https://allafrica.com/stories/202112080939.html


Namibia: 'Cut Out the Middleman'... Rural Communities Demand Win-Win Benefits From International Hunting

8 DECEMBER 2021
New Era (Windhoek)
By Emmanuel Koro

Once considered to be voiceless and almost powerless, southern African hunting communities are increasingly becoming powerful and are now demanding win-win benefits from international hunting by removing the middlemen.

The Southern African hunting communities representatives say the middlemen for international hunting are the local and foreign safari hunting companies that market southern Africa as a must-visit international hunting destination; where the big five are hunted. These hunting companies buy the international wildlife hunting quotas from SADC hunting communities then sell the huntable wildlife to international hunters and also handle their hunts in Africa.



Despite acknowledging that they receive payment from the safari hunting companies, the SADC hunting communities that own the wildlife think they should be getting paid more than what they are currently receiving. Hence their call to remove the middlemen.

However, the representatives of the SADC hunting communities know the reality that currently they lack the skills to market their areas as attractive international hunting destinations. They also don't have skilled professional hunters to handle hunting for the international hunters when they come to Africa.

Therefore, the hunting communities ironically need the safari hunting companies that they would like to remove as middlemen; to first train them to market their hunts overseas and also to help them train professional hunters who would in the future handle the hunts of international hunters who come to Africa.



"We think this is the right time to remove the middleman and let communities market their own natural resources," said a member of SADC Community Leaders Network (SCLN) and CEO Ngamiland NGOs, Siyoka Simasiku. "Communities should not be stakeholders but shareholders."

However, Siyoka said that this transition from middlemen to hunting community self-marketing will take time as "there is need for capacity building."

The outgoing chairperson of SCLN, Maxi Louis, and the Director of Namibia's National Association of Community-based Organisations (NACSO) said that "70% of rural people rely on natural resources in Africa, including hunting."

She said that the challenges of southern African communities that co-exist with wildlife include limited rights and benefits from "our resources and increased vulnerability to poverty."

"Communities living closest to wildlife and the natural resources are generally the poorest," said Louis. "We are open to a partnership that looks at win-win. We need a regional monitoring and information system."



Meanwhile, Chief Timex Maolosi of Botswana's Samunkuyo Trust said that all the community trusts in Botswana met in Maun recently and recommended the need for capacity building of hunting communities to enable them to market their wildlife to preferred markets.

"Communities should become shareholders or owners of the hunting industry in their localities," said Chief Maolosi. "There is a need to do away with middlemen in the hunting industry but it will take time to achieve capacity building."

Elsewhere, the Botswana government is working towards introducing a Community Based Natural Resources Management Bill, in order to ensure that local communities "don't get a bad deal from hunting contracts."

"Government will look at the agreements to ensure that communities are not getting a bad deal," said Botswana Department of Wildlife and National Parks (DWNP), Kabelo Senyatso. "We discovered some of the communities did not get a fair share in some of the 2021 hunting agreements. The DWNP reserves the right to determine whether or not the agreement between the community and the safari operator is fair or not."

He said that the government of Botswana is working towards introducing a law that would ensure that communities receive fair benefits from the use of their natural resources, including hunting.

"We are extremely happy when communities receive direct benefits from wildlife," said Chairman of the Botswana Wildlife Producers Association, Basimane Masire - a member of former President Masire's family." It gives good buy-in and conservation support from the communities that bear the costs of co-existing with wildlife."


Meanwhile, Professor Brian Child of the University of Florida has called for the expansion of the hunting industry in the SADC region in order to increase the conservation of land.

"Hunting supports 60-80% of conservation land in the SADC region," said Professor Child. "The Southern African communities are looking after wildlife and it's increasing."

He said that "wildlife is destroyed" when you take away ownership.

"The world has lost over 80% of wildlife because they don't allow people to own it," said Professor Child. "But we don't lose livestock the same way because they own it."

*Emmanuel Koro is a Johannesburg-based international award-winning independent environmental journalist who writes extensively on environment and development issues in Africa.

Self destruction!

With the Western countries doing their best to squelch African trophy hunting, the rural African population has little chance of moving up to full participation in the foreseeable future. It almost seems that the African governments don't read Western newspapers.

quote:

He said that the government of Botswana is working towards introducing a law that would ensure that communities receive fair benefits from the use of their natural resources, including hunting.

I just love this concept of "fair benefits". Those communities are free to raise their prices, are they not. If they don't like the price they are getting - raise it. the market will respond accordingly.

So the guy that pays $$ for the concession, pays $$$ for the quota, builds/maintains the camp and the roads, controls poaching, markets the hunts, provides the vehicles, furniture, water, power, laundry, meals, and transport, does the paperwork, guides the hunt, entertains the hunter when not hunting, takes care of the meat and trophies, and risks his life in the process is a "MIDDLEMAN"!!

Gotta love the African mentality.

Oh and I forgot .. now the MIDDLEMAN must also TRAIN the local communities how to cut him out of the deal.

That's rich.

If anyone needs to be cut out of the deal, it's the government officials.

quote:

Originally posted by Russ Gould:
So the guy that pays $$ for the concession, pays $$$ for the quota, builds/maintains the camp and the roads, controls poaching, markets the hunts, provides the vehicles, furniture, water, power, laundry, meals, and transport, does the paperwork, guides the hunt, entertains the hunter when not hunting, takes care of the meat and trophies, and risks his life in the process is a "MIDDLEMAN"!!

Exactly.

This is like trying to turn the local witch doctor into a brain surgeon.

Fine…let the “communities” build and staff the camps, pay the concession, government trophy and associated fees (upfront, mind you), pay for anti-poaching against their brethren, spend a small fortune marketing their hunts (and if they are dumb enough to think current concession holder “middleman” PH’s will teach them how to “market their hunts, they will certainly get what they deserve). This is about the stupidest idea I have seen so far. Unbelievable.

This is a prime example of why Africa is a disaster economically.

quote:

Originally posted by larryshores:
This is a prime example of why Africa is a disaster economically.

I made a comment at Dar airport how nice the new building was.

An employee there said they wanted it to be like Dubai airport.

I said that might happen, in a million years!

He laughed.

quote:

Fine…let the “communities” build and staff the camps, pay the concession, government trophy and associated fees (upfront, mind you), pay for anti-poaching against their brethren, spend a small fortune marketing their hunts (and if they are dumb enough to think current concession holder “middleman” PH’s will teach them how to “market their hunts, they will certainly get what they deserve). This is about the stupidest idea I have seen so far. Unbelievable.

This has been the typical African model envisioned by the majority of Black Africans for years and years, including non other than the late dictator Robert Mugabe. Let the whites do everything to make a business, city and/or country vibrant and successful, and then step in and take it, all the while f--king it up from day one, never making the necessary repairs and improvements to keep it going or to make it better, and then keeping/stealing the benefits/profits for just the very few at the top. You can substitute Namibia for Botswana, South Africa, Zimbabwe or any other Southern African country and come up with the very same result. OIA

I always thought letting the "animals run the zoo" was a bad idea...but what do I know?

Guys,

I think the indigenous people see a cash cow to be milked but do not have the willingness or ability to make the safari business work for them without help from the established safari operators.

Mark

Typical.

Why don't the same communities tender for these concessions?

quote:

Originally posted by fairgame:
Why don't the same communities tender for these concessions?

Andrew,

I am sure you know Africa better than me.

But from what I have seen so far all they think about is how they are getting out of it.

No one seems to even consider that before you can sell anything there are q few things to prepare.

And make sure everything is up to scratch or client won't be coming.

They don't think past their noses.