The Accurate Reloading Forums
LOADING THE 300 WEATHERBY FOR WHITE TAIL

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/2511043/m/2851063741

07 January 2011, 19:54
vines
LOADING THE 300 WEATHERBY FOR WHITE TAIL
need some good loads for 150 or 165. This is my first time loading for a weatherby..
07 January 2011, 20:46
Blacktailer
Vines,
Can't help with load data but the question I would like to ask is Why?
With overbore magnums like your Weatherby or my RUM, when you go to lighter bullets you get a helluvalot of velocity. While velocity flattens out your trajectory curve, it also leads to more meat destruction and can lead to bullet "failures".
Unless you are planning on regularly shooting 400 yards, my thought would be to stick to a larger bullet or lighter if you prefer at around 2900fps. Just my $.02 but having shot a blacktail with my elk loads and having to throw away an entire shoulder, I been there done that and don't do that no more. BOOM


Have gun- Will travel
The value of a trophy is computed directly in terms of personal investment in its acquisition. Robert Ruark
07 January 2011, 21:07
vines
BLACKTAIL: I asked the same quastion, this is NOT my gun. I dont even use a long action. My deer rifles are .260 Rem. & 7MM-08. this is for a friend of mine, I told him the same thing. To big for white tail.
07 January 2011, 21:12
R D McMillan
quote:
To big for white tail.

No it is not! Too fast maybe but not too big! Use a 180 Nosler Protected Point and---wait for it---shoot 'em in the head!!!LOL!
07 January 2011, 21:24
Blacktailer
If he is stuck on lighter bullets, load up some of the starting loads at around 2900fps in the loading books and see how they shoot. If accuracy is acceptable you should be OK. There certainly is no good reason to push anything faster than 3000fps unless he likes hamburger Big Grin


Have gun- Will travel
The value of a trophy is computed directly in terms of personal investment in its acquisition. Robert Ruark
07 January 2011, 21:53
dave-t
I hunted with a 300winmag for over a decade as my go to big game gun, and went with a 180grn at 2960fps or so. I gave up on lighter bullets do to meat loss and blood shot meat. Keeping the bullet under 3000fps, and having a fairly sturdy bullet helps. But after that, it's no more effective than a more standard deer round though, and has more downside if you hit a shouler, etc.

If he wants a lighter bullet I'd look into the mono metal projectiles.
07 January 2011, 22:57
LWD
It'll do just fine with a tougher bullet. A Barnes TSX or TTSX would be perfect. Lots of velocity without the explosion that destroys meat.


LWD
08 January 2011, 00:48
Blacktailer
quote:
Originally posted by LWD:
It'll do just fine with a tougher bullet. A Barnes TSX or TTSX would be perfect. Lots of velocity without the explosion that destroys meat.


LWD

Well, the experience I had with my RUM was a 180gr Barnes X at about 200yds. Blew the you-know-what out of things. Granted the RUM runs considerably faster than the Roy but even with monometals, you can have too much of a good thing.


Have gun- Will travel
The value of a trophy is computed directly in terms of personal investment in its acquisition. Robert Ruark
08 January 2011, 00:56
Mark
My two cents- use the bigger bullets this gun was throated for and keep slowing them down until the groups open up to unacceptable.

I suspect he'll be able to make smaller bullets zip right along and then be surprised to have a clean miss on a deer a few hundred yards away. Then again, he may be able to load 150's and get less than 3 MOA out of it but if if he doesn't it might not be the fault of the trigger-puller.
As mentioned earlier, I'd also try using a 180 grain sized bullet which works fine on white tails. The bonus is that 180 grains of most ANY bullet is adequate to hunt white tails with, so no need for premium bullets when regular hunting bullets work just fine.


for every hour in front of the computer you should have 3 hours outside
08 January 2011, 04:22
TEANCUM
quote:
Originally posted by R D McMillan:
quote:
To big for white tail.

No it is not! Too fast maybe but not too big! Use a 180 Nosler Protected Point and---wait for it---shoot 'em in the head!!!LOL!


My know all shooting and reloading guru Hotsh#t has repeatedly warned us about the dangers of attempting a "stunt" with head-shooting. He is on record with the admonishment of looking out for the "rapid head movements", as he calls them, that could lead to bullet failure. Since some here are quoting his turds of wisdom in their signature line I thought that I would bring this to your attention.

Kind of like a civic duty.
08 January 2011, 04:43
Quintus
The 130gr barnes in the 300Wby is a GREAT combo for whitetails. 87 Grains of IMR4350 and Vouala! An easy to shoot laser beam that will do no more damage than any other 30 from any other case.
08 January 2011, 07:00
CISCO
Go for the shoulder then you wont have to worry about boning the sumbitches out.

Chris
08 January 2011, 07:38
muygrande
168 TTSX
08 January 2011, 07:40
RMiller
I would go with a monmetal bullet also. Not to brag about shitty shooting but I have hit deer in the femur and through both shoulders with a 200 TSX out of a 300 win mag at 2950. Didnt lose a bit of meat but what I had to trim out the small bone shards. Maybe a pound at most. I have had 0% bloodshot from any barnes X bullets.


--------------------
THANOS WAS RIGHT!