The Accurate Reloading Forums
Re: Best .270 bullet for less meat damage on roedeeer?

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/5421043/m/654104611

30 June 2004, 11:29
Niels
Re: Best .270 bullet for less meat damage on roedeeer?
Just- another- norwegian

Thanks for your reply. That is the good stuff. I have never tried the Scirocco. Now I'll wait 'till I go reddeer hunting again.

Niels
30 June 2004, 11:20
Niels
Tiggertate... I have neither a Velocity problem nor a bullet problem.
I have loaded down and up for whatever purpose I needed a bullet for.
But I'll tell you what... I'd really like if you please put in the facts I am asking for.

Best regards Niels
02 July 2004, 04:13
1894
You will certainly have to wait to try out a GS - site average appears to be 2 years from ordering (and paying) to delivery!
02 July 2004, 04:40
500grains
You could try out some cast lead bullets at reduced velocity (1500 fps).

Or you could use heavy, controlled expansion bullets at under 2700 fps.
02 July 2004, 09:06
Pete E
Dakor,

Welcome to the thread!

I am not sure what size Whitetails run in your area but where I stalk a decent adult Roebuck is going to weigh between 30lbs and 40lbs hanging up in the larder. Thats gutted, head and feet off, but skin on. There is a size variation across the UK and Europe, but you will get more Roe dressing out under 30lb than over 40lbs I bet.

I may be wrong, but I suspect that is about half to three quaters the size of a Coues deer?

From what I have read, your Whitetail are typically about the same size of our Fallow, Sika or Red depending on the habitat in each case.

Regards,

Pete
02 July 2004, 07:01
justanothernorwegian
I have the GS sitting on my loading bench... They look sexy! Will try the HP and the HV in both 300wsm, and 375wby. I have not been able to get my chronograph set up lately, will find the right velocity before I start messing with expansion tests in wet telephone directories. Fun!
02 July 2004, 05:30
dakor
Well I live in the USA and have never shot a Roe Deer but have shot whitetails wich look about the same to me. In a 270 with a 130gr Winchester Silver tip going 2900fps the bullet seems to go in about the size of a dime and comes out about like a Penny nice little round hole not much meat damage. Another good one is the 130gr Partition going around 3000 fps seems to do about the same and a 140gr Barnes X at 2877 fps is again about the same. If you want to insure that a bullet will not fragment and send chuncks of lead through meat if it hits something hard I would use the 130gr or 140gr Barnes X or the New 130gr Barnes TSX in the 2900 to 3000 fps range. Hope this helps.