Deer baiting

11 July 2018, 14:52

300 win

Deer baiting

The Michigan DNR want's to ban deer baiting and non synthetic deer urine based lure and scents. To me they should never started to bait,you are making the deer more nocturnal. As far as the scent,you just got to play the wind

11 July 2018, 17:53

Snyper

quote:
Originally posted by 300 win:
The Michigan DNR want's to ban deer baiting and non synthetic deer urine based lure and scents. To me they should never started to bait,you are making the deer more nocturnal. As far as the scent,you just got to play the wind

I don't think baiting changes anything about the times deer are active.

The urine scents are attractants, not covers, so "playing the wind" has no bearing.

The primary advantage to baits and scent lures is their ability to get the deer in a clear spot to take a shot.

11 July 2018, 19:11

Crazyhorseconsulting

This is one of those circular arguements that only shows dkivision lines among hunters. It would get more mileage/interest if placed in the American Hunting discussion forum.

12 July 2018, 08:47

NormanConquest

Back in the day when my wife was "in season" I asked her for her used kotex. BELIEVE me women give them up less easier than their virtue. I would use the kotex,in a Kodak film cannister duct taped to a clothes line pin.When hunting remove the ca Clip to any + several branches..Esterus works for most mammals.It has worked for me.If that is baiting then I was baited when I got married. As an addendum,when Cecil B. Demills did his movie of Samson + Delila;on the set the lion worker asker her if she wes in her period.At that point it ceased being a fantasty + real world.

13 July 2018, 18:58

Grizzly Adams

quote:
Originally posted by NormanConquest:
Back in the day when my wife was "in season" I asked her for her used kotex. BELIEVE me women give them up less easier than their virtue. I would use the kotex,in a Kodak film cannister duct taped to a clothes line pin.When hunting remove the ca Clip to any + several branches..Esterus works for most mammals.It has worked for me.If that is baiting then I was baited when I got married. As an addendum,when Cecil B. Demills did his movie of Samson + Delila;on the set the lion worker asker her if she wes in her period.At that point it ceased being a fantasty + real world.

Most of us are just NOT that dedicated.

Baiting is illegal here.

Grizz

Indeed, no human being has yet lived under conditions which, considering the prevailing climates of the past, can be regarded as normal. John E Pfeiffer, The Emergence of Man

Those who can't skin, can hold a leg. Abraham Lincoln

Only one war at a time. Abe Again.

13 July 2018, 21:04

lindy2

One of the most common debates, at least here in Minnesota, is why baiting is illegal but hunting over a field of soybeans or corn (or for that matter any planted crop) is not illegal.

A hunter can sit in a stand near a picked corn field where there are hundreds of cobs sitting on the ground and it would be legal as long as the cobs were not "placed" there by the hunter.
But another hunter could pick up a few of those cobs of corn, move 10 yards away from the other hunter and "place" those cobs of corn on the ground and would then be subject to arrest and a fine.

Another example. My brother has a number of apple trees. Deer flock to them in the fall. It would be legal for him to sit in a blind next those trees and shoot a deer. But if he were to pick up just one apple and "place" it a foot from where it had naturally fallen, it would then be illegal to hunt there.

The Minnesota DNR's answer to why baiting is illegal is because it aids in the spread of disease.

I am not for or against baiting. I don't do it myself. But I admit to being fortunate enough to hunt on my own property, which is excellent for deer.