I would like to get some input on how HS#6 and AA#5 compare in 45ACP 230gr full power loads. Do they both burn clean,are they both accurate ? Any comparative input for folks that have used these two powers would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks, Dyno

I never have used AA#5, but I use HS 6 a lot in my 12 ga and .44 Spl. It is not particularly clean, but it is powerful. In my 12 ga, I load 1 1/4 oz of #6 shot and it is the best pattern of any load I have and the book says it is over 1300 fps. Extra good hunting load.

The .44 will make your hand sting with ~8-9 gr behind a 240 gr lead bullet. Don't know how fast it is. When you eject the empties, you get a hand full of dirt with the shells. I switched to Universal Clays in hopes that it would be cleaner. It is a little, but not as powerful. Next I guess I will try H4227.

------------------
Davis Chase

They are both slow powders, but I get good accurate loads with AA#5 and 200gr.SWC.
Yes they dirty.

Thanks Guys for your info on the powders,I am looking to buy some powder for 45acp full power loads using 230gr fmj and am leaning towards AA#5 at this time.

Dyno