The Accurate Reloading Forums
Pig Sticking and other reads

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/1411043/m/288105632

22 March 2005, 05:55
Nickudu
Pig Sticking and other reads
Pig Sticking

More Pig Sticking

Tiger Story

Burmese Days

Those About to Die
22 March 2005, 13:58
RHB
Thanks very much, Nick.

Rustam
22 March 2005, 14:10
NitroX
I'd forgotten about the hunting section in Orwell's "Burmese Days". I used to read a lot of Orwell but remember his "Burmese Days" was rather negative and depressing (like most of his writing).

I could never quite work out if the hunting story in "Burmese Days" was anti-hunting or not. Or just showing the failure of the character in the story.


__________________________

John H.

..
NitroExpress.com - the net's double rifle forum
22 March 2005, 15:41
Marterius
Thanks Nick!

NitroX, you wrote "I could never quite work out if the hunting story in "Burmese Days" was anti-hunting or not."

I think it is a sign of a good author that he leaves the moral judgement to his readers - this means he takes his readers seriously. Not very common, unfortunately.

Another, more general thought: I think that many older hunting stories, seen as very pro-hunting by the standards of those days, would be seen as anti-hunting if published by a modern writer.

Regards,
Martin


-----------------------
A man can never have too much red wine, too many books, or too much ammunition. - R. Kipling
22 March 2005, 19:03
mehulkamdar
Nickudu,

Thank you very much for another set of superb articles. Baden Powell opined that a gentleman would only take a pig with cold steel and not shoot one, something impossible in this politically correct age, of course, in India. The article was a superb account of the past.

NitroX/Marterius,

Orwell's hunting articles - his "Shooting an Elephant" was taught to us in school - reflected his own personal problems, especially his depression. If one reads some of the other greats from that time, like Kipling, the same kind of feeling comes through.

I personally doubt that any of the writers of that time were anti hunting in any way.

Best wishes,


Mehul Kamdar

"I ask, sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."-- Patrick Henry

23 March 2005, 05:53
Nickudu
You're very welcome, my friends.