Angel (243win) vs Devil (6mm-284)

The Accurate Reloading Forums

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/2511043/m/227103373

24 November 2005, 20:26

1894mk2

Angel (243win) vs Devil (6mm-284)

Primary use small deer out to 300yards
Low volume varminting out to 300yards
Action - Sako AII
Barrel - length 26"
primarily for 85gr but able to handle 105gr soft points (speer) at a pinch (so plan on 9 twist)
Mag length - max col 2.75"

Angel or Devil?

Angel says this is prime 243 territory, Devil says you only live once, barrel steel is cheap and an 85gr might be driven at 3,400fps. Angel says so what does that do that 3,250fps doesn't, Devil says 105gr difference bigger, Angel says how often do you plan on using them, Devil says you can download me, Angel says you can pick up 243 anywhere and you allready have the dies, Devil says you should get better dies anyway and not use old brass in a new chamber.

At present Angel is winning....

24 November 2005, 23:03

<JOHAN>

I understand the confusion. Throw me a pair of those wings

In a perfect world 6mm rem would be the ideal

Cheers
/JOHAN

25 November 2005, 02:15

reverenddan

What's small deer? Shouldn't 85 grain pills be enough?

I understand the conundrum! My wife constantly catches me having arguments with myself in the reloading room!

25 November 2005, 04:55

Fjold

For 300 yards and less you'll never need the 6-284. 300 yards is the perfect max for the 243, burn less powder, resale's higher and you have more than enough gun.

Frank

"I don't know what there is about buffalo that frightens me so.....He looks like he hates you personally. He looks like you owe him money."
- Robert Ruark, Horn of the Hunter, 1953

NRA Life, SAF Life, CRPA Life, DRSS lite

26 November 2005, 00:32

TomP

quote:
Originally posted by 1894mk2:

Primary use small deer out to 300yards
Low volume varminting out to 300yards

At present Angel is winning....

Maybe 243 AI is an answer; you can still shoot factory ammunition when you run short.

I went the 6mm-284 route with an ex-243, twist isn't enough for heavy bullets but 85 grain Noslers have been sufficient for what I wanted to do anyway.

26 November 2005, 01:25

Thomas Jones

I say split the difference !
get yourself a 6mm Remington !
Life is most comfortable somewhere beetween the angel and the devil...tj3006

26 November 2005, 07:26

MajorCaliber

My 1-10 twist .243 shoots the 105gr Speers great

28 November 2005, 15:02

1894mk2

quote:
Originally posted by MajorCaliber:
My 1-10 twist .243 shoots the 105gr Speers great

Mine doesn't - 8 inches at best

quote:
I say split the difference !
get yourself a 6mm Remington !
Life is most comfortable somewhere beetween the angel and the devil...

Indeed I love the 6mm rem (and I have one!) but it is too long to feed from this action comfortably

quote:
I went the 6mm-284 route with an ex-243, twist isn't enough for heavy bullets but 85 grain Noslers have been sufficient for what I wanted to do anyway.

TomP you have a PM