Question for Todd E

23 April 2002, 05:20

POSEUR

Question for Todd E

Which action is stiffer the Remington M700 or the Winchester M70 Classic. Comparing long actions. You are so knowledgable about this stuff I hope you can answer my question with mathematical analysis.

Thank you,
Casey

23 April 2002, 11:19

<500 AHR>

Casey,

The M70 Winchester is by far stiffer than the M700. Gunsmith's like the M700 better because it is a no brainer to work with. It is just a "pipe" which does not require special fixtures.

Between the these two actions the M70 Classic would be the best action from a stiffness standpoint; therefore, accuracy.

Todd E

23 April 2002, 19:08

wallyw

quote:
Originally posted by CASEY:
Which action is stiffer the Remington M700 or the Winchester M70 Classic. Comparing long actions. You are so knowledgable about this stuff I hope you can answer my question with mathematical analysis.
Thank you,
Casey

Take a good look at both receivers. Remington is a simple tube. Recoil lug adds nothing to action stiffness or strength. Marine Corps now welds that lug to the action.

The Model 70 can be viewed as a tube with an integral tecoil lug and flat bottom. Much stiffer.

Wally

24 April 2002, 13:20

<500 AHR>

Casey,

To more accurately answer your question I measured a M700 LA and a M70 Classic LA and calculated their repsective Area Moments of Inertia.

Remington @ Receiver Ring = 0.1003 in ^4
Winchester @ Receiver Ring = 0.1456 in^4

The Winchester is about 45% stiffer than the Remington. The same is true at through the magazine mortise/ejection port. The difference there is that the Winchester is only about 37% stiffer than the Remington.

Todd E