The Accurate Reloading Forums
Rookie black bear hunter question

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/3411043/m/4031071171

08 February 2012, 02:46
PSmith
Rookie black bear hunter question
Okay Gents, your thoughts on the use of a .308 and .30-'06 for black bear, the kind of bears they grow up in British Columbia. I was thinking of 180 grain TSX or Swift A-Frame, or for the '06 maybe Norma's 200 grain Oryx. Thanks!


Paul Smith
SCI Life Member
NRA Life Member
DSC Member
Life Member of the "I Can't Wait to Get Back to Africa" Club
DRSS
I had the privilege to fire E. Hemingway's WR .577NE, E. Keith's WR .470NE, & F. Jamieson's WJJ .500 Jeffery
I strongly recommend avoidance of "The Zambezi Safari & Travel Co., Ltd." and "Pisces Sportfishing-Cabo San Lucas"

"A failed policy of national defense is its own punishment" Otto von Bismarck
08 February 2012, 02:52
Aaron Neilson
I've shot plenty of black bears, even in B.C. You've got plenty of medicine, just make a good shot!

Good luck.


Aaron Neilson
Global Hunting Resources
303-619-2872: Cell
globalhunts@aol.com
www.huntghr.com

08 February 2012, 03:37
BigB
I have used 30.06, 300 winmag and 375 H&H and all resulted in dead bears. Good bullet and shot placement is the key. Your choice is excellent.

BigB
08 February 2012, 04:14
p dog shooter
I haven't shot as many as some but I have shot and have seen bears shot with both.

I have seen blk bears that have been over 400lbs dressed shot with both.

Shoot them in the right spot and one well have a dead bear.

A good 165 to 220 gr bullets works great.

A good freind of mine who is in on 10-15 bear kills a year for the pass 30 years or so.

Carrys a Rem model 7 in 308 with 165 core locks the last bear he shot with it dressed at 416lbs.

He says it is plenty.
08 February 2012, 04:24
Stonecreek
Inland B.C. bears will be relatively small. Plus or minus 200 lbs. is a typical adult, depending on whether you are hunting spring (lighter) or fall (heavier). Coastal and Vancouver Island bears will be somewhat larger due to their fish diet.

From my limited experience, I would say the perfect rifle for inland bears is about a .30 caliber shooting a 165 to 180 grain bullet between 2600 and 2800 fps. For the larger coastal bears I would say that the perfect rifle is about a .30 caliber shooting a 165 to 180 grain bullet between 2600 and 2800 fps. If either of your rifles fit this description it should should be "just about perfect".

However, don't think in terms of too tough a bullet. Blackies succumb much more quickly to proper expansion than to just drilling a .30 caliber hole through them. I'd rather use any good conventional cup and core bullet than a monometal or limited expansion bullet like the A-frame. A Nosler Partition might be a good compromise if you're worried about lack of penetration.
08 February 2012, 04:36
Snellstrom
Well said Stonecreek.
A .308 or a 30/06 with 165 or 180 grain bullets is a big killer and don't let anybody tell you different, put one where it counts and you've got a dead bear.
08 February 2012, 04:52
PSmith
Thanks guys, much appreciated.


Paul Smith
SCI Life Member
NRA Life Member
DSC Member
Life Member of the "I Can't Wait to Get Back to Africa" Club
DRSS
I had the privilege to fire E. Hemingway's WR .577NE, E. Keith's WR .470NE, & F. Jamieson's WJJ .500 Jeffery
I strongly recommend avoidance of "The Zambezi Safari & Travel Co., Ltd." and "Pisces Sportfishing-Cabo San Lucas"

"A failed policy of national defense is its own punishment" Otto von Bismarck
08 February 2012, 05:10
ravenr
quote:
You've got plenty of medicine, just make a good shot!

quote:
put one where it counts and you've got a dead bear.

Savvy hunters and even better advice.
08 February 2012, 13:52
youp50
Now learn anatomy of the Black Bear. You have plenty of gun and great bullet choice there.
09 February 2012, 20:27
OLBIKER
Black bears are not hard to kill.You are not underarmed with a 30/30 in what ever bullet you like.
10 February 2012, 01:53
Doc
black bears die quick. All but 2 of my rifle kills were with my 30.06. I used a 168 TTSX on one, a 200 AB on another and 180 Swift Scirocco on the rest.

Every bullet passed through except the AB.


Ted Kennedy's car has killed more people than my guns
10 February 2012, 01:54
Doc
next time I go bb hunting, I'm taking my bow and one of my 270s or my 308. will archery hunt primarily.


Ted Kennedy's car has killed more people than my guns
10 February 2012, 06:03
N E 450 No2
I have shot black bear with a 300 WBY Mag, a 475 FA revolver, a 450/400 3 1/4" double, a 9,3x74R double, and a single shot in 308.

The 308 killed the bear as good as anything.

The bear shot with the 450/400, at 4 or 5 yards, and one of the bears I shot, at 12 yards with the 9,3x74R did drop to the shot, however.


DOUBLE RIFLE SHOOTERS SOCIETY
10 February 2012, 22:57
p dog shooter
I think my next well be with my Ruger no.3 in 45-70 with a 460 gr cast bullet made by me.

Just because I can
10 February 2012, 23:31
ravenr
mine will probably be with my 7STW
but if he gets too close....
I'll "ruin the bruin" with the 45 auto
BOOM
10 February 2012, 23:36
p dog shooter
quote:
Originally posted by ravenr:
mine will probably be with my 7STW
but if he gets too close....
I'll "ruin the bruin" with the 45 auto
BOOM



There there just stir donttroll
12 February 2012, 21:21
AnotherAZWriter
Black bears do die easy, but if you are faced with a frontal shot on a big bear, you better have a good bullet.

I have shot five with a .308. I did shoot one once with a cup and core bullet with a frontal shot and didnt' find him until the next morning, even though I shot him two hours before sunset.


Don't Ever Book a Hunt with Jeff Blair
http://forums.accuratereloadin...821061151#2821061151

13 February 2012, 17:39
Mikelravy
Even more so if you have to shoot a big bear going away. No cup and core bullets for bear for me.
20 February 2012, 03:00
vlwtx348
quote:
Originally posted by PSmith:
Okay Gents, your thoughts on the use of a .308 and .30-'06 for black bear, the kind of bears they grow up in British Columbia. I was thinking of 180 grain TSX or Swift A-Frame, or for the '06 maybe Norma's 200 grain Oryx. Thanks!


I shot a 436 lb Black bear in Maine in 2010 with my .308. I hand-loaded some 165 gr GMX Hornadys. They were not "hot-loaded", only about 2500 fps muzzle velocity. I got 19-20" penetration and had 99.9% weight retention. Did the job just fine. A TSX or A-Frame should do just as well or better.


_______________
DSC
NRA Benefactor
24 February 2012, 06:04
RMiller
I have only shot one black bear. I shot it with a 308 and a remington 180 grain corelokt about 225 yards. Hit it in the throat and found the bullet in the rear leg nicely mushroomed. It squares 6' as a rug on my wall.


--------------------
THANOS WAS RIGHT!
26 February 2012, 05:42
WestCoaster
You do not need a heavy for caliber bullet.
But as some have said here a bonded or mono bullet would be a decent idea.
The only other bullet I recommend is the Hornady interlock if you shoot them @ 2800 fps or less @ muzzle.
A 150gr mono or a 165gr bonded would be plenty of bullet in a 308 for B Bear.
For spring bear they are easy to kill with a well placed shot.
Fall bear with a heavy fat accumulation require a bit more bullet.

The last B bear I potted was a spring bear and I thumped him with my 7mm Rem mag shooting 150gr Federal blue box (long story LOL) dropped at the shot rolled downhill bout 30ft and was dead when he got there.
26 February 2012, 05:44
WestCoaster
The largest B bear I saw actually weighed was a Island bear that went 356 lbs in mid sept.
It had been hanging around a slaughter house and became a nuisance.

Oops weight should read 536 lbs... typo! LOL