The Accurate Reloading Forums
Poor groups and heat.

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/5681088631

23 July 2010, 20:04
frank4570
Poor groups and heat.
I have a Savage action. I removed the 7mm barrel and replaced it with a pre-chambered .458 win mag barrel I bought from midway. Accra glassed it, and went to load development.

After some truly terrible groups, I took my best load and waited 5 to 10 minutes for the barrel to cool between shots. Groups went down to .75 inches. It was pretty hot when I was doing this.

Is this to be expected? Anything I can do about it?

This is my first rifle project, I have been under the supervision of a local gunsmith.






Sand Creek November 29 1864
23 July 2010, 20:25
Busheler
Heat is a bane,in something wearing shy of proper stress relief. Agg's settle,once things foul a bit.

What tube? Base/rings/glass?
23 July 2010, 21:22
frank4570
Tube? I think you talking about the barrel, I don't know who makes the barrel for midway.

The scope is a nikon prostaff, I got it and the base at the same local gun shop. They sell all tactical stuff. I don't know who makes the base. It is 1 piece with the base and rings formed from one piece of beefy aluminum.
I don't believe I lapped in the rings. I should probably do that.

quote:
Originally posted by Busheler:
Heat is a bane,in something wearing shy of proper stress relief. Agg's settle,once things foul a bit.

What tube? Base/rings/glass?







Sand Creek November 29 1864
23 July 2010, 21:33
Busheler
You are in well over your head,on all counts.
23 July 2010, 22:01
butchloc
at a guess its either that the barrel is hitting the forend as it warms up and warps a bit or you have a bad barrel
23 July 2010, 22:25
frank4570
quote:
Originally posted by Busheler:
You are in well over your head,on all counts.


You're right. I'll just give up now.






Sand Creek November 29 1864
23 July 2010, 22:26
frank4570
quote:
Originally posted by butchloc:
at a guess its either that the barrel is hitting the forend as it warms up and warps a bit or you have a bad barrel


Thanks. I'll check the gap and the bedding.






Sand Creek November 29 1864
24 July 2010, 00:33
Westpac
quote:
Originally posted by frank4570:
I have a Savage action. I removed the 7mm barrel and replaced it with a pre-chambered .458 win mag barrel I bought from midway. Accra glassed it, and went to load development.

After some truly terrible groups, I took my best load and waited 5 to 10 minutes for the barrel to cool between shots. Groups went down to .75 inches. It was pretty hot when I was doing this.

Is this to be expected? Anything I can do about it?

This is my first rifle project, I have been under the supervision of a local gunsmith.


Yes heat can do it.

If you cut a rifle barrel into 6 inch sections and measure the wall thickness in all the sections, you will discover that the wall thickness varies from one end of the barrel to the other.

If you kept track of what location the wall was at it's thinnest point, you could somewhat predict which way your groups would move as the barrel got hot. Of course if the barrel is floating you can accomplish the same thing by watching which way it moves as it heats up.

This is one reason a lot of rifle perform their best when their barrels are free floating. It gives the barrel some room to move without compounding the problem further by making contact with the forearm.

Making sure your barrel isn't colliding with the forend as things heat up would be my first suggestion.


_______________________________________________________________________________
This is my rifle, there are many like it but this one is mine. My rifle is my best friend, it is my life.
24 July 2010, 00:43
Busheler
You girls are a RIOT!
24 July 2010, 04:37
frank4570
Thanks. I'll put on the Nightforce just to knock out that variable. Then I'll check the clearance as the barrel heats up.The barrel is bedded up to the end of the chamber and floats beyond that.

quote:
Originally posted by Westpac:
quote:
Originally posted by frank4570:
I have a Savage action. I removed the 7mm barrel and replaced it with a pre-chambered .458 win mag barrel I bought from midway. Accra glassed it, and went to load development.

After some truly terrible groups, I took my best load and waited 5 to 10 minutes for the barrel to cool between shots. Groups went down to .75 inches. It was pretty hot when I was doing this.

Is this to be expected? Anything I can do about it?

This is my first rifle project, I have been under the supervision of a local gunsmith.


Yes heat can do it.

If you cut a rifle barrel into 6 inch sections and measure the wall thickness in all the sections, you will discover that the wall thickness varies from one end of the barrel to the other.

If you kept track of what location the wall was at it's thinnest point, you could somewhat predict which way your groups would move as the barrel got hot. Of course if the barrel is floating you can accomplish the same thing by watching which way it moves as it heats up.

This is one reason a lot of rifle perform their best when their barrels are free floating. It gives the barrel some room to move without compounding the problem further by making contact with the forearm.

Making sure your barrel isn't colliding with the forend as things heat up would be my first suggestion.







Sand Creek November 29 1864
28 July 2010, 06:19
majestrate98
If you bought the barrel from MidwayUSA, you have my sincere regrets. Most likely it is an Adams and Bennett barrel. If you do some research, you will not find too many complimentary statements about those barrels from anybody interested in accuracy. Don't read only the reviews on Midway, they're biased. Try other sites, like this forum. Unfortunately, I did my research after I got the barrel.

With the A&B barrel, my best accuracy was 0.75" but that was only twice out of over 100 groups (500+ rounds). Most groups were over 1.5"! I finally had the barrel replaced with a Shilen and group sizes shrunk to a range from 0.60" to 0.90" - all the time, not just once in a while - with every bullet fed through it. All my groups are five shot groups, so barrel heat does become a major factor. This just further reinforces the fact that a top quality barrel will always perform. Overall, I spent twice the money on gunsmithing not to mention the time and ammo wasted.

As they say, the sweet taste of a low price is quickly replaced with the bitter taste of poor quality.


Sneak close, aim small, hit hard!
** NRA Lifetime Member **
28 July 2010, 10:12
Westpac
quote:
Originally posted by majestrate98:
This just further reinforces the fact that a top quality barrel will always perform.


A top quality barrel is only as good as the installation. A poor barrel expertly installed is still a poor barrel. A great barrel poorly installed is a hanging offense. Big Grin


_______________________________________________________________________________
This is my rifle, there are many like it but this one is mine. My rifle is my best friend, it is my life.
30 July 2010, 10:20
majestrate98
quote:
Originally posted by Westpac:
A top quality barrel is only as good as the installation. A poor barrel expertly installed is still a poor barrel. A great barrel poorly installed is a hanging offense. Big Grin


A very true statement that too often goes unstated!


Sneak close, aim small, hit hard!
** NRA Lifetime Member **
30 July 2010, 18:38
Boss Hoss
The approach you used to install the new tube does not lend itself to accuracy. There are no free lunches so to speak --- have a good Smith install good tube and go from there.
31 July 2010, 02:16
wyoske
dont underestimate the effects of heat on yourself, ignore the bullshit, have some fun and learn something
31 July 2010, 03:23
Doc224/375
An along comes Straight Barrel Systems Voodoo Magic !. http://www.teludynetech.com/

I'm in the process of selecting one of my half ass shooters and making a Carbonfiber tube with a

Ceramic Boron spider insert bound by a lightweight slurry epoxy matrix !.

We shall see if my technology works on Rifle barrels as well as it did in Scram Jet exhaust ducts !.

Light weight Super rigidity with unbelievable heat dissipation .

salute archer archer
01 August 2010, 21:10
frank4570
Thanks a lot for the input. I'll do as you suggested and read reviews on the barrel.

There were 2 major points behind me building this rifle. One was to start learning how to do this stuff, I have actually do it and make some mistakes in order to learn. I don't know anybody who was born knowing how to be a gunsmith, luckily I have a gunsmith for guidance.

The other point was to see if I liked the .458 win mag as a cartridge. And I have to say, for my style of hunting, I just love it. If I find that this barrel just won't shoot, I'll probably buy a good barrel.


quote:
Originally posted by majestrate98:
If you bought the barrel from MidwayUSA, you have my sincere regrets. Most likely it is an Adams and Bennett barrel. If you do some research, you will not find too many complimentary statements about those barrels from anybody interested in accuracy. Don't read only the reviews on Midway, they're biased. Try other sites, like this forum. Unfortunately, I did my research after I got the barrel.

With the A&B barrel, my best accuracy was 0.75" but that was only twice out of over 100 groups (500+ rounds). Most groups were over 1.5"! I finally had the barrel replaced with a Shilen and group sizes shrunk to a range from 0.60" to 0.90" - all the time, not just once in a while - with every bullet fed through it. All my groups are five shot groups, so barrel heat does become a major factor. This just further reinforces the fact that a top quality barrel will always perform. Overall, I spent twice the money on gunsmithing not to mention the time and ammo wasted.

As they say, the sweet taste of a low price is quickly replaced with the bitter taste of poor quality.







Sand Creek November 29 1864
01 August 2010, 21:12
frank4570
quote:
Originally posted by frank4570:
Thanks a lot for the input. I'll do as you suggested and read reviews on the barrel.

There were 2 major points behind me building this rifle. One was to start learning how to do this stuff, I have actually do it and make some mistakes in order to learn. I don't know anybody who was born knowing how to be a gunsmith, luckily I have a gunsmith for guidance.

The other point was to see if I liked the .458 win mag as a cartridge. And I have to say, for my style of hunting, I just love it. If I find that this barrel just won't shoot, I'll probably buy a good barrel.
Unfortunately, nobody around her shoots anything like this, so I'm kind of on my own with this big cartridge.


quote:
Originally posted by majestrate98:
If you bought the barrel from MidwayUSA, you have my sincere regrets. Most likely it is an Adams and Bennett barrel. If you do some research, you will not find too many complimentary statements about those barrels from anybody interested in accuracy. Don't read only the reviews on Midway, they're biased. Try other sites, like this forum. Unfortunately, I did my research after I got the barrel.

With the A&B barrel, my best accuracy was 0.75" but that was only twice out of over 100 groups (500+ rounds). Most groups were over 1.5"! I finally had the barrel replaced with a Shilen and group sizes shrunk to a range from 0.60" to 0.90" - all the time, not just once in a while - with every bullet fed through it. All my groups are five shot groups, so barrel heat does become a major factor. This just further reinforces the fact that a top quality barrel will always perform. Overall, I spent twice the money on gunsmithing not to mention the time and ammo wasted.

As they say, the sweet taste of a low price is quickly replaced with the bitter taste of poor quality.







Sand Creek November 29 1864