Gentlemen,

I'm buying a used Model 19 and I had a few questions:

I've heard this called a Model 19 Combat Revolver. Is that correct?

Is this a K-frame Smith and Wesson?

Is a 4" barrel too short to hunt with in Texas? I don't mean hunt as in using this as my main firearm; rather using it to shoot hogs and maybe a deer up very close.

Also, do any of you have any tips on handloading for it? Handguns are a new frontier to me and I don't know much about them. I've got a couple more bucks left on its lay-away and I can't wait to get it!

Thanks all,

Jason

Yes it's a K frame and because of that don't load it too hot.

I believe it's formal name is the Smith & Wesson Model 19 "Combat Magnum Masterpiece", as opposed to the Model 15's "Combat Masterpiece". Carried one in various flavors (blue, nickel and stainless) for many years both in uniform and out. A finer revolver would be hard to find.

quote:

---

Originally posted by mete:
Yes it's a K frame and because of that don't load it too hot.

---

Sir,

Does this mean I cannot use the maximum loads published in reloading maunuals, such as the Sierra book?

The Model 19 was designed to be carried more than it was to be shot. I would not feed it a steady diet of max or near max loads unles you have a good gunsmith who can rework the revolver. It is a fine revolver, but I advise against pushing it too hard.

It was originally designed to shoot 90% 38 spec and 10% 357 Mag.

I believe you would be better served for your purposes with a single action Ruger. The Mod 19 is a vary weak action, will not take heavy factory loads such as the plus P for vary long. I've had the recoil shield back out on this model. Cylinders lock up, on and on with trouble when using heavy stuff. Real fine when using .38sp loads. I know if they would let me switch the layaway to another sixgun I would look to a Ruger even in DA they will take much heavier loads. This comes from a guy that only carries S&W every day. I carry a model 340PD on my person every day in 357 mag and this is a J frame. But the purpose is not the same. I use it only for protection(two or four legged). If I was going to hunt with a pistol I switch to my old S&W .44 Mod 29. Which still is not as strong as the Ruger flat top. I don't own one but for what you want one for it's clearly a better choice. IMHO

Jason, the Model 19 will handle several thousand rounds of 357 before giving any trouble. It's true 357's cause more wear than 38's, but unless you're going to shoot it a lot, it's just not an issue. If you plan on shooting more than 2 or 3 K rounds of 357's, go with a L or N frame. Otherwise, just enjoy a fine revolver.

John