Not so much. My money's on the one closest to the camera, although points off for the repeated low blows. That HAD to hurt! Now that's an uppercut of immense proportions.

http://www.boreme.com/boreme/funny-2007/giraffe-fight-p1.php?edp=1

This was posted a few days ago as well as an amazing sequence of a lion pride fighting a giraffe.

I agree on your pick. The closest, biggest giraffe really rocked the smaller one. That has to hurt.