17 March 2003, 08:38
mbogo375Ballistics programs
Which is the most useful program for working with obsolete and wildcat calibers in calculating pressure and velocity of new loads?
Thanks,
Jim
17 March 2003, 15:39
mbogo375waitaminit,
Thanks. I have been considering QuickLoad or Load From A Disk, but the demo of QuickLoad did seem to offer more possibilities for non-standard calibers.
Jim
17 March 2003, 15:58
Bob338Look at AccuLoad as well. Similar to QuickLoad for internal ballistics but with a bunch more bells and whistles for gun inventory, load storage, etc. Do a Search here. It's been rehashed many times.
18 March 2003, 13:32
waitaminitJim, I use QuickLoad for a while already and ordered LFAD for curiosity: you get what you pay for.
One day I'll buy AccuLoad as well - right now it is still too new and within too flawy (what I read).
But the AccuLoad people seem to be quite knowledgeable and permanently improving their product so that it will be an attractive reloading tool in a year or so.
What I miss in QL is the AccurateArms powder selection - which is not Mr. Br�mel's fault: AA fails to provide the propellant data necessary for the calculations.
Every time I'v downloaded the QL demo at neconos,I get a "corrupted setup file" message??
Jeff
19 March 2003, 20:57
mbogo375Gentlemen,
Thanks for your replies. I have decided to try Calculoader before deciding on whether to go with the full Accuload or with Quickload (Calculoader is relatively inexpensive, and can be upgraded to the full Accuload program). I have tried the Quickload demo, and it seems very promising, but I have been impressed with the responsiveness of the Accuload developers in looking back at previous posts concerning ballistics programs on this site.
Jim
20 March 2003, 02:35
<RickMD>If you're looking for world class service try AccuLoad. I had problems running the initial version on a XP Professional system but the newest version (2.03) seems to have solved all problems. These guys are great!
25 March 2003, 17:36
MagnumP5The newest update of QL has several of the AA powders. One drawback to QL is it's failure to accurately predict pressures, etc. in straight or nearly straight walled cartridges like 45-70 or 416 Rigby. I understand that Hartmut and MM are working on this, but no promises. This is all explained in the manual (has to do with powder column shift). I have used QL for a number of years and it is a superb program, but does have it's limitations. Those limitations can easily be surmounted with good manuals and a chronograph.
26 March 2003, 03:32
<bigcountry>What about for guy that doesn't want chamber pressures and all. But more a very accurate bullistics calculator and maybe a catalog of loads? And doesn't have the 150 dollars for a program? I know Lee makes one and Sierra.