THE ACCURATERELOADING.COM FORUMS


Moderators: Mark
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
correct way to measure a group
 Login/Join
 
one of us
Picture of cummins cowboy
posted
I was wondering what is the correct way to measure a group. If i put 4 shots inside a nickel with my .22-250 what would that be. The nickel measures slightly more than 13/16" or do i measure the diameter of the group 13/16 or would it be the radius.
 
Posts: 1755 | Location: slc Ut | Registered: 22 December 2002Reply With Quote
new member
posted Hide Post
Measure the outside of the 'furthest apart' holes, and then subtract the diameter of the bullet.

At least that's the method I've been taught.

This means a perfect 'one hole' group would have a measurement of zero!
 
Posts: 10 | Location: Norfolk, VA | Registered: 30 January 2003Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Bob338
posted Hide Post
Previous poster is correct. Center to center of the holes furthest apart. If they're all in the same hole, then the widest point of the hole, minus the caliber of the bullet used.
 
Posts: 1261 | Location: Placerville, CA, US of A | Registered: 07 January 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of ricciardelli
posted Hide Post
GROUP SIZE ANALYSIS METHODS

(Maximum Spread)
The Maximum Spread (also called group diameter or extreme spread) is simply the distance between the centers of the two most widely dispersed shots in a group. This is the most common method used to describe group size because it is the easiest measurement to take. Unfortunately it only considers two shots in the result so an otherwise tight group of 10 shots with one "flyer" can produce results similar to a widely dispersed two shot group. For bench rest shooters who are capable of putting five shots in one hole it is a valid measure; but for the rest of us, or for handgun shooting it does not provide a "statistically significant" number for comparing targets.

(String Measurement)
This is an old method still used to determine a shooter's skill at hitting a target. It assumes the point of aim is always the desired point of impact and is simply the sum of the distances from the point of aim to each bullet hole. Originally a string was used to gather the distances, hence the name. It is still a valid measure of total error relative to the aim point. String Measurements however cannot be used to analyze sight settings because it only measures the magnitude of error, not the direction of error. It is also not a useful measure of group size because a tight group located away from the Bullseye will produce a large String Measurement.

(Average Group Radius)
The average of the distances from the statistical group center (not the aim point) to each shot is the Average Group Radius. It accurately reflects how far a typical shot will impact from the aim point with a well sighted arm. This measure is the best indicator of group size or firearm performance because flyers have less impact on the result so it provides a "statistically significant" number for comparing a series of targets or groups. Unfortunately it is difficult to calculate manually. Unlike a String Measurement, the Average Group Radius does not assume the point of aim is the desired impact point, so sighting error is not a factor in the result. Average Group Radius can therefore be used to compare group sizes when the impact point is intentionally high (rifle sighted for maximum point blank range and shooting dead center). It is also the best measure for evaluating the overall accuracy of loads. Magazine articles using Average Group Radius indicate the writer has taken care to provide readers with statistically significant data, but you should be careful not to compare it to the more common Maximum Spread.

ERROR ANALYSIS METHODS

(Vertical and Horizontal Spread)

The Horizontal and Vertical Spread of a group is simply the greatest distance between shots on the vertical or horizontal plane. This contrasts with the Maximum Spread which can be at any angle across the group. This measurement is understood by most shooters, easy to make, and can be used to help detect load and mechanical problems or "pulling" by the shooter. If the Vertical or Horizontal Spread is significantly larger and shots are well dispersed, it is called "stringing". A cross wind will obviously disperse shots horizontally. Vertical stringing may be caused by irregular powder charges and detonation problems (inconsistent ignition due to variations in primer pocket depth or primer thickness). Improper crimping, bullet inconsistencies or other loading problems usually result in larger overall group sizes, and not "stringing" in any particular direction. A loose gun sight, or broken scope may also cause stringing.

(Average Vertical and Horizontal Error)

The Average Horizontal and Vertical Error is the average of errors on the Vertical and Horizontal plane from the group's statistical center. This is a much better measure for detecting errors than Vert./Hor. Spread because the shot data is averaged to reduce the influence of "flyers". If the goal is to track "pulling" by the shooter over time or to isolate problems, then the Average Vertical & Horizontal Error is a better measurement for comparing a series of targets.

(Maximum Shot Radius)

The Maximum Shot Radius (or maximum group radius) is the distance from a group's statistical center to the center of the most distant hole. It really only indicates how far from the group center the worst shot should fall and is not a good indicator of overall performance. On a target where shots are evenly dispersed, this measurement will be about 1/2 the Maximum Spread and larger than the Average Group Radius. It is best used to quantify the worst shot in a series of targets.

(Maximum Shot Radius Compared To Average Group Radius)
The Maximum Shot Radius should be only slightly larger than the Average Group Radius. A big difference between these measures is another indication of shooter error or a bad load.

(Average Elevation and Windage Error)
The Average Elevation and Windage Errors compare a group's statistical center to the point of aim. It accurately indicates where the group center is located (or average shot impacted) with a set of vertical and horizontal dimensions. The two measurements show how well the firearm is sighted to hit the Bullseye and can be used to adjust sights if the results are converted to Minutes of Angle.
 
Posts: 3282 | Location: Saint Marie, Montana | Registered: 22 May 2002Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of cummins cowboy
posted Hide Post
so a nickel being 13/16" or .8125" minus .224 the caliber of my bullet that leaves a group of .651" I am shooting a ruger m77 mkII with a 22" standard weight barrel load is 38 grains of H380 behind a 55 grain vmax. my question is should i be happy with this, should i even really expect anymore out of a gun like this?? should i do further load development?
 
Posts: 1755 | Location: slc Ut | Registered: 22 December 2002Reply With Quote
<PaulS>
posted
Cowboy,
By all means do further load developement! .6" groups are good by any measure but if the weapon can give you .2 inch groups why settle for more?

PaulS
 
Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of ricciardelli
posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by cummins cowboy:
so a nickel being 13/16" or .8125" minus .224 the caliber of my bullet that leaves a group of .651" I am shooting a ruger m77 mkII with a 22" standard weight barrel load is 38 grains of H380 behind a 55 grain vmax. my question is should i be happy with this, should i even really expect anymore out of a gun like this?? should i do further load development?

 -
This group, which measured somewhere around 0.260-inches for 5-shots at 200-yards.
It was fired using a Ruger 77V in .22-250 Remington with Leupold 12x optics
Case: Remington
Primer: Remington 9-1/2
Powder: 38.4 grains of H-380
Bullet: Sierra 52 grain Hollow Point Boat Tail
Velocity: 3702 FPs @ 15' from muzzle

Now, answer your own question...
[Smile]
 
Posts: 3282 | Location: Saint Marie, Montana | Registered: 22 May 2002Reply With Quote
  Powered by Social Strata  
 


Copyright December 1997-2023 Accuratereloading.com


Visit our on-line store for AR Memorabilia