Administrator
| I read this book, and was very disappointed in it. It started well, then degenerated into a sort of Hollywood B movie script. |
| |
One of Us
| I too agree with Saeed. I have read every book that Wilbur Smith has written and even took this one to Zambia with me last year to read on the plane and during down times. This is his first book that I struggled to finish. Maybe it's because his prior reads were so well done that one tends to make comparisons. I wound up giving the hardback copy that I had to Russel Caldecot in Vic Falls hoping he might enjoy it. |
| Posts: 158 | Location: texas panhandle | Registered: 15 October 2006 | 
IP
|
|
One of Us
| I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books; just finished reading Assegai, this is not his best one. |
| |
one of us
| I've read many of his books, but not this one. Did just finish reading an older one called "Gold Mine", and struggled with it, which is not something I usually do with his books. |
| |
One of Us

| After a few books the theme starts to become old hat. I guess we all expect something new and exciting with each new volume , and its probably pretty difficult for the author to maintain the initial momentum. Another formulaic author is Clive Cussler. Good airplane books - good vs evil , heroe wins the girl , can read without needing too many braincells engaged.
________________________
Old enough to know better
|
| Posts: 4475 | Location: Eltham , New Zealand | Registered: 13 May 2002 | 
IP
|
|
One of Us
| Muzza, have you read any Peter Watt? He is Australia's version of Wilbur Smith, only better. Guy I was hunting with gave me a copy of "Cry of the Curlew" a few years ago; said "if you like Wilbur Smith, you will love this guy". His stories are based in the Australian Outback and New Guinea, and are far from boring. Once I start one of his books, I can't put it down. Haven't been able to find any of his books here in the states; had to order them from Australia. |
| |