14 December 2024, 08:45
buckstixJ.W. Tolley shotgun turns out to be a Double Rifle
J.W. Tolley shotgun turns out to be a Double Rifle
When searching auctions for good deals, it pays to read past the heading and read the detail description.
This was the case when I saw a heading that read; "J. W. Tolly Rotary-Underlever Hammergun SxS Shotgun 500 Black Powder Express"... but the detail description read;
"J.W. Tolley Rotary Underlever 500 Black Powder Express Double rifle"When the auction ended I was the high bidder at less than 1/2 the low estimate. Take a look .... what do you think?
http://www.buckstix.com/buckpics/500t-000.jpg
.
.
.
14 December 2024, 19:11
dougfinnYou scored on this one. Looks to be in excellent condition, and an interesting calibre as well. Congratulations.
15 December 2024, 01:50
mt AlI think you did really well! Can't wait to read a report on it and congrats on getting it at a great price.
08 January 2025, 09:07
buckstixHello all, I got the double in hand today. First thing I did was to look down the barrels .... there is rifling ... its not a shotgun.

The chambers and the rifling were MINT. But when I inserted a 500 bpe cartridge into the chambers, it was way too loose. The chambers were bigger. Turns out this is NOT a 500 bpe. after all, its the larger 577-500 No. 2 bpe. Take a look at the difference between the two cartridges. I have loaded some ammo and a field test will follow. .... Let me know what you think?
http://www.buckstix.com/buckpics/500vs577-000.jpg
.
.
.
08 January 2025, 16:09
p dog shooterYou do buy some interesting stuff
27 January 2025, 22:02
AtkinsonBack in the day, the pre double rifle days I almost bought the same gun for $500 in minty condition. Back then you could buy any double rifle for a pittance as they were all wall hangers, I had a H&H double I paid $1500 for and sold for $2500 plus..Wish I had bought a hundred of them, and sold them 5 years ago!!..
28 January 2025, 18:11
buckstixYes, me too. But I wasn't into double rifles back then.
28 January 2025, 22:34
sroseBuckstix,
I have a Purdey 577-500 No.2 if you are interested in another double. Have dies and brass also. PM me if you would like photos.
Sam
05 May 2025, 11:16
carpediem4570What a neat find. Congratulations.
I am looking forward to the after action report from the range.
Kind regards,
Carpediem
11 May 2025, 00:08
Dutch44Great find Buckstix. I know you'll enjoy shooting it.
11 May 2025, 14:14
buckstixquote:
Originally posted by Dutch44:
Great find Buckstix. I know you'll enjoy shooting it.
Hello Dutch44,
the weather is finally getting warmer so range test will come soon.