The Accurate Reloading Forums
Which would you take?
08 July 2004, 15:59
clarkfork1Which would you take?
Ok, I'm gonna get a new rifle and I'm down to two choices, both in 7mm-08. One is a Remington Model 7, stainless/laminate and the other is a Winchester Model 70 Featherweight. Am leaning toward the Model 7 since I already have a Featherweight in 30-06. I guess I'm in the mood for something different. Use would be mainly for deer here in the Southeast. Which would you go with and why?
08 July 2004, 17:42
fredj338To me the only eason to go M7 is to save weight. If you are shooting from a stand/blind that's not an issue so I would go w/ the M70 ft.wt. I beleive the M7 has a 20" bbl. & the M70 a 22" so you'll get a bit more perf. out of the M70. Fords vs Chevy vs Dodge.

08 July 2004, 17:55
Pecos41Really no wrong choice here. Both will obviously serve you well. Best point for staying with the Win is your mind won't have to always wonder which action am I using today. If all your rifles are Win, then your hands can do it all while you're sleeping.
Make yourself happy here. I don't think any of us can give you a persuasive argument one way or other.

09 July 2004, 00:50
<eldeguello>I'm not much of a Remington fan anymore, but the Model 7's are nice guns.
09 July 2004, 07:22
John GBe sure to handle them both before you decide. The Model 7 is nice and light, but many people feel that it is too muzzle light and doesn't point well. Others say it's perfect as a quick-pointing gun. The synthetic stock, almost all will agree, leaves a lot to be desired. Consider a laminated stainless if they make it, or look at a laminated stainless Rem mountain rifle in 7-08, which is still nice and light, looks great, and balances a bit better for most people.
The Featherweight is a nicely balanced gun for almost anyone, and very attractive to most gun admirers. It will feel only very slightly different to you because the 7-08 is in the short action Model 70, which is lighter than your long-action 30-06 and will have a balance point very slightly further back. Otherwise, it's the same, which isn't a bad thing, as a previous poster pointed out. There'll be no fumbling for the safety or some other control when you're in a hurry or in the dark.
All things being equal (which they never are) I would put the Featherweight first in my consideration because of it's quality, action design, your familiarity with the Model 70 features, and appearance; the Rem LSS Mt. Rifle would come in second because of it's light weight and excellent stock design; and the Model 7 last.
09 July 2004, 08:19
PPoseyI have the Rem LSS Mt. Rifle in 7mm-08 and like it,,,,I used to have a Win featherweight in 270 and liked it too,,,
whichever feels the best to you,
I do agree that sense you already have a win 70 then that would be an advantage of getting the Win.
09 July 2004, 08:23
SlingsterWhat about the Win M70 Compact? Does it come in 7mm-08? If so, I'd lean in that direction myself.
09 July 2004, 17:00
<9.3x62>Avoid the j-lock, get the Winchester (I had a CRF 70 FW in 7mm-08 - nice gun). Good luck.
09 July 2004, 17:45
beemanbemeI agree that a 20-22" barrel might be an advantage but I have a old 18" model 7 in 7-08 that I routinely used in mulie hunting in Wyoming. As far as the J lock, its too bad some folks just can't get past it. I have rifles with and without it and can't offhand tell you which ones are which. I understand you can get a new shroud for @$50. Lots cheaper than sending a winchester off to a smith and spending big bucks to get it on paper.

09 July 2004, 18:54
cobradForget them both and pick up a Kimber. Sweetest little rifle I ever handled. I just got a Montana in .243.
10 July 2004, 02:37
Cold BoreI was shooting a little Model 7 yesterday, in 243. I put a stainless gun in a walnut stock, so it's "almost" the one you're looking at. With 100 grain handloads, it easily went under 3/4" at 100 yards. Of course, it heats up fast, but when was the last time you needed to fire five shots rapid-fire at a deer?
I also have a 7mm-08 in a "regular" M700. I LOVE the caliber.
So to me, I'd get the Model 7.
Matter-of-fact, I've always got my eye half-peeled towards the racks, and if I ever do find a nice stainless/laminated Model 7 in 7mm-08, I'm gonna get it...
11 July 2004, 00:43
clarkfork1Well...., I couldn't pass up on the looks of the stainless/laminate so I picked up the Model 7 in 7mm-08 yesterday. It also fit me and just seemed to feel good in my hands. Already mounted a compact Leupold on it and will hit the range soon to see if it shoots as good as it looks. I'm gonna try some factory 140 Rem Core Lokts since I no longer reload. Thanks for all the replies.
17 July 2004, 15:43
WstrnhuntrAbout a month ago my wife gave me the green light to get a new rifle. I looked long and hard at some 30-06'es and 300 WSM's. I checked out the Model 70 and the 700. Dang near bought a Vanguard. Then I looked and contemplated some more. Suffice to say that the machine marks all over the Model 70 and the other "little things" (cheap parts and characteristics I just didnt like) I saw with all the others I looked at, made it hard to justify chosing one over the other. In the end I decided to re-barrel my Springfield.

Its too bad the QC at Winchester isnt better, if it were they would have sold me on a 300 WSM.
I would take the M70 for sure !!
If the remington choice was in a stainless mountain rifle, with laminated stock, I can see the Remington choice.
However since it isn't, I'd go with the Featherweight hands down. I never did like the model 7 at all. Never owned one for a reason. However it has it all over the Model 710!
Cheers and Good shooting
seafire
19 July 2004, 13:22
AtkinsonAnytime I have a choice between a control feed rifle and a push feed rifle, you can be sure that I will always take the control feed gun...I base that on my experience of some 60 years of hunting, and from observation and personal experience....I have not owned a push feed big game rifle in some twenty years and thats not going to change.
What other choose is their opinnion and I respect that....