The Accurate Reloading Forums
Best Or Most Practical Finish
18 October 2021, 03:58
Uncle GrinchBest Or Most Practical Finish
I’m wanting to get my Star BM refinished and my first thought was Cerakote, but is it the best finish? I think it may be the most practical for everyday use and maybe the most cost effective. At $220, it’s very close to my cost of the gun, but that’s my choice.
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
18 October 2021, 08:02
dpcdIt's paint and not worth the prices some charge. I like phosphate better.
18 October 2021, 14:51
p dog shooterIs it worth refinishing most likely not.
Just use it as is and do not worry about it.
18 October 2021, 21:19
kendogquote:
Originally posted by dpcd:
It's paint and not worth the prices some charge. I like phosphate better.
This right here, all day long.
If you must spray coat it, KG Gunkote is far more user friendly and just about as tough.
18 October 2021, 21:59
Uncle GrinchI’ve been pondering on putting that much money in refinishing and since it’s almost as much as I paid for the gun, I’m having serious doubts. After all, it just going to be a knock about truck gun. Time will tell what I’m going to do.
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
18 October 2021, 23:44
rcraigquote:
Originally posted by Uncle Grinch:
I’ve been pondering on putting that much money in refinishing and since it’s almost as much as I paid for the gun, I’m having serious doubts. After all, it just going to be a knock about truck gun. Time will tell what I’m going to do.
I use a coat of Renaissance Wax for similar applications, works great, just touch it up now and then. Just think of all the money you'll save to spend on something else.
19 October 2021, 00:59
Uncle GrinchI cleaned up the Star and removed the magazine disconnect safety. Also replaced the black plastic grips with some checkered cocobolo from Century Arms. I really like these grips. They really make this old pistol shine. Kinda remind me of my old S&W M39 from years ago.
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
19 October 2021, 03:55
BobsterRustblue it and then clearcoat it with two thin coats of an automotive grade spray lacquer. Great for a truck gun that may get condensation. As the clearcoat wears simply recoat the worn areas. Looks like blue instead of paint.
Bob
www.rustblue.com19 October 2021, 04:29
rcraigNice, I like the patina, sorta like a "rat rod" look.
19 October 2021, 23:31
Uncle GrinchPatina or well worn or well carried… action is tight with very little internal wear.
Shoot Safe,
Mike
NRA Endowment Member
19 October 2021, 23:46
dpcdNow that I see it; I say, do nothing but keep it oiled.
22 October 2021, 15:03
p dog shooterquote:
Originally posted by dpcd:
Now that I see it; I say, do nothing but keep it oiled.
For sure carry as is and do not worry about it.
I have a beat up Glock 23 one of the first ones
Slide finish mostly worn lots of nicks and marks on the frame.
It is a great everyday carry gun as one does not have to worry about it.
As every day carry guns do get beat up.
28 October 2021, 01:16
AtkinsonI like it as is, I suppose in GA you should lightly oil it now and then..A good reblue would be nice if polished out properly keeping edges sharp and screw holes flat and not wallowed out, use on hones to polish for best results..Its a good hide a way gun and with todays modern 32 and 380 bullets it will get the job done pretty well..
Ray Atkinson
Atkinson Hunting Adventures
10 Ward Lane,
Filer, Idaho, 83328
208-731-4120
rayatkinsonhunting@gmail.com
09 November 2021, 05:15
rgrx1276here in humid Florida, there's very little that won't rust, especially 30 miles from the coast. Heck, my stainless guns rust... The only thing that's carried on my boat that doesn't rust is a Glock... Having a couple rifles nitrided at HM. Will report back when they've been tested.
13 November 2021, 21:46
AtkinsonFor ever day carry in hot humid climates, a standard nickel finish and expensive chrome is the best by far.
I like certain parts bead blasted the flats bright..Pistols only..Rust is a real problem so use lots of tender loving care..An honest patina is beautiful IMO, but wipe down daily and wipe with silcone cloth every evening worked for me in South Texas and Mexico...I liked the star pistol in 380 ACP with todays hollow points..The BM as I recall is the shorty model..I like any thing that resembles a 1911 and it does! as I recall...Id just leave it as is and take care of it..
Ray Atkinson
Atkinson Hunting Adventures
10 Ward Lane,
Filer, Idaho, 83328
208-731-4120
rayatkinsonhunting@gmail.com
17 November 2021, 01:57
JiriBest finish?
Hard Chrome, DLC coating, titanium nitride etc. Those modern high-tech coatings.
Here is CrN (hard chrome) on small parts and TiAlN (titanium aluminum nitride) on the main parts on my pistol.
02 December 2021, 21:08
Vol717Check out CCRrefinishing.com. They parkerize steel first, then ceracoat it. Their house black is nearly identical to rust bluing.
Quick, Cheap, or Good: Pick Two