'I shot a lion in Africa'

By Derek Taylor

The international scandal of South Africa's "canned" lion hunting - which allowed more than 740 cage-bred lions to be shot by tourists while waiting to be fed last year - is not over.

Last year's total has doubled since 2005 and is increasing exponentially, conservationists claim.

Another 4 000 caged lions are in the 123 breeders' supply line, according to the International Big Cats Rescue movement - and more are available over the borders in Mozambique, Zimbabwe and Namibia.


Many of those borders are porous and rarely policed, except at stolen-car-smuggling points. Locals move whatever they want across the Limpopo.

Tourists have been paying fees of between $22 000 (R181 500) and $60 000 (R495 000) for the trophy killing of a lion.

Most are not hunters, an industry insider said. "I had one of them who thought he would be allowed to shoot the beast in his feeding cage between the bars. Some don't like to get out of the vehicle to shoot. They just want the skin, the head and the boast - 'I shot a lion in Africa'."

Three years ago new legislation was passed to ameliorate this lucrative tourist attraction. Now cage-bred lions must first be freed to adapt to the wild within legal hunting properties "in an extensive wildlife system" for at least two years before being sold as easy targets.

The new law aimed at introducing the principle of a hunting "fair chase" to killing animals that had been fed by humans all their lives and kept in restricted compounds.

The SA Predator Breeders' Association and two independent breeders brought a high court action to dismiss the new legislation, pleading that it would ruin their industry and cost 4 000 people their jobs.

They lost the case. But now concerned conservationists and action groups that worked to establish the new two-years-in-the-wild clause fear it is too easy to ignore.

South Africa has a large number of new and well-intentioned laws that have proved to be unenforceable. The lack of trained and competent civil servants, corruption and an overstrained police force have already hamstrung important reforms.

Breeders

And while canned lion breeders are present in every province, last year's scores were led by North-West Province, with 637 lions out of an estimated 740 killed there. This concentration of the practice in one province argues the strength of local support in law-breaking - and easy border breaking - which will enable the $14 million-$42m (R115m-R346m) a year industry to survive.

Canned lion breeders justify their industry's survival with a number of claims.

They say they are helping to ensure the survival of the lion while the Zimbabwean army has almost wiped out their country's Big Five wild animals for their meat and hides.

Other African countries have lost the battle against poachers - they now rely on breeders to restock their parks and keep the tourists coming.

Even the Kruger National Park has problems, say the breeders. Most of their lions are tubercular and short-lived, the hunters claim. Infection-free caged-breeding can replace them.

Yes, but can't the parks take care of this themselves?

Canned lion hunting can continue on a moral basis with only six months of survival out of the cage or paddock instead of the required two years, they believe.

But others say this is a reluctant and easily faked means to save on the expensive game-proof fencing of their game farms. Also, say conservationists, it is a way of saving money because it's cheaper to feed cage-reared lions cheap abattoir scraps instead of live eland or gazelle.

Mozambique has no policed restrictions on canned lion hunting yet breeders claim lions are still thriving in the country, except where the Zimbabwean army makes incursions.

I met my first caged-lions for trophy-hunting years ago in Zambia. Some 11 of them were kept in an old wired tennis court on an unfenced farm 15km outside Lusaka.

All the lions were named Fred, the breeder explained, because that helped conceal their inevitable fates from his young children. Freds came and went and the kids lost track of their favourites.

Bob, the breeder, moved to South Africa but eventually, sickened by the business, abandoned it for specialised theme safaris - fishing and bird watching, from which he makes a comfortable living.

"What wasn't disgusting about it was just a bad-taste joke for any real hunter," he said.

Good show

"Some hero from Colorado, Texas or Sweden would turn up with lots of dollars and the compulsory .375 rifle and we always put on a good show for him."

His farm was divided into five camps of bush all encircled by dirt roads. The roads were swept smooth by towing an old tarpaulin behind a Landrover after a cage-lion was transported to one of the camps and released.

"The next morning my guys would report exactly where he was - usually just where we had left him - by checking for any tracks crossing the dirt roads.

"There he would be, waiting for someone to bring him his breakfast, while we gave the client his show in another camp - we would make him crawl around the bushes for an hour or so.

"Then we would whiz him away to follow a pretend-sighting from one of my guys.

"Finally, around lunch time we would take him up to Fred, who would walk towards us, expecting his lunch. I would cover the client from the side while he shot Fred from about thirty paces with a telescopic sight. Big deal. Clap him on the back. What a shot! What a lion! Finish off Fred if necessary.

"Then we would take him off for a good lunch while Fred went to be skinned and prepared for trophies."

Bob still believes that properly planned, sustainable "real hunting" can be part of the future of wildlife.

As the great wildlife preservation pioneer, Johnny Uys, who saved the huge Luangwa Park in Zambia from abandonment said: "Wild animals will not survive without benefit given to and value believed in by the people who live around them."

But population growth is accelerating the pressures on Africa's wildlife reserves. It is time to re-evaluate the belief that controlled trophy hunting is essential to wildlife survival.

The debate continues.

So does the killing of canned lions.

...but how do you properly age a canned lion????? Sorry!

Brett

Er, look in the file cabinet for the birth record?

Check the label for it's shoot by date?

quote:

Er, look in the file cabinet for the birth record?

But all the birth records have the name listed as "FRED".

So the interesting take away from this and a similar article on Shakaris site is that people do get deceived by this industry. For the most part they believe that they are hunting a wild lion.

If you shatter that belief BEFORE they book then you might solve the whole problem.

John

If you want to hunt wild Africa then you better get going. It won't last.

JohnHunt:

Certainly I agree with your sentiment. I think, however, that these people know full well what the circumstances are of the "execution". ( A word, I use advisedly)They want to be able to say "I shot a lion in Africa". Every single word is "true" and a total lie so far as real hunters are concerned.

While this is highly objectionable to me, it has also caused me to ponder why.
As a hunter, I obviously must consider these animals a renewable resource. Why should it matter to me whether they are essentially pen raised and slaughtered or allowed to live in a "wild" setting? Yet it does.
I think it's the fundamental dishonesty of it all. There isn't a shred of honor here. The outfitter, the "hunters," everyone is part of a conspiracy of deception.
Do I think it should be illegal? Not really. The solution isn't more laws, which would be unenforceable anyway. Louis Brandeis once said that "daylight is the best disinfectant."


"But population growth is accelerating the pressures on Africa's wildlife reserves. It is time to re-evaluate the belief that controlled trophy hunting is essential to wildlife survival."

What's up with that? It's saying that as wildlife comes under increasing pressure, we should stop doing the one thing that gives wild game enough economic value to assure its survival? Sheesh.

It's well known that I DETEST canned Lion hunting and the people who take part in it but maybe not so well known that I view the whole thing as an immense threat to ALL African hunting.

I believe that if we don't stop it, one day the antis will quite rightly use it as a weapon to beat us over the head with in an attempt to not only stop canned Lion hunting but all (African) hunting.

If we don't police ourselves, someone will do it for us and they won't be pro hunters.

If I had my way, I'd feed the Lion breeders to the Lions and then shoot the Lions because they're no possible use to man nor beast.

First read this..

http://www.shakariconnection.c...-and-wild-lions.html

Then think back to your first trip to Africa. Would you have spotted the deception?

What about that last trip to Namibia when the outfitter says a local farmer just happens to have a huge Sable bull coming into a watering hole and do you want it? Or a Leopard?

It isn't hunting when you shoot one of these farm animals. You have nothing to brag about, no great memories to speak of. You do end up with a pretty cool mount for your home.

Once you remove the word hunting from it. And the deception. The question boils down to is it okay to raise and slaughter lions as if they were domestic cows. Some will say sure some will say no.

It isn't for me.

http://forums.accuratereloadin.../5421043/m/703102845


This hunter thought he was hunting a true wild animal.

For some good insight into how this all plays out...here is a link to Pat Lefemine's (of bowsite.com) 2006 "relocated lion" hunt:

http://forums.accuratereloadin...411043/m/372100535?r

Note the "remarkable" chance sighting on Day-2


(http://www.bowsite.com/bowsite/features/livehunts/lionbuff2006/INDEX.CFM?DAY=2)

I can't find it but wasn't there a thread where 3 guys had shot something like 6 Lions in about a week and thought it was a fair chase hunt. Their comment was something like 'the most fun you can have with your pants on'?

http://forums.accuratereloadin...=504100286#504100286


Shakari,

Here is the link.

quote:

Originally posted by shakari:
I can't find it but wasn't there a thread where 3 guys had shot something like 6 Lions in about a week and thought it was a fair chase hunt. Their comment was something like 'the most fun you can have with your pants on'?

I shot two lions in less than half an hour - from the time we saw the tracks to the time they were dead! and I can assure you it was fair chase!

Kathy,

Thanks, that's the one I was thinking of.

Saeed,

I wasn't suggesting that you're shooting two in half an hour was dubious at all and I'm 110% sure that any animal you hunted would always be absolutely fair chase.

However, I'm sure you'll agree that 3 Lions and 3 Lionesses by 3 blokes in one day on a South African game farm simply has to be a tad dubious at the very least.

quote:

Originally posted by shakari:
However, I'm sure you'll agree that 3 Lions and 3 Lionesses by 3 blokes in one day on a South African game farm simply has to be a tad dubious at the very least.

You think!!!!!!

Brett

When I want a laugh, I come here and read Steve's posts, they are truly funny.

Brett,

Note the wink!

quote:

Originally posted by Saeed:
I shot two lions in less than half an hour - from the time we saw the tracks to the time they were dead! and I can assure you it was fair chase!

The difference is where and (more importantly I'll guess) when this happenned. There is a not so subtle differnece between an enclosure in RSA a couple of years ago and a wilderness concession back in the Good Old Days.

Dean