases so they could play their pre-determined opinion card?

You need to go read his dissent in the Admissions, socio-economics in college admissions case.

The man is exactly what the Left says about the Right. A scared, angry white guy afraid of power not resting in his class.

Bush appointment. What would you expect?

I expected him to apply Stare Decisis as he lead the Senate to believe in confirmation.

If he had said in confirmation what he wrote, he would not have been confirmed.

Likewise, his policy that Roe had unintended consequences is insulting to all the women living with Dobbs unintended consequences which are worse.

quote:

Originally posted by LHeym500:
I expected him to apply Stare Decisis as he lead the Senate to believe in confirmation.

If he had said in confirmation what he wrote, he would not have been confirmed.

Likewise, his policy that Roe had unintended consequences is insulting to all the women living with Dobbs unintended consequences which are worse.

Just like Goresuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett.

If you lie to get a job working the window at McDonald's you get fired when they find out.

We have lower standards for the Supreme Court.

quote:

Justice Alito:
“In this case, the court below reasoned that a person who still holds traditional religious views on questions of sexual morality is presumptively unfit to serve on a jury in a case involving a party who is a lesbian,” Alito wrote, referring to the Missouri appeals court.

“That holding exemplifies the danger that I anticipated in Obergefell v. Hodges … namely, that Americans who do not hide their adherence to traditional religious beliefs about homosexual conduct will be ‘labeled as bigots and treated as such’ by the government.”

Well said Justice Alito!

The country was not wrong the first 225 years. Society was not incorrect the millennia preceding Obergefell. And Joshua likes to cite precedence.

Yes it was. Just like it was wrong for 200 years w slavery and 100 years of segregation.

You and Justice Alito can go straddle a Billie goat.

He misled the Senate in Confirmation. Point blank and unequivocally he did so.

He needs to be impeached.

He strongly inferred Stare Decisis applied to Plan Parenthood v Casey.

Confirmation is the only voice and interview we the people get in this process.

He should be impeached.

Some other things we did not do for 200 plus years (one closer to 300 years):

We did not apply the Bill of Rights as rights states had to recognize.

We did not recognize the 2nd Amendment as a personal right that states had to reconsider. For over 200 years we did the exact opposite. Even Justice Scalia never said that in McDonald. He said the right to self defense was a fundamental right that required incorporating the 2nd.

Your argument that 200 plus years means anything has no barring.

Since the 60s, the Court has created the Fundamental Right.

I am not going to take lectures on morality from a men of your moral standing.

You cannot articulate a legitimate state interstate in restricting marriage between 2 consenting adults. Other than the Bible says so. Well, the New Testament does not reinforce the prohibition.

In addition, thank God, my Sunday School Teacher said so is insufficient.

The facts of the case the majority rejected exist outside of marriage equality.

It is really a safe work place environment fact pattern.

Well one thing we have clearly established is that precedence carries little weight with you.

Alito’s statement above is spot on. The left has advanced the norm to be abnormal and the morally weak buy into it.

The world was not wrong for the millennia preceding Obergefell.

quote:

Well, the New Testament does not reinforce the prohibition.

Do not think that I came to destroy the Law of Moses or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill.

Get government out of marriage, stop preferential treatment of married people and childbearing and the problem goes away.

As long as taxpayers are forced to subsidize it they deserve a voice in it.

quote:

Originally posted by Jefffive:
Get government out of marriage, stop preferential treatment of married people and childbearing and the problem goes away.

As long as taxpayers are forced to subsidize it they deserve a voice in it.

I can go along with the of as written.

quote:

Originally posted by ledvm:
Well one thing we have clearly established is that precedence carries little weight with you.

Alito’s statement above is spot on. The left has advanced the norm to be abnormal and the morally weak buy into it.

Hear! Hear!


.

quote:

Originally posted by ledvm:

quote:

Originally posted by Jefffive:
Get government out of marriage, stop preferential treatment of married people and childbearing and the problem goes away.

As long as taxpayers are forced to subsidize it they deserve a voice in it.

I can go along with the of as written.

I agree wholeheartedly. As written.

Some other things we allowed in the past:

1 Black Code Laws (made folks slaves on all but name) and

2 allowing President’s to ignore the S. Ct., and remove whole groups of people. That was what happened to the Cherokee under the Indian Removal Act. The Cherokee took the matter to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court ruled the Cherokee could not be removed. President Jackson took pride in ignoring the holding.