The Accurate Reloading Forums
Humour me, score this "elk"!
06 March 2016, 14:02
EXPRESSHumour me, score this "elk"!
I just got around to putting a tape on this Romanian mountain red stag. The basic measurements are 43" beams 50" spread, and 19" brow.
Just out of curiosity, if he was an elk, what class of B&C would that put him in?
06 March 2016, 15:56
p dog shooterBig enough to shoot.
06 March 2016, 18:08
Snellstrom310
Always tough to tell from a single picture.
You should just finish measuring him if you have the tape out.
06 March 2016, 18:14
Rsm458LottLow 300s
It's always so quiet when the goldfish die.(Bror Blixen)
DRSS
Merkel 470 NE
06 March 2016, 18:54
EXPRESS
06 March 2016, 20:05
COYOTE HUNTERI would say that bull would score just over 350" gross with his extras.
The second pic is odd. The top end of his right beam seems to disappear?
06 March 2016, 20:55
WebsterGreat looking stag, what did he weigh, 8 to 9 kilos ?
06 March 2016, 21:07
EXPRESSactually 12.1 green. Will probably be 11
You can easily score it yourself. Here is where you can download the chart with instructions.
https://www.boone-crockett.org...s.asp?area=bgRecords07 March 2016, 04:34
Skip NantzI'll say 346"...nice bull, crowns like a stag!
Skip Nantz
07 March 2016, 05:09
jdollarMaybe that's because it is a red stag. Re-read the first post....
Vote Trump- Putin’s best friend…
To quote a former AND CURRENT Trumpiteer - DUMP TRUMP
07 March 2016, 08:11
Matt GrahamLittle bit of maral influence there maybe too!! Very nice mate!! Yes it must be 330
07 March 2016, 08:40
SliderRight at 340.
07 March 2016, 08:45
billrquimbyA nice stag, but to answer Express's question, it wouldn't qualify for the Boone & Crockett Club's American elk record book categories if the estimates on this post are correct.
The minimum B&C score for an American typical elk is 360 points after deductions for non-symmetrical tines and 385 for an American non-typical elk.
Also, I don't think B&C has "classes." Safari Club International's book has bronze (minimum 264), silver (minimum 311 1/8) and gold (minimum 350 2/8) classes for typical North American elk and does not deduct for non-symmetry.
If entered as a European red deer, the SCI minimums are bronze 220, silver 289 7/8, and gold 331 7/8.
Bill Quimby
07 March 2016, 10:53
EXPRESSTechnically you're rright Bill, but don't take the wording of my question literally. By "class" I simply meant "300 class" as I hear people say, nor was it relevant that it would or would not qualify to be entered.
It's just such a great stag that I wondered if I would have much chance of shooting a bigger elk, considering that elk are and can be much bigger.
Here's to always hoping that might still happen.
07 March 2016, 19:27
OLBIKERYou could pay the money for a private land hunt in New Mexico or on one of the Indian Reservations and shoot much bigger.How big is your pocket book???
07 March 2016, 22:18
ZekeShikarDid you measure it yet?
My guestimation is +/- 320"
I've never scored a stag but I've scored more elk than I can remember.
Zeke
08 March 2016, 08:51
Paul TruccoloMeasured on a system that does not penalise for overspread, as does our local (Australian) Douglas scoring method, your stag, as a "Red" Stag should go 330 - 350.
How that would translate to the B&C system for measuring Elk I have no idea, but in any case that is an exceptional wild Red Stag.
Congrats.
08 March 2016, 09:21
georgeldI don't know much about scoring racks. But, don't they deduct for non typical points??
Dandy rack, hell of a pile of "dead meat". How far and how did you pack it out? IF I didn't miss it, tell us about the gun and range of shot etc.
Congrats no less, best of luck on the elk hunt too.
George
"Gun Control is NOT about Guns'
"It's about Control!!"
Join the NRA today!"
LM: NRA, DAV,
George L. Dwight
09 March 2016, 09:04
loud-n-boomerNice looking critter, my friend. I agree with those that say he would go in the low 300s. He would still be an excellent bull for public land in most parts of Colorado.
One morning I shot an elephant in my pajamas. How he got into my pajamas I'll never know. - Groucho Marx
10 March 2016, 08:07
Jason PEasily 340+
13 March 2016, 04:09
Big Wonderful WyomingWas he a silver medal stag?
He looks to be 310-325.
13 March 2016, 22:03
jdollarwith the size and overall weight, almost certainly a gold medal stag. the 9x8 one that i shot in Poland last Sept weighed 10kg and was scored as a CIC gold medal stag.
Vote Trump- Putin’s best friend…
To quote a former AND CURRENT Trumpiteer - DUMP TRUMP