The Accurate Reloading Forums
That sucks

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9411043/m/3471030132

09 April 2017, 04:52
Magnum Hunter1
That sucks
Bad deal.
Broke my Mauser bolt shroud.
Must have had a hairline crack.
Just when everything was going well.
Dang
09 April 2017, 05:59
dpcd
Interesting. Was it re-hardend after machining? If so, that is what caused it.
09 April 2017, 06:14
RogerR
It looks to have failed at the forward edge of the horizontal cut made by a slitting saw. The slitting saw blade typically has alternating off set teeth to create a kerf, and the edges are very sharp leading to a sharp 90 degree corner. Perhaps putting a small radius in that corner would reduce the risk of this failure. I would be interested to know if that shroud was "heat treated" after machining. Obviously brittle, decarbonized steel from "burning" or hardened but not tempered steel might contribute to that failure.

I believe that is a Chapman kit, and I have only used Wisner's. Mr Wisner advised me to aneal, machine, then heat, quence and draw the 96 shroud but he stated the 98 had enough material and re heat treating was not needed. I wonder if Mr Wisner or any of the gunsmith's who install this kit frequently have seen this failure?

Of course the good news is the lever, spring and plunger look fine, and a surplus shroud is inexpensive. I bit of time on the mill and you will be good to go!

Ed: Oops, I was typing and dpcd beat me to it on the heating
09 April 2017, 07:59
dpcd
That is why I asked; I have made many of these, and I never try to re heat treat them; they don't need it. I use a sharp cornered mill cutter too.
Whoever did this one didn't draw it back enough. Probably.
09 April 2017, 17:38
Jim Kobe
I'll agree also, don't think any of mine have ever broken like that. I have some made up if you need a replacement.


Jim Kobe
10841 Oxborough Ave So
Bloomington MN 55437
952.884.6031
Professional member American Custom Gunmakers Guild

09 April 2017, 18:11
Magnum Hunter1
Don't know about the heat treat but it seemed pretty hard.

Jim, PM me and let me know how much you would need for a replacement.
I have some extra shrouds laying around so I could send one if need be.

The odd thing about this shroud was I had it done a few years ago for a bolt that had a swept back handle. Recently I decided to put it on another bolt so I could have a straight handle. Oddly, it wouldn't screw into any other bolt body. It was truly weird. It would start to screw in but stop. I measured every contact point I could and could not come up with a problem.
09 April 2017, 20:07
dpcd
Likely your stop plumber; the one that keeps the bolt from opening when the safety is on, was out too far and didn't allow the shroud to turn in all the way in the other bolt. Fix is to shorten the plunger. It happens; tolerance stack up.
10 April 2017, 05:35
Magnum Hunter1
dcpd.
Thanks for the suggestion. Unfortunately it wouldn't screw in with the shroud stripped. That shroud would only work with one bolt body.
Several other shrouds screwed onto the bolt I was trying to use this one on with no problem.
10 April 2017, 06:20
Steve E.
Don't believe I've seen one split like that.

Steve.......


NRA Patron Life Member
GOA Life Member
North American Hunting Club Life Member
USAF Veteran
14 April 2017, 00:50
Atkinson
Looks to be a Mauser, they are a dime a dozen..so all is not lost.


Ray Atkinson
Atkinson Hunting Adventures
10 Ward Lane,
Filer, Idaho, 83328
208-731-4120

rayatkinsonhunting@gmail.com
14 April 2017, 17:18
Jim Kobe
You have a very sharp eye Ray!


Jim Kobe
10841 Oxborough Ave So
Bloomington MN 55437
952.884.6031
Professional member American Custom Gunmakers Guild

14 April 2017, 19:21
J Wisner
A couple of things going on there.

Yes looks like the sleeve was reheat treated but not tempered back. So was hard not tough causing the fracture.

I have gotten to the point years ago that I simply temper all the M98 sleeves back to about 40 - 42 Rc and then use a carbide slitting saw, and use really good drills and taps. At that hardness the sleeve is tough but machinable, with little chance of breakage down the road.

Recently I picked up a bunch of M98 sleeves, almost 200 pieces, a hodge poge of Pre WW1 and Pre WW2 and some post war FN's. Those post war FN's have slightly different specs on the hollow mill cut and thread OD vs pitch. The FN sleeves will not thread into a Arg 1909 or CZ 24 bolt, HMMM.

I reset them up and had to recut the hollow mill cut on all those sleeves, they were from .005" to .010" undersize, and would rub on the OD of the rear of the bolts. OK so after recutting now about half would thread into the CZ bolt 1 - 2 turns.

I am now recutting the threads on those post war FN sleeves. Again they are oversize just enough to give the normal guy problems.

Could be that was one of those post war FN sleeves.

Jim Wisner