The Accurate Reloading Forums
Taste of Penguin Meat

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9811043/m/1751069182

19 August 2025, 23:41
Saeed
Taste of Penguin Meat
They were right: undercooked seal and penguin meat is a rich source of vitamin C. The problem was the taste. One polar explorer described the flavor of penguin as a mélange of “beef, an odoriferous cod fish and a canvas-backed duck, roasted in a pot, with blood and cod-liver oil mutton and Yorkshire pudding. Jack diplomatically claimed it tasted like steak.


From the book

THE LOST MEN OF Shackleton expedition


www.accuratereloading.com
Instagram : ganyana2000
20 August 2025, 04:22
Hipshoot
Funny you should mention penguins.

A small flock flew over my house just last evening. They usually don't come this far south.

Hip
20 August 2025, 06:36
lavaca
Interesting, since penguins don't fly and live in the Southern Hemisphere.
20 August 2025, 09:21
Saeed
quote:
Originally posted by lavaca:
Interesting, since penguins don't fly and live in the Southern Hemisphere.


They do.

When you have imbibed more than you should! clap


www.accuratereloading.com
Instagram : ganyana2000
20 August 2025, 09:34
Saeed
Rare seal meat.

From the same book.


With next to no coal and just twenty gallons of kerosene for heat and cooking, fuel was the most urgent concern.

Food was more plentiful, as Stenhouse had dropped off enough to last two months. Supplies left by Scott’s expeditions would last another two months. Though the bulk of the food was over a decade old, some of it was still edible. A seal colony near the hut promised a regular supply of fresh meat and blubber.

Leaving the invalids at the hut, the strongest men—Mackintosh, Jack, and Hayward—began hunting soon after their arrival. The passive Weddell seals put up little resistance. Fast and agile underwater, they were clumsy on land.

The hunter would stun the slow-moving animal with a blow to the nose, then swiftly draw a blade across the throat. It was a gruesome task. “It really is murder killing these innocent harmless brutes who roll their eyes and start with fright when they see you,” Mackintosh lamented. “At first I detested the job, especially when the seals looked beseechingly at one with their large eyes, but after starving in the tent I am afraid the tender instincts, if any, in us vanish.”


However odious the butchery, seal meat was the best medicine for their wasted bodies. After living on the limited sledging diet since January, all of the men were malnourished. Joyce’s insistence on serving the meat bloody rare ensured that the nutrients were not cooked away in the pan. The flavor was another matter. “Believe the taste is an acquired one,” wrote Jack. “Sincerely do I hope so.”


The motley assortment of leftover provisions added variety: flour, sheep’s tongues, corned beef, porridge, bottled fruit, canned salmon, sardines, dried onions, and beans. As they chipped away at the ice around the hut, odd luxuries including a leg of mutton and a Christmas pudding surfaced. Tobacco, to universal disappointment, was in short supply. Mackintosh mandated only two meals each day to conserve the stockpile, with Joyce’s specialty, scones fried in blubber, served in between.

With this regimen, the invalids slowly convalesced, though in Joyce’s words, “It was a couple of weeks before our faces straightened out again.” During their waking hours, the shuttered gloom of the hut limited activities inside.


www.accuratereloading.com
Instagram : ganyana2000
20 August 2025, 18:28
Bill/Oregon
Scones fried in blubber -- sounds very interesting.


There is hope, even when your brain tells you there isn’t.
– John Green, author
20 August 2025, 18:31
Hipshoot
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by lavaca:
Interesting, since penguins don't fly and live in the Southern Hemisphere.


They do.

When you have imbibed more than you should! clap


Boy----You guys sure fell for that one!!! archer jumping
21 August 2025, 03:08
jdollar
I tried seal once on a moose hunt in Newfoundland. It was hunted by my guide the previous year and then pickled in a Mason jar. It’s most definitely an acquired taste. Think liver with pickle seasoning. The one bite I took was not enough to acquire a taste for it…. barf


Vote Trump- Putin’s best friend…
To quote a former AND CURRENT Trumpiteer - DUMP TRUMP
25 September 2025, 08:56
lavaca
Well you got me Hip. Your post was just before I left for Africa, just back.
25 September 2025, 17:05
Michael Robinson
One hopes they at least had some salt!


Mike

Wilderness is my cathedral, and hunting is my prayer.
03 October 2025, 06:17
Navaluk
Ringed seal tastes decent. Better than wild duck for sure. Beluga whale is strangely good. I would not pass that up.
04 October 2025, 04:49
Hipshoot
Husband used to eat beef tongue for breakfast every day!

One day his wife said to him----"How can you eat something that comes out of an animals mouth every day?

He said-----Shut up and eat your sausage and eggs Honey!
11 October 2025, 09:18
lavaca
When I used to hunt ducks, I avoided shooting divers, but occasionally it happened. I'd label it "Mother in Law Meat". To discourage visits.