The Accurate Reloading Forums
How would you handle the pitting on this barrel…?

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/3991058082

14 March 2025, 19:15
Blackbart2
How would you handle the pitting on this barrel…?
Guys:

Have an otherwise very nice Ithaca 37, that has some small areas of pitting on the barrel. Fairly shallow, but, I think, too deep to polish out. Been looking into/reading about laser welding. That seems like a viable options.

Would appreciate thoughts and ideas from experienced metal finishers. Will attempt to post pics.
14 March 2025, 19:18
Blackbart2

14 March 2025, 19:26
Blackbart2
Whoa, that a big pic. Sorry about that.
15 March 2025, 02:58
slivers
Draw filing before polishing seems to work every time! Just don't dig a hole, needs to be blended and uniform. Doesn't take some high tech welding procedure, just manual labor (who, by the way, was not Mexican General). I polish most shotgun barrels by hand, as they are so soft. More "manual labor".


15 March 2025, 04:04
dpcd
You need to resize your pictures; you are in HUGE mode. All I see is a blur.
Ithaca 37: Not worth much; shoot it as is. or get another one.
Do NOT weld on a barrel!
15 March 2025, 04:52
rcraig
quote:
Originally posted by slivers:
Draw filing before polishing seems to work every time! Just don't dig a hole, needs to be blended and uniform. Doesn't take some high tech welding procedure, just manual labor (who, by the way, was not Mexican General). I polish most shotgun barrels by hand, as they are so soft. More "manual labor".
\

This. Or buy a used barrel, check FleaBay.


Old Corps
Semper Fi
FJB
15 March 2025, 16:19
p dog shooter
quote:
Ithaca 37: Not worth much; shoot it as is. or get another one.
Do NOT weld on a barrel!


This
15 March 2025, 17:13
Steve Bertram
quote:
Originally posted by p dog shooter:
quote:
Ithaca 37: Not worth much; shoot it as is. or get another one.
Do NOT weld on a barrel!


This


The HAZ on modern micro-welders makes the above statements dated. You can literally hold the piece you are welding and touch it immediately afterwards and not burn yourself. I micro-welder barrel flaws regularly.


That said, for the above barrel draw filing would likely get you where you need to be. The barrel wall thickness on a 37 is quite generous.
15 March 2025, 21:36
Bill Leeper
I have not seen a picture of the pitting (just a large expanse of gray), but it is likely it can be filed and polished out. Regards, Bill
15 March 2025, 21:40
2152hq
I take it that the pitting is way out at the muzzle end,,,if that is the Front Sight Bead and the back end of a Poly Choke in the pic.

Filing/polishing it out would be my first choice.
The bbls are generally stout. Measure the wall first, then take into consideration it's out at the muzzle (if I'm correct in my assuption above).

Laser Welding is certainly an option. Way out there and being a shotgun as well (pressures).

Lastly, and this would be some work.
Move the Poly choke back the amt required that removes the pitted section of bbl.
Some Polys are hard soldered onto the turned muzzle. Others (more common) are threaded onto the muzzle.
If threaded, cut the threaded section off just behind the poly body and re-solder into the cut down bbl with a counter bored joint up close to the polychoke body. You won't notice the joint that way.

You will loose maybe 1 1/2" of bbl length I'd guess.
16 March 2025, 00:50
eagle27
Resized image, pitting is close to muzzle/polychoke, draw file and replace Bradley front bead, it will be like new.


16 March 2025, 07:33
Blackbart2
Guys-

Thanks for the inputs and advice. Also thanks for the resizing!

Yes, it is towards the end of the barrel near the polychoke with the broken Bradley…..hood eyes there!

At SB mentions, the Laser/micro welding techniques have changed the game a bit here. I have reached out to fellow that does this to get his thoughts. If the cost is not unreasonable I may very well go that route just to try it out.

This particular one is a pre-war 16 ga so not a throw away to me at least. Also barrels don’t interchange on these so a new barrel isn’t cost effective either.

Thanks. Bob
02 April 2025, 07:00
ElCaballero
Chicks dig scars! I'd just hunt with it and be happy!


As a general rule, people are nuts!
spinksranch.com
09 April 2025, 06:28
Vol717
It's a 37 with a poly choke. 0000 steel wool, cold blue and oil. Then hunt with it!


Quick, Cheap, or Good: Pick Two
09 April 2025, 17:05
clowdis
The pits look too deep to me. I think maybe filing them completely out will thin the steel too much or leave a flat spot on the barrel that would be hard to hide. Just shoot it.


"Peace is that brief glorious moment in history when everybody stands around reloading".