The Accurate Reloading Forums
Re: Diamond vs Arkansas which is better and why?

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/5021043/m/862109711

13 October 2004, 15:08
ASS_CLOWN
Re: Diamond vs Arkansas which is better and why?
Gentlemen,

Thank you for your comments. I was just contemplating the purchase of the exact Japanese water stone combination DJP mentioned. I will have to think about it somemore (you know old dog new tricks).

I guess I can see myself doing one of the following:

1.) 750 grit diamond for roughing, and an Arkansas black or translucent bench stone for finishing.

2.) The 750 diamond again for roughing and then a set of Japanese water stones (1000 & 6000 grits).

I need new stones, I am too damned embarrassed to explain why.

Thanks again.

ASS_CLOWN
14 October 2004, 01:34
Jiri
I sharpen on DMT two side folder, first Fine, then ExtraFine (if knife is not totaly dull, coarse is not necessary) and finish it with old butcher steel to shaving sharp. In the past, I used carborundum, but diamonds are much faster, sharpening today high-tech steels on carburundum or natural stones is nearly impossible, edge is more homogenous and final result with diamont/steel combination is best ever seen. For total satisfaction on premium knives after treatment on steel I use leather belt, edge is mirror polished, it is shaving for long time and leads to best result . ..

Jiri
14 October 2004, 08:37
Mark
The best place to get japanese waterstones in at a japanese grocery store! Sometime when you are in a large city with a significant oriental population go into some mom&pop store, last time I checked coarse stones were $6.00 and the fine "gold" one was about $23. Most were around 12.
14 October 2004, 02:01
Jiri
Image just for fun, what can you find in students apartment

You can see DMT sharpener, leather belt specialy made for finishing woodworking knives, old butcher steel, old worn carborundum sharpener, kitchen knife made by local knifemaker from some special french steel, it shave hair after hour of cuting meat, vegetables etc . . .



Sorry for bad image quality
Jiri