Best Brass Tumbler

08 March 2005, 16:21

jdlouie

Best Brass Tumbler

My brass tumbler just bit the dust. I was wandering which one everyone is using and how you like it. Thanks

08 March 2005, 16:59

Bill Adams

I have one of those old cheap blue tumblers from Midway, has worked fine for 15 years. BA

08 March 2005, 17:09

HL

I use the Lyman 2200, which seems to work well, but the best one I have used and still use often is the RCBS sidewinder rotary tumbler.

The lyman will handle more brass, but the sidewinder will clean them much quicker. Plus you can use liquid solution in the sidewinder. Not sure if you can in the vibrator types.

08 March 2005, 19:59

Stonecreek

Like Bill Adams, my old Midway tumbler is still going strong. Any of the vibrating "tumblers" will do about the same job. Unlike HL, my impression is that the vibrators work faster than the rollers, but having no experience with the rollers I can't really say. HL is certainly correct that if for some reason you want to use a liquid, you must use the rolling-style machine.

My advice would be to buy whatever is cheapest and has a bowl large enough to accomodate your particular volume demands.

08 March 2005, 20:03

skb2706

The best is a Thumlers Tumbler vibratory tumbler. They are also the most expensive. If I were doing it again I would just go to Midway or Midsouth find out what vibratory tumbler was on sale. They are all basically the same.

08 March 2005, 23:18

z1r

My Thumlers has been going strong since 1987. Wasn't that much more than any other at the time.

One piece of advice is get the largest you can afford.

09 March 2005, 01:10

Cal Sibley

I have a Lyman Turbo tumbler that serves me well, and has for several years. I think most tumblers are pretty well made. The key is in finding the media and cleaning solution that works best for you. There is a learning curve involved in this. After much experimentation and frustration I setled on a product called Lyman Tuf-Nut. It's a walnut media that has jewellers rouge built into it. There's nothing else to add. Being dry the median doesn't clog your primer pockets and insides of the case. Also it leaves no haze on the case. They come out shiny and clean. Being dry also doesn't contaminate your media so rapidly. Just one mans opinion, but it works well for me. Best wishes.

Cal - Montreal

09 March 2005, 02:12

12FLVSS

Not the best, but certainly large... I saw a vibratory tumbler at Jeff Bartlett's place that would handle 1000 30-06 cases. The tumbler bowl was 3' across in the middle. Was fargin Huge!

Ian

09 March 2005, 15:08

PC

I bought a dillon on adice from others.

09 March 2005, 16:36

rcasto

I have nothing but praise for the large Dillon vibrator. It will handle a ton of cases and has done a great job for many, many years.

However, as I type, I just fired up for the first time a new Thumblers rotary with ceramic media. I'll report back with the results.

I shoot a lot of black powder cartridges and the brass gets about as dirty as it can get. Others tell me this ceramic media set up will make the brass look brand new after 2-3 hours without all the brushing and scrubbing I have to do before I use the walnut media. Plus, the ceramic never wears out.

We will see.

24 August 2008, 00:34

163bc

rcasto, I'd love to hear what you think of that Thumlers rotary tumbler with the ceramic media. Thanks, Sam

24 August 2008, 10:37

delloro

my midway will not quit.

24 August 2008, 15:44

Ozzie

I have a Lyman, an RCBS and the Cabelas, all the vibratory model. Nothing wrong with the first two but the Cabelas is the best of these three

24 August 2008, 16:23

dsiteman

I use the Midway blue vibratory type and couple years ago, basement flooded, ruined the unit. Called Midway to order another one and was told to send it to them, did so and they sent me a new one, no charge!! Fixed the basement problem and no more problems!

24 August 2008, 17:48

Steve Latham

Lyman turbo pro 1200, has great capacity, & no intrusive noise. Steve in U.K.

24 August 2008, 19:57

greenjoy

I have the RCBS Sidewinder case tumbler. It is that first and only tumbler I have purchased.
I was expensive, but I like the idea that it could use both liquid and dry media. I was also worried that the vibratory type would make a loud buzzing noise that I would not like.

The sidewinder produces is quiet a low rumbling noise along with a slight tinkling sound of the cartridge case touching.
With extra tumblers barrels available (again expensive) I thought I might one day use it to moly coat bullets.

I have not tried ceramic media, so far I have just used Lyman treated corn cob media.
Recently I have added a couple of table spoons of Dillon Rapid Polish 290 just to see if the cases could get shiner and yes it did make them a little shiner.

My only complaints are:
1) The unit is expensive.

2) The media I am using left a slimy greasy feel to the cases and a little dust(before and after the dillon polish). I wash the cases off under running water after tumbling.

3) I thought the cases would get clean inside too but nothing can remove the burned on stain on the inside of the case.

If I was in the market for a case cleaner today knowing what I now know, I would buy an ultrasonic type cleaner for its superior cleaning ability and its versatility for cleaning other small part jewelry and stuff.

For cleaning just a few cases (less than 25) I just brush them out under running water then spin them while holding a "Krazy Kloth" cleaning rag against them, the brass shines up so much it looks almost white and they hold their shine in storage. Where as the cases straight from the tumbler with only a rinse off tend to get a dark mottled or uneven colour with a slight greenish tint after a few months in storage (I blame the media I am using).

25 August 2008, 12:11

Steve Latham

quote:
Posted 24 August 2008 19:57 Hide Post
I have the RCBS Sidewinder case tumbler. It is that first and only tumbler I have purchased.
I was expensive, but I like the idea that it could use both liquid and dry media. I was also worried that the vibratory type would make a loud buzzing noise that I would not like.

The sidewinder produces is quiet a low rumbling noise along with a slight tinkling sound of the cartridge case touching.
With extra tumblers barrels available (again expensive) I thought I might one day use it to moly coat bullets.

I have not tried ceramic media, so far I have just used Lyman treated corn cob media.
Recently I have added a couple of table spoons of Dillon Rapid Polish 290 just to see if the cases could get shiner and yes it did make them a little shiner.

My only complaints are:
1) The unit is expensive.

2) The media I am using left a slimy greasy feel to the cases and a little dust(before and after the dillon polish). I wash the cases off under running water after tumbling.

3) I thought the cases would get clean inside too but nothing can remove the burned on stain on the inside of the case.

If I was in the market for a case cleaner today knowing what I now know, I would buy an ultrasonic type cleaner for its superior cleaning ability and its versatility for cleaning other small part jewelry and stuff.

For cleaning just a few cases (less than 25) I just brush them out under running water then spin them while holding a "Krazy Kloth" cleaning rag against them, the brass shines up so much it looks almost white and they hold their shine in storage. Where as the cases straight from the tumbler with only a rinse off tend to get a dark mottled or uneven colour with a slight greenish tint after a few months in storage (I blame the media I am using).

Posts: 127 | Location: Ont. Canada | Registered: 17 June 2006 Reply With Quote

Hi Greenjoy, I don't use any washing myself, but would suspect your greenish hue is to do with not drying fully, I have found that lightly loaded tumblers running for 4 hours minimum gives a factory shine

26 August 2008, 06:11

Fish30114

I too will be interested to learn of the results with ceramic media and the Thumblers.

I bought one of the Thumblers, and was VERY disappointed. I loaded it up with a reasonable amount of media and brass and it would barely spin. I emptied it immediately, and it sits in the basement looking for another owner, it has a spare 'rubber' liner, and other than the 30 minute first test, is brand new--very frustrated with it, maybe I was just using it wrong--can't imagine how--but my dillon 'regular' tumbler works like a charm, has for several years now.

27 August 2008, 07:53

btefft

I have had 0 problems with my Lyman Twin Tumbler.

Hack

27 August 2008, 08:04

Macifej

27 August 2008, 08:58

ireload2

Think I bought my Thumblers Model B roller in 1970 or so when they were about all that was available. I used it quite a bit the first 5 years. I learned to keep my brass clean so I don't use it so much now. It will be 40 in 2 years.

28 September 2008, 12:01

Explorer

quote:
Originally posted by Steve Latham:
[QUOTE]I thought the cases would get clean inside too but nothing can remove the burned on stain on the inside of the case.

I've used the ultrasonic type cleaner (which you are looking for) together with citric acid

28 September 2008, 12:05

Airguns

looks like the one on top has a head separation coming, didn't you notice the discoloration?