The Accurate Reloading Forums
The "Tough Decision" buck
12 November 2011, 23:34
Bobby TomekThe "Tough Decision" buck
I’ve been watching a particular buck for some time now and had been hoping I’d get a chance to put my tag on him during the season. As older bucks tend to do, he had disappeared for several weeks before I finally got a glimpse of him late yesterday. There was no opportunity for a shot, however.
This morning, he was back – but he was with another buck and doing some serious sparring.
The other buck was limping badly and getting soundly beaten by the buck I dubbed Big Boy. I didn’t think he’d be able to take much more of this treatment– or if so, that coyotes would bring him down before he ever has a chance to recover. I’ll admit running my crosshairs over Big Boy’s vitals before I made the decision to spend my tag and take out the injured buck. Other than either a spike or buck with an unbranched antler, I am done for the season, but I feel it was the right – and humane – thing to do.
In retrospect, the decision wasn't all that tough...
Once again, my 24” MGM 7-30 Waters and the 140 grain Combined Technology Ballistic Silvertip performed flawlessly. The buck was taken at 166 yards through the edge of the front shoulder. The bullet nipped the top of the heart and wrecked its plumbing while also doing a number on the lungs. It broke through the center of the opposite-side shoulder and lodged under the skin on the far side. The buck simply whirled and dropped at impact.
My “help” this morning – our twin boys who just turned 8 – temporarily misplaced the recovered bullet, but I’ll eventually retrieve it and post a photo of the textbook performance. But if it weren’t for their eager and able-bodied help and that of my wife, this morning would never have been possible as some health issues severely limit my mobility, so for their part in this, I am both blessed and thankful.
Bobby
Μολὼν λαβέ
The most important thing in life is not what we do but how and why we do it. - Nana Mouskouri
12 November 2011, 23:51
DTalagood call and still a nice looking buck in the bag, congrats.
troy
Birmingham, Al
13 November 2011, 01:38
guns68Good call, and nice "little buck"!
If we don't try, we don't do. And if we don't do, what are we here for?
13 November 2011, 02:22
Aspen Hill AdventuresNothing wrong with that choice!

~Ann
13 November 2011, 03:27
ravenrgood work bobby
meat for the freezer and horns for the wall
glad to see you are getting out and enjoying
yourself.keep up the good work

13 November 2011, 03:50
Bobby TomekHere is another view of the buck and a game cam photo from last year of the buck he was losing to. That game cam buck this year was much the same in antler configuration but does have much better mass. For this area, he is impressive as south central TX is not renown for antler growth like the South TX brush country and the Panhandle regions.
Heck, just 10 years ago I never would have imagined a buck like I took today. The 13-inch minimum rule, while certainly not perfect, does indeed work.
Bobby
Μολὼν λαβέ
The most important thing in life is not what we do but how and why we do it. - Nana Mouskouri
13 November 2011, 18:26
Bob in TXBobby-Kudo's on both the "little" buck and on your decision.
Bob
13 November 2011, 18:33
CrazyhorseconsultingNice looking buck and a good choice. The bigger buck might make it thru till net season but the buck you took possibly would have died from his injurues or would have fell to the coyotes.
Congratulations.

Even the rocks don't last forever.
13 November 2011, 19:19
Outdoor WriterVery fine buck. Way to go.

Tony Mandile - Author "How To Hunt Coues Deer"
14 November 2011, 01:04
GeedubyaGood on ya' there Bobby,
I think another fellow who also employed a single shot once said, "be sure you're right, then go ahead".
I'd say you made the right choice.
Congrats on the buck.
Best
GWB
16 November 2011, 18:13
SDhunterYou always seem to make the right decision. Congrats.
16 November 2011, 19:00
scottfromdallasNice job Bobby. You can get Big Boy next year when he is Bigger Boy.

17 November 2011, 17:50
MMMMy hat's off to you sir, that is a great buck. I am impressed with your experience, judgement and coolness, I have to say I don't know if I would have been capable of making that choice in the heat of the moment, but in retrospect it's easy to see it clearly was the better choice. Congratulations!
17 November 2011, 18:36
M16Great buck Bobby. Congratulations!
17 November 2011, 19:10
graybirdNothing wrong with that ole boy! Congrats Bobby!!!
Graybird
"Make no mistake, it's not revenge he's after ... it's the reckoning."
18 November 2011, 02:53
JTEXGood on ya'.
.
28 November 2011, 21:30
Bobby TomekThanks for the kind words. I appreciate it. On another board, I had someone e-mail and ask why I was not smiling in the photos. His exact words: "I'd have been grinning like a 'possum."
He wondered if I was not happy with taking that buck. Looking at my face, I can see now why he asked.
So I'll answer here, too: My health is failing, and my mobility is very poor. To get to kneeling like that took an act of congress -- well, "real" help and not the Congress kind ha ha -- and was quite painful, as was getting back up.
I am positively thrilled with the beautiful buck, even though my expression may not have shown as much.
Bobby
Μολὼν λαβέ
The most important thing in life is not what we do but how and why we do it. - Nana Mouskouri