Anyone have any experience with the Hornady version? How about the Hornady with the micrometer insert? How is it for value and consistency when put up against the Redding measures?

I've used the Hornady, Lyman, RCBS Uni-flow, and the Redding. My vote will have to go for the Redding, with the RCBS Uni-flow as a close second.
The last two are the ones I currently use.

Just the way I see it,,,,,

I use the RCBS more than others. No matter the brand, the key to consistant charges is an exact, repeatable movement, down to the amount of pressure and number of bumps of the handle. However you move the chamber, it has to be the same each and every time. If it doesn't feel the same, dump the charge and do it again.