Just trying to stir up trouble again.

06 April 2004, 19:29
JBrown500grains
As I said before that is a pretty impressive find. Thanks for sharing it the story and photos.
I do have one question, if this had been a 500 grain .470 soft of similar construction with an expanded diameter of say 0.8648 would it have reached the vitals?
I am interested to hear what you think.
Jason
07 April 2004, 03:21
500grains[qupte]* * * You are ignoring this user. * * *
07 April 2004, 05:34
AtkinsonJ Brown,
I can tell you that the 375 will out penitrate the .470 N.E. and most other calibers, but penitration is not the ONLY criteria to killing power just one of them..The problem here is bullet choice..On Buffalo one should always use a solid in the smaller calibers. In fact I use them in all calibers..But the monolicthics seem to have a large following as the best of both worlds..I have seen a soft point fail in the .470 on two or three ocassion as most American hunters like softs. Softs are fine but they are not for head shots on buffalo, and they don't do real good on spine shots sometimes...Some hunters forget which barrel the soft is in on their doubles and that has caused problems..when the .470 has two solids in it then the problem is solved and you can take any shot thats offered IMO.
One never knows just why a bullet is found in game, but it is not uncommon and a million reasons could have caused the bullet in question to be where it was...as I stated in my post I found a bullet that had penitrated both lungs to the opposite side and was in a wad of callus tissue and healed..that one should have killed the bull but he was fully recovered...The new Man Magnum gives such reports as this btw.
07 April 2004, 14:01
laredo kidPlease,what are the differences in materials and construction of solids-monolithic solids-soft-soft monolithic.
08 April 2004, 11:19
500grainsmonolithic solid:
Barnes: brass
GS Custom: copper
regular solid:
Woodleigh: copper alloy jacket, steel liner, hardened lead core
Speer AGS: copper alloy jacket around tungsten carbide core
Trophy Bonded Sledgehammer: jacket of come type of copper or brass alloy (brass is mostly copper) with a lead core.
How does the Trophy Bonded Sledgehammer compare as solids go?
Thanks for your time,
Regards, PG