one of us
| never hunted moose yet. how about the 220 grain loads? |
| Posts: 310 | Location: middle tennesse | Registered: 05 February 2003 |
IP
|
|
one of us
| I haven't hunted Moose, yet, but I did use the 180gr Federal High Energy Trophy Bonded Bear Claws in my 30-06 last year in Africa and will use them again this year. I highly recommend them. |
| Posts: 1739 | Location: alabama | Registered: 13 November 2001 |
IP
|
|
one of us
| Federal Premium 180 to 200-grain Nosler is all you need. If you want more power you could always use Federal HE in the same bullet weight. |
| |
one of us
| Quote:
I shot a big 10 year old moose a couple of years ago with said ammo. I plunked him 4 times in the shoulder and two bullets exited the off shoulder. He was dead on the first shot, but refused to think so. I kept the lead flying for fear of losing him in the fading light and thick brush.
Like I said of the Trophy Bonded, "they may be fine, but there is also the chance for under-expansion on a broadside lung shot, which will leave you tracking your moose through places you'd just as soon not go". Flinch's real life experience illustrates my concern. But if he's happy with this TB's, then more power to him. |
| Posts: 13274 | Location: Henly, TX, USA | Registered: 04 April 2001 |
IP
|
|
new member
| ToneCreek, the exit holes were quarter sized. The other two bullets were found against the off side hide. Both shoulders were smashed. The lungs, and heart were total mush. All four shots took place in less than half a minute. The bull dropped on the first shot, but got back up. He was deader than dead on his feet, but I always pour the lead on until no sign of life are left in the critter. No back slapping and hand shakes take place until critter is dead and several minutes elapse. Of the 40 big game kills with said bullet, none have even remotely made me unhappy. Even antelope and small white tail crumple with big exit holes. Moose seldom crumple, even when hit with big bores in my experience. They are an interesting critter. Flinch |
| |
one of us
| Stonecreek: A bear guide I hunted with for years in Ontario (Nipissing district) used a 303 on moose regularly and said he never had a problem. I knew he was a liar, of course, even as I always enjoyed his wife's sausage made from moose and bear. |
| |
One of Us
| I was lucky last year and got a permit in the Maine lottery. I used my Remington 700 BDL 30-06 (which is going on a plains game hunt in RSA in August!) with Winchester 165 failsafe. They were recommended by an elk hunting friend. I dropped my 50", 850lb bull at 230 yards and he did not get up. I hit him just below the "hump" and shattered his spine. I was not able to recover that bullet but I recovered my �finishing� bullet (heart shot from 15 ft). It was a perfect mushroom at the top, while retaining almost all its weight. I found them to be more than sufficient for a decent size eastern moose. Cheers |
| Posts: 251 | Location: Central Massachusetts | Registered: 02 June 2004 |
IP
|
|
one of us
| I use 150 grainers in 30-06-- most don't agree. The moose I shot and the moose my wife shot didnt argue. Many that disagree would use a .270 though. None of the moose I saw taken seemed hard to kill,and that was the common report I got from folks that had hunted them for years. The rag mags all tell a different story though. |
| Posts: 1289 | Location: San Angelo,Tx | Registered: 22 August 2003 |
IP
|
|
one of us
| The moose I shot was with a remington 180 gr. corelock. It stood there for like a long second then its legs wobbled and down it went, stone dead. Yup, a $11 box of shells. I hit it right in the crease of the shoulder and it went right thru. Two of the other 3 guys I was with had almost exactly the same experience=1 shot 30-06 rem corelocks... |
| Posts: 318 | Location: People's Republic of New York | Registered: 10 April 2004 |
IP
|
|
new member
| I shot another one at 30 yards with a 165 grain ballistic tip from a .30-06. I shot it tight behind the shoulder and thought I missed. It didn't move and was too close to see anything happen in the scope. I quickly chambered another round and fired at the same spot again. It still just stood there. I chambered a 3rd round and was getting ready to hit the switch again, when the bull fell over like a slow motion tree. I found one bullet against the off side hide perfectly mushroomed. The entrance hole was quarter sized and you could put a tennis ball through the hole in the lungs. That bull never even so much as twitched. Not enough gun or bullet????? Hardly, but totally different reaction from the Trophy Bonded bullet bull. He was dancing around trying to get away, but didn't want to leave his two cows. Flinch |
| |