The Accurate Reloading Forums
broken rifle need opinion for replacement

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/1411043/m/4341009052

26 March 2019, 23:08
brent ebeling
broken rifle need opinion for replacement
I am heading to Zambia this summer for the PG portion of the hunt I was planning on using my 300 win mag. We have both lechwe on ticket, sable, roan and smaller PG. Yes buff is on ticket as well, but that rifle is a 500 and it will not do for the longer shots.
Back up choices are a 308 win or 6.5 credmore
Any suggestions as to which? I am not going to get a 375 to do it all, so thanks for the the thought. I will have my 500 and one of these two
26 March 2019, 23:35
Labman
I'd go with the one that you shoot the best and are the most comfortable shooting. If that's a tie I'd go with the 308. A little extra bullet diameter and mass is always a good thing.


Tom Z

NRA Life Member
26 March 2019, 23:36
crbutler
While a 6.5 is all the rage, I’d prefer the .308 of the two with heavier bullets.

You really won’t notice wind drift or trajectory differences between the two at normal hunting ranges, and a bigger bullet is better. Not to mention, if you can deal with a .500, you can handle the difference in recoil.

Sable can be pretty tough.
27 March 2019, 01:48
drongo
Sell both and buy a 30:06!


USMC Retired
DSC Life Member
SCI Life Member
NRA Life Member
27 March 2019, 03:47
Wesheltonj
308
27 March 2019, 04:18
ho
drongo is a very wise man. lol
27 March 2019, 04:31
Brian Canada
Thanks for a great video. Brian


IHMSA BC Provincial Champion and Perfect 40 Score, Unlimited Category, AAA Class.
27 March 2019, 07:23
Saeed
quote:
Originally posted by brent ebeling:
I am heading to Zambia this summer for the PG portion of the hunt I was planning on using my 300 win mag. We have both lechwe on ticket, sable, roan and smaller PG. Yes buff is on ticket as well, but that rifle is a 500 and it will not do for the longer shots.
Back up choices are a 308 win or 6.5 credmore
Any suggestions as to which? I am not going to get a 375 to do it all, so thanks for the the thought. I will have my 500 and one of these two


Check if the 6.5 is legal, as in many countries it is not.


www.accuratereloading.com
Instagram : ganyana2000
27 March 2019, 12:36
buckeyeshooter
308, use a premium bullet of 165 or 180 grains and you are set.
27 March 2019, 13:38
faisal
Get the .300WinMag fixed!
27 March 2019, 19:10
Blacktailer
Loaded the wife's 308 with 165TSX. I used it on the smaller stuff and she used it on zebra. No problems. While the 6.5 is all the rage, my preference would be larger bullet diameter, frontal area and weight for Africa.


Have gun- Will travel
The value of a trophy is computed directly in terms of personal investment in its acquisition. Robert Ruark
27 March 2019, 19:21
Michael Robinson
Brent, FWIW, as others have said, I would want the heavier punch of the .308 using good 165 grain bullets.


Mike

Wilderness is my cathedral, and hunting is my prayer.
27 March 2019, 20:00
DLS
Brent, you say that sable and roan are on license, but then ask which gun to take. Sable and Roan are both big, tough and EXPENSIVE. Do you really think the smaller gun is a viable option? I think the choice is clear, just shoot quality bullets accurately in that .308.
27 March 2019, 20:15
BuffHunter63
Definitely the .308.

BH63


Hunting buff is better than sex!
27 March 2019, 20:35
Aspen Hill Adventures
Treat yourself and buy a new rifle. Try a .375H&H, I bet you would love it.


~Ann


27 March 2019, 22:28
p dog shooter
quote:
Originally posted by Aspen Hill Adventures:
Treat yourself and buy a new rifle. Try a .375H&H, I bet you would love it.


Even better a 375 ruger.
27 March 2019, 23:48
surefire7
quote:
Originally posted by DLS:
Brent, you say that sable and roan are on license, but then ask which gun to take. Sable and Roan are both big, tough and EXPENSIVE. Do you really think the smaller gun is a viable option? I think the choice is clear, just shoot quality bullets accurately in that .308.


tu2 Beat me to it...
28 March 2019, 00:43
376 steyr
The 308 is a great caliber, right on the hills of the '06.
28 March 2019, 02:22
Nakihunter
let me step in with MY choices if I was in this situation.

Firstly I would have the money to do such a hunt and so I would have the money to buy a new rifle.

I already have a 470NE and that would be the DG rifle. I also have a beautiful 100+ year old Mauser 98 Simson in 9.3X62 & that would be my choice for roan & sable out to 250 meters. I might even consider taking my 9.5X57MS if I can get it shooting right and plan to stalk up to 150 meters.

I could consider another rifle - A 375H&H from Holts auction. A 318 Wesley Richards

It would be fun just planning & preparing.

Good luck with your trip and hope all goes well.


"When the wind stops....start rowing. When the wind starts, get the sail up quick."
28 March 2019, 05:47
brent ebeling
Thanks for the replies. I was leaning towards 308 as well. For same reasons as mentioned. Creedmore has great ballistics and is sexy, but better for deer and sheep in my opinion.
The cost to replace my 300 will be 4k
And the reason i can afford to drop a bunch of cash on a new rifle is because od the hunt, so thanks.
Looks like the 308 will be it.
28 March 2019, 05:54
MARK H. YOUNG
Brent,

I'm with the rest of the guys. 308 with 150-165 TTSX or similar.

Mark


MARK H. YOUNG
MARK'S EXCLUSIVE ADVENTURES
7094 Oakleigh Dr. Las Vegas, NV 89110
Office 702-848-1693
Cell, Whats App, Signal 307-250-1156 PREFERRED
E-mail markttc@msn.com
Website: myexclusiveadventures.com
Skype: markhyhunter
Check us out on https://www.facebook.com/pages...ures/627027353990716
28 March 2019, 19:38
MacD37
quote:
Originally posted by brent ebeling:
I am heading to Zambia this summer for the PG portion of the hunt I was planning on using my 300 win mag. We have both lechwe on ticket, sable, roan and smaller PG. Yes buff is on ticket as well, but that rifle is a 500 and it will not do for the longer shots.
Back up choices are a 308 win or 6.5 credmore
Any suggestions as to which? I am not going to get a 375 to do it all, so thanks for the the thought. I will have my 500 and one of these two



That's too bad, because a 375 H&H CRF rifle WILL DO IT ALL!

……………………………………………………..375H&H, one rifle for the world! Case closed

……………………………………………………….. old


....Mac >>>===(x)===> MacD37, ...and DUGABOY1
DRSS Charter member
"If I die today, I've had a life well spent, for I've been to see the Elephant, and smelled the smoke of Africa!"~ME 1982

Hands of Old Elmer Keith

28 March 2019, 19:52
fairgame
quote:
Originally posted by faisal:
Get the .300WinMag fixed!


What Faisal says.


ROYAL KAFUE LTD
Email - kafueroyal@gmail.com
Tel/Whatsapp (00260) 975315144
Instagram - kafueroyal
29 March 2019, 05:41
brent ebeling
quote:
Originally posted by fairgame:
quote:
Originally posted by faisal:
Get the .300WinMag fixed!


What Faisal says.


I hear you both, it is at gunsmith. Bolt will not open. It will cam up but not all the way. It is the guy that built the rifle and it is a tack driver, a dime covers 4 bullets at a hundred. He said on phone it will be easy fix or new rifle if lugs got all flattened out. Cant swing new cusrom rifle before the trip
29 March 2019, 05:58
Michael Robinson
Brent, if you want a bigger boomer, I have a couple of .375 H&H Mags., a .338 Win. Mag., a .30-06, a 7mm Rem. Mag. and a .270 WSM I could lend you.

All are well-scoped, and MOA or better rifles.

Just let me know, and I'll ship pronto.


Mike

Wilderness is my cathedral, and hunting is my prayer.
29 March 2019, 06:37
WLW
quote:
Originally posted by brent ebeling:
quote:
Originally posted by fairgame:
quote:
Originally posted by faisal:
Get the .300WinMag fixed!


What Faisal says.


I hear you both, it is at gunsmith. Bolt will not open. It will cam up but not all the way. It is the guy that built the rifle and it is a tack driver, a dime covers 4 bullets at a hundred. He said on phone it will be easy fix or new rifle if lugs got all flattened out. Cant swing new cusrom rifle before the trip


How do lugs get flattened out?


http://forums.accuratereloadin...6321043/m/4821014232


"He Who Farts in Church, Must Sit in Own Pew".
29 March 2019, 07:43
H T
The 308 will be fine, or at least it was for me on a PG hunt in Namibia. Taking it again next year in South Africa. Normally use a 338 for the light rifle, but my wife has taken over that one, and I gave the 308 a try. Did well, and I would echo what others have said: (1) proper bullet weight and construction (I used a 165 grain Barnes TTSX); (2) The rifle needs to shoot the bullet pretty close to 1 MOA, not above 1.5 MOA; (3) Watch that the long shots are not at marginal angles. (4) Be prepared to put in another shot or two.

Besides some smaller stuff, I took two mountain zebra - roughly the size of a sable - at 250 and 320 yards. The 308 did a great job for me and I really believe it will work for you as well.
29 March 2019, 14:27
faisal
I may be wrong but isn't there restrictions on military calibers in Zambia (ie. 303, 5.56/223,7.62/.308,7.62x39)
29 March 2019, 15:32
fairgame
quote:
Originally posted by faisal:
I may be wrong but isn't there restrictions on military calibers in Zambia (ie. 303, 5.56/223,7.62/.308,7.62x39)


Indeed and needs to check with the Outfitter first. I understand .308 maybe allowed but nothing with a head stamp of 7.62 or .303

Regulations may have changed?


ROYAL KAFUE LTD
Email - kafueroyal@gmail.com
Tel/Whatsapp (00260) 975315144
Instagram - kafueroyal
30 March 2019, 00:31
dgr416
Ruger model 77 in 338 win mag .The stainless one is indstructable and super accurate .Mine in a boyds laminated stock shoots under an inch at 200 yards with factory ammo -
30 March 2019, 03:56
DuggaBoye
When I was young, I would take an aluminum 4 gun case with 4 long guns and a handgun.
(those were the days of 100 # bags)

For those of us traveling Airlines , it is an almost impossible to manage more than two long guns, also some counties make it difficult at best to clear more than 2.

If you are committed to bringing a 500, I assume DG is planned as well as non-DG.

My first choice for a number of reasons would be a 375 as a secondary.

My second would be your (a) 300.

Beyond that , whatever light rifle you shoot well and is reliable .(308 or 6.5)
(as mentioned earlier , be certain the caliber(6.5) is approved in the hunt area.


DuggaBoye-O
NRA-Life
Whittington-Life
TSRA-Life
DRSS
DSC
HSC
SCI