The Accurate Reloading Forums
Trophy Fee(s)

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/8521043/m/7361046862

18 December 2021, 11:44
458Win
Trophy Fee(s)
quote:
Originally posted by Fourtyonesix:
I have checked references of a client before. They tell me two or three horror stories and I email the guides they hunted with to find out the other side. That’s a red flag to me when I hear multiple bad stories in a row…they all only have one common denominator. Lol


I wasn't divulging my secrets


Anyone who claims the 30-06 is ineffective has either not tried one, or is unwittingly commenting on their own marksmanship
Phil Shoemaker
Alaska Master guide
FAA Master pilot
NRA Benefactor www.grizzlyskinsofalaska.com
18 December 2021, 20:14
Fourtyonesix
I guess mines not a secret. Lol


Master guide #212
Black River Hunting Camps llc
www.alaska-bearhunting.com
20 December 2021, 02:45
Steve Ahrenberg
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by Alaskan Sourdough:
quote:
Originally posted by Howard:
Phil tu2

What you say about the time for pack out etc makes sense. Considering the logistics of AK hunting I’d find it reasonable and expected that this time takes away from client “hunting” time.

It’s all in clearly communicating expectations on both sides.

My conclusion here is that “trophy fee” doesn’t have a standard definition and specifics need to be obtained from the outfitter in question.

Howard.


Just aware that you may have "Clearly Communicated Expectations" With the Guide who signed the "contract" between you and him. Likely no problems if he/she is actually the person guiding you in the field. That might not work, if you end up in the field with a guide he hired. It could be different then the agreement he/she has with the guide hired.


Shouldn’t the outfitter make sure that the actual guide is well aware of the clients desires??


Absolutely! The guides in the field work directly under the guide/outfitter who signed the contract and Is legally responsible for their conduct. And state law requires the guide/outfitter be in the game unit while the hunt is in progress.

I would say in the industry it's about 50/50 if the outfitter is also guiding clients on hunts themselves. But they have to be in close proximity and personally talk with the client to make sure he was satisfied and sign the end of the hunt report!


Phil,

I've never been presented a hunter satisfaction report?


Formerly "Nganga"
20 December 2021, 09:58
458Win
quote:
Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by Alaskan Sourdough:
quote:
Originally posted by Howard:
Phil tu2

What you say about the time for pack out etc makes sense. Considering the logistics of AK hunting I’d find it reasonable and expected that this time takes away from client “hunting” time.

It’s all in clearly communicating expectations on both sides.

My conclusion here is that “trophy fee” doesn’t have a standard definition and specifics need to be obtained from the outfitter in question.

Howard.


Just aware that you may have "Clearly Communicated Expectations" With the Guide who signed the "contract" between you and him. Likely no problems if he/she is actually the person guiding you in the field. That might not work, if you end up in the field with a guide he hired. It could be different then the agreement he/she has with the guide hired.


Shouldn’t the outfitter make sure that the actual guide is well aware of the clients desires??


Absolutely! The guides in the field work directly under the guide/outfitter who signed the contract and Is legally responsible for their conduct. And state law requires the guide/outfitter be in the game unit while the hunt is in progress.

I would say in the industry it's about 50/50 if the outfitter is also guiding clients on hunts themselves. But they have to be in close proximity and personally talk with the client to make sure he was satisfied and sign the end of the hunt report!


Phil,

I've never been presented a hunter satisfaction report?


When was the last time you hunted with a guide in Alaska?
And with whom ? Those laws have been in effect for over a dozen years


Anyone who claims the 30-06 is ineffective has either not tried one, or is unwittingly commenting on their own marksmanship
Phil Shoemaker
Alaska Master guide
FAA Master pilot
NRA Benefactor www.grizzlyskinsofalaska.com
21 December 2021, 21:32
Fourtyonesix
quote:
Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by Alaskan Sourdough:
quote:
Originally posted by Howard:
Phil tu2

What you say about the time for pack out etc makes sense. Considering the logistics of AK hunting I’d find it reasonable and expected that this time takes away from client “hunting” time.

It’s all in clearly communicating expectations on both sides.

My conclusion here is that “trophy fee” doesn’t have a standard definition and specifics need to be obtained from the outfitter in question.

Howard.


Just aware that you may have "Clearly Communicated Expectations" With the Guide who signed the "contract" between you and him. Likely no problems if he/she is actually the person guiding you in the field. That might not work, if you end up in the field with a guide he hired. It could be different then the agreement he/she has with the guide hired.


Shouldn’t the outfitter make sure that the actual guide is well aware of the clients desires??


Absolutely! The guides in the field work directly under the guide/outfitter who signed the contract and Is legally responsible for their conduct. And state law requires the guide/outfitter be in the game unit while the hunt is in progress.

I would say in the industry it's about 50/50 if the outfitter is also guiding clients on hunts themselves. But they have to be in close proximity and personally talk with the client to make sure he was satisfied and sign the end of the hunt report!


Phil,

I've never been presented a hunter satisfaction report?


On our hunt report we are required to do a follow up with the client I believe might be what your calling the satisfaction report. It’s not a formal form just a conversation that takes place.


Master guide #212
Black River Hunting Camps llc
www.alaska-bearhunting.com
21 December 2021, 23:58
Steve Ahrenberg
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by Alaskan Sourdough:
quote:
Originally posted by Howard:
Phil tu2

What you say about the time for pack out etc makes sense. Considering the logistics of AK hunting I’d find it reasonable and expected that this time takes away from client “hunting” time.

It’s all in clearly communicating expectations on both sides.

My conclusion here is that “trophy fee” doesn’t have a standard definition and specifics need to be obtained from the outfitter in question.

Howard.


Just aware that you may have "Clearly Communicated Expectations" With the Guide who signed the "contract" between you and him. Likely no problems if he/she is actually the person guiding you in the field. That might not work, if you end up in the field with a guide he hired. It could be different then the agreement he/she has with the guide hired.


Shouldn’t the outfitter make sure that the actual guide is well aware of the clients desires??


Absolutely! The guides in the field work directly under the guide/outfitter who signed the contract and Is legally responsible for their conduct. And state law requires the guide/outfitter be in the game unit while the hunt is in progress.

I would say in the industry it's about 50/50 if the outfitter is also guiding clients on hunts themselves. But they have to be in close proximity and personally talk with the client to make sure he was satisfied and sign the end of the hunt report!


Phil,

I've never been presented a hunter satisfaction report?


When was the last time you hunted with a guide in Alaska?
And with whom ? Those laws have been in effect for over a dozen years


Been a while I guess. I hunted Deadman's Bay with Tom Kirstein in 98, unsuccessfully. Then sort of a make up deal at his Peninsula camp at Ugashik in 99'

Then I did a great Moose Hunt around Farewell Lake on the Kuskokwim in 2001. (Cathy Frost)

Dall Sheep with John Peterson in 2012 I believe? On that one, I did get a questionnaire from the agent (here) that I refused to fill out.


Formerly "Nganga"
02 January 2022, 13:05
458Win
quote:
Originally posted by Fourtyonesix:
quote:
Originally posted by Steve Ahrenberg:
quote:
Originally posted by 458Win:
quote:
Originally posted by Saeed:
quote:
Originally posted by Alaskan Sourdough:
quote:
Originally posted by Howard:
Phil tu2

What you say about the time for pack out etc makes sense. Considering the logistics of AK hunting I’d find it reasonable and expected that this time takes away from client “hunting” time.

It’s all in clearly communicating expectations on both sides.

My conclusion here is that “trophy fee” doesn’t have a standard definition and specifics need to be obtained from the outfitter in question.

Howard.


Just aware that you may have "Clearly Communicated Expectations" With the Guide who signed the "contract" between you and him. Likely no problems if he/she is actually the person guiding you in the field. That might not work, if you end up in the field with a guide he hired. It could be different then the agreement he/she has with the guide hired.


Shouldn’t the outfitter make sure that the actual guide is well aware of the clients desires??


Absolutely! The guides in the field work directly under the guide/outfitter who signed the contract and Is legally responsible for their conduct. And state law requires the guide/outfitter be in the game unit while the hunt is in progress.

I would say in the industry it's about 50/50 if the outfitter is also guiding clients on hunts themselves. But they have to be in close proximity and personally talk with the client to make sure he was satisfied and sign the end of the hunt report!


Phil,

I've never been presented a hunter satisfaction report?


On our hunt report we are required to do a follow up with the client I believe might be what your calling the satisfaction report. It’s not a formal form just a conversation that takes place.


It is a LEGAL REQUIREMENT for the guide who booked the hunt to fill out the SFR/end of hunt report and personally ask the client how satisfied they were with the hunt and guide who assisted them in the field !

The law has been in effect for many years and was meant to make sure the claims of malfeasance like Alaskan Sourdough claim are addressed !


Anyone who claims the 30-06 is ineffective has either not tried one, or is unwittingly commenting on their own marksmanship
Phil Shoemaker
Alaska Master guide
FAA Master pilot
NRA Benefactor www.grizzlyskinsofalaska.com