The Accurate Reloading Forums
Why do we use brass jags and brushes?

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/645100744/m/7781067231

17 May 2010, 04:56
Mort Canard
Why do we use brass jags and brushes?
I was talking to a young shooter the other day and he said he was having trouble cleaning his first centerfire rifle. He was using Sweets and patch after patch was coming out blue. Which meant there was still copper in the bore, right? I told him years ago on my first 30-06 I had been having the same problem till it occurred to me that the brass jag might be turning the Sweets soaked patches blue. I simply dug out a cheap plastic jag and PRESTO, no more blue!

This kind of makes me wonder why we don't use aluminum jags or some other metal that is not attacked by the same solvents that we use on the copper deposits in the barrels. The same goes for the bronze bore brushes that we use to scrub the copper deposits out of our rifle barrels. Trying to remove copper with a brush that has significant amounts of copper in the bristles????

Does this seem a little wacky to anyone else? bewildered


*******************************************************
For every action, there is an equal and opposite malfunction.
17 May 2010, 05:35
ted thorn
Seems Midway is marketing a nickle plated jag just for this reason.


________________________________________________
Maker of The Frankenstud Sling Keeper
Proudly made in the USA
Acepting all forms of payment
17 May 2010, 08:52
wasbeeman
Don't bronze brushes and jags pre-date using costic chemicals to clean bores? When I still had hair, about all you had was Hoppes and 3 in 1 oil.
And the jags and brushes wouldn't mar a steel barrel. You now have plastic brushes and jags and eyelets that are pretty stout.
Would nickel plating be harder than barrel steel??


Aim for the exit hole
17 May 2010, 11:19
guncurtis2
I have found a miracle cure for copper fouling. The KG products are amazing! I have had guns that took hours with sweets to remove the copper (and i had a nylon bore brush so that was not the culprit), but with the KG products i have seen barrels with similar amounts of fouling cleen in only a few minutes. They have a series of product, including a polish, that work well.

In my GP100 I shot a couple barnes bullets that left pretty hefty fouling. Used thes products, including the polish and the next time I shot barnes, probably 4 times as many bullets, and very little fouling. Great products.


Curtis
18 May 2010, 03:55
ted thorn
quote:
Originally posted by wasbeeman:
Would nickel plating be harder than barrel steel??


No


________________________________________________
Maker of The Frankenstud Sling Keeper
Proudly made in the USA
Acepting all forms of payment
23 May 2010, 03:59
amamnn
Why would he be using Sweet's unless he had already inspected the bore and found a copper fouling problem? And______________even so--why not use JB and do it right?


If the enemy is in range, so are you. - Infantry manual
03 June 2010, 15:16
BNagel
Brass is softer than barrels and we usually read and follow instructions / warnings / cautions provided by manufacturers, one of which addresses chemical interactions. Some, however, live by monkey see / monkey do. Life is about learning...


_______________________


21 June 2010, 03:26
Oddbod
quote:
Originally posted by amamnn:
Why would he be using Sweet's unless he had already inspected the bore and found a copper fouling problem? And______________even so--why not use JB and do it right?


I for one don't want to use an abrasive in my barrels & JB is just that - no matter how "mild" they say it is.
21 June 2010, 09:52
wasbeeman
JB is indeed an abrasive; however, I believe it is made from wheat chaff or some such and the abrasiveness comes from the silica that is drawn into the plant as it grows. I think you would have to scrub a barrel for a long, long time before you got a measureable amount of wear.
Me?? I use it all. Smiler clean your barrel really good with the chemicals and then give it a go with JB if you want to feel what a really slick barrel feels like. Wink


Aim for the exit hole
05 August 2010, 02:49
butchlambert
Contrary to the post above, nickle plating is much harder than barrel steel. Most barrel steels are 30RC +or-. Bronze brushes with a bronze core are the best. I use stainless jags. Your arm will fall off before JB or Isso will wear anything.
Butch
28 November 2010, 14:22
44magLeo
Aluminum is a soft metal. It can get imbedded with grit that can wear a bore. Brass is harder and won't get grit imbedded. The brass is softer than the steel so it will wear before the bore.
I use a good brass rod on my rifles and an aluminum rod on my shotguns.


The only way to know if you can do a thing is to do it.
30 November 2010, 00:45
DuggaBoye
quote:
Originally posted by guncurtis2:
I have found a miracle cure for copper fouling. The KG products are amazing! I have had guns that took hours with sweets to remove the copper (and i had a nylon bore brush so that was not the culprit), but with the KG products i have seen barrels with similar amounts of fouling cleen in only a few minutes. They have a series of product, including a polish, that work well.

In my GP100 I shot a couple barnes bullets that left pretty hefty fouling. Used thes products, including the polish and the next time I shot barnes, probably 4 times as many bullets, and very little fouling. Great products.


I have also become a KG -12 fan.

Much easier on my hands and arms,
due to much less scrubbing.


DuggaBoye-O
NRA-Life
Whittington-Life
TSRA-Life
DRSS
DSC
HSC
SCI