THE ACCURATERELOADING.COM DOWN UNDER FORUM    The Accurate Reloading Forums    THE ACCURATE RELOADING.COM FORUMS  Hop To Forum Categories  Hunting  Hop To Forums  Australian and New Zealand Hunting    Hobbit Hunt Report - Hunt with Gerald Telford and Mort Moon

Moderators: Bakes
Hobbit Hunt Report - Hunt with Gerald Telford and Mort Moon
one of us
Hobbit Hunt or New Zealand Trip Report
Dates – April 19 – May 2, 2014
Location – Wanaka, South Island and Tirau (near Rotarua), North Island
Hunting Company – Telford Hunting and Fishing Services – Gerald and Sue Telford – – Wanaka, South Island

Kuranui Wilderness Lodge and Trophy Park – Mort and Mel Moon – – Tirau, North Island

Booking Agent – none, booked direct on recommendations from other hunters

Travel Agent – Esplanade Travel – Kit Schultz – 800-628-4893,
Kit specializes in New Zealand travel. She put me onto “Premium Economy” seats on these flights and it was worth it. I would use her again.

Hunt Guides – Gerald Telford and Mort Moon

Game Sought – Red Stag, Himalayan Tahr, Fallow Deer, Chamois, Rusa Deer, Possum(s)

Game Taken – Red Stag (2x), Tahr (2x), Fallow Deer (2x), Rusa Deer (2x), Chamois and Possums

Executive Summary

If you like “no hassle” hunting – you will love New Zealand
If you like great food, great accommodations – you will love New Zealand
If you like no issues with quotas or available game – you will love New Zealand
If you like laid back, fun, easy going guides – you will love New Zealand
If you like spending minimal time in a vehicle- you will love New Zealand
If you really like spot and stalk hunting – you will love New Zealand
If you want to see a lot of game – you will love New Zealand
If you are a sheep hunter or a wannabe sheep hunter – you will love New Zealand
If you like hunting in Canada, Europe or the US – you will like New Zealand more

If you like hassles at the airport – you will hate New Zealand
If you like bugs, malaria, snakes, sweat, dirt, diarrhea – you will hate New Zealand
If you like problems exporting trophies – you will hate New Zealand
If you like hassles with your guns and ammo – you will hate New Zealand
If you like having game scouts and other “hangers on” in your group – you will hate New Zealand

Get my point? I have travelled many places hunting. So far, none exceed New Zealand for a relaxing experience with great people.

We hunted hard and easy. We climbed and crawled. We laughed when we got busted on a stalk. We had multiple shot opportunities every day. We took all of the trophies we were after and a couple we learned to appreciate once we got there.

We did not need to use a helicopter. We climbed and sweated and had a great hunt.

There is not enough server storage on AR to post all of the pictures I took. You need to go and take your own pics. It is a blast.

Background and Research
This hunt was a no brainer. I found that there are 70 hunting outfits in New Zealand. There are many good ones that are steadily on AR and at the shows. I picked Gerald Telford after reading the following hunt report on AR - http://forums.accuratereloadin...8321043/m/2251045551
I also checked a couple of references, all were good. I then met Gerald at DSC to seal the deal.
Gerald is the President of the New Zealand hunting guides association.

For Kuranui, I asked Gerald who he would recommend from the North Island. He told me Mort and Mel operate a nice, boutique type outfit and that I would enjoy them. He was right.

Comments on Equipment

Rain Gear - New Zealand can be wet either from rain or heavy dew. To deal with “wet”, we used Helly Hanson raingear and Outdoor Research tall gaiters over our boots. The gaiters were especially helpful as we spent a lot of time on the sides of hills in wet/damp grass that would have soaked our pants.

Boots – I used Kennetrek non-insulated Mountain Extreme boots ( mainly for the climbing. They were great and stayed completely dry. I will use these on a sheep hunt later this year. My wife bought some boots from REI that served here very well.

Clothing – I used a variety of Sitka Gear pants, light shirts, vest and jackets. All were in the Open Country Optifade camo pattern. If I go again, I will use a camo pattern that is darker or just go with Swazi gear you can buy there. My wife use ladies camo called "OutfitHer" from Cabelas. She was perfectly happy with it. The weather is not cold but it is cool in the mornings and warmed up in the afternoons or while climbing. Dress light and in layers.

Guns – I chose to use their guns but I brought some ammo. With Gerald Telford, I used a Ruger Mark I in 7mm Rem Mag topped with an older German make scope. I brought some Federal Premium ammo on 160gr Nosler Partions. The gun shot perfect. I wounded a fallow but that was due to my error.

With Mort Moon, I used his Remington Model 700 SS fluted version in .300WSM. Scope was a Leupold 4.5 x14 x40. I used his handloads that were 165 gr Hornady bullets at 3200 fps. Everything I shot at was taken.

Binoculars – This is important. I took my Swarovski SLC 10x42’s. These were perfect and I would recommend taken 10x to New Zealand as the distances are similar to the western US. Gerald Telford used the Leica Geovid 10x42 HD rangefinding binoculars and they were impressive.

Day pack – For the second time, I used an Eberstock X1A1 daypack ( ) with a built in scabbard. I would recommend this as you will be climbing a lot and will need both hands to get up and down the hills.

The Country

What can you say about New Zealand? I have been there several times and always return to the US depressed wishing I had stayed longer. It is green, beautiful, laid back, clean, friendly, has great roads, and is the easiest place to get to for an American other than Canada. The scenery is stunning whether in the sheep country or ski country or coasts. The entire place reminds me of what the US was like in the late 1950’s or early 1960’s. Cell phones work. The internet works. We never waited in a line. The traffic was easy and polite. I never heard a car horn “honk”.

A sign in one store we stopped by –

We were there on ANZAC Day, a day of remembrance for the war heroes from New Zealand and Australia that fought in WWI at Gallipoli against the Turks. People also remember the veterans and war dead from WWII as well. It is celebrated at dawn on April 25th and nearly every town in New Zealand hosts a remembrance and celebration. Gerald and Sue’s daughters both participated in a ceremony to commemorate the dead and bravery of the soldiers. I was extremely impressed that the generations in New Zealand that have not known war paused to remember.

Hunt Method

All spot and stalk. Both areas we hunted required climbing and stalking. We got busted several times. The climbs were tough but not impossible as the altitude in New Zealand is less than I thought. The highest we climbed was about 4000’. We took a grand tour of one large sheep station via an ATV and got up to about 5000’. The area in the South Island was open and we spent a lot of time glassing, then making a plan to get closer to check horns or antlers. In the North Island, we were in a closer, steeper, more heavily forested area. We would spot an animal, then glass closely to see what we had. Usually we stalked as close as possible to re-check.

Comment on Helicopters

I have stayed out of the argument on AR as I had no frame of reference. It is a hotly discussed topic as we all know. Here is what I learned on my trip –

1. They are used a lot. We saw them in nearby hunt areas.
2. It is regulated to some degree.
3. The ethics of the individual hunter and guide will dictate the use of them.
4. They are expensive, running about $2000 per hour or more.
5. They are used by “hunters” that cannot or will not get up and down the mountains for tahr or chamois.
6. The tahr and chamois have learned to run downhill toward timber or into deep crags to get away from the helicopter hunters.
7. There are significant accessibility issues in the South Island due to the terrain. I also understood that the Dept of Conservation requires a certain number of female tahr to be removed in relation to males killed. Helicopters are the most efficient method to do this.
8. Due to all of the mammals in New Zealand being introduced and not being native, the view is that many of the animals are nuisances and can/should be taken by any means deemed necessary.
9. If you want to start a debate, start a conversation about helicopters. I suggest you be open minded before speaking on a topic you know nothing about first hand.
10. It is not something I would do, but I would tour around in one. The scenery is stunning.

I am not sure I have stated everything above accurately, but this is my general understanding. Any New Zealand operators that have different thoughts or views, please comment. If any non-New Zealand hunters have any comments, I suggest you re-look at your position on shooting white-tailed deer out of a box blind over a timed feeder (US hunters) or a driven hunt using many if not hundreds of “beaters” to drive hogs or deer or whatever to waiting hunters (Europe) or spotlighting leopards over bait from a blind having used a trail camera (Africa). Enough said on ethics.

Observations on New Zealand Hunting in General
New Zealand is an outdoor activity/work oriented country. The local people are well grounded in ranching, farming and outdoor activities in general. Nearly everyone I met or talked with was a keen fisherman or hunter. Believe it or not, I think pig hunting is more popular than all the rest of the types of hunting. Being a transplanted Texan, I was a bit surprised they actually hunt them on purpose and eat them. In my area, the only good pig is a dead pig and it usually is left on the ground. Anyway, the following are my observations on the business and hobby of hunting in New Zealand.

First, I noticed about three types of hunting operations. First was the large sheep station or cattle operation that has added red deer hunting to their business model. Red deer are raised like cattle and sold for three reasons – 1) for the meat, 2) the antlers are harvested while in the velvet and sold to Asian buyers for medicinal reasons, and 3) sold/hunted by sport hunters. The same thing goes for fallow deer, elk, rams, feral goats other species of deer. The land owner sees these animals as additional farm animals like cattle and sheep. I am excluding tahr and chamois from this as they are not “farmed” like the various deer and sheep.

The second type was the outfitter that leases land owned by a large sheep or cattle operation. He organizes the hunt(s), gets the hunters, charges a day rate and a trophy fee. He splits the fee with the landowner. The outfitter may or may not help in the active management of the red deer, fallow deer, chamois or tahr.

The third type would be a smaller outfit that owns land, farms the red deer or other species and offers hunts. This operation would have a farm nearby where the red deer or others are raised and bred like cattle, then mature animals are placed in hunting areas and others are sold for meat or velvet.

This is all big business and well run in New Zealand. As you know, there are no native mammals in New Zealand. Every mammal was introduced to the island for commercial reasons. Hence, the local hunter or rancher sees his game animals differently than the same person in the US or Canada. His animals are his and he manages them as he chooses. There are no hunting seasons and no limits. The red deer and all of the other animals are “open season”.

The question then comes – what about high fence operations? Well, from what I could tell, nearly all of the hunting areas have fences somewhere. The pastures can be quite large and quite small. The two main areas I hunting on the South Island were very large but contained some smaller high fenced areas that had some monster red stags available. We chose to hunt the large paddocks that had a lot of stags but none of the 400+” animals you see in photos. The smaller area I hunted on the North Island was high fenced. It was about 3 square miles (best I could tell). The area was seriously steep and overgrown. I doubt I saw 20% of the area due to the foliage and the steep hills. I never had the sense it was high fenced except driving and driving out through a gate.

The point I am making is that if you choose to hunt any of the deer in New Zealand, you will likely be hunting in a type of high fenced area. Based on what I saw, the reason for the fences is to keep “livestock” separated and to allow some hunters to hump it up and down hills in a very large area (50,000+ acres). Nearly all of the land I saw was shared by sheep, cattle and deer; hence the need for fences.

I am not going to discuss the issue of high fenced hunting. From what I saw in New Zealand, it was completely fair chase and I had a lot of fun.

The Animals

Rather than do a shot by shot or day by day diary, let me just discuss the various animals we encountered and the results.

Red Stag
The question is not “if” you will take a nice stag, just “when”. I saw numerous stags each day and passed on many. I asked both Gerald and Mort to recommend what I was looking for as I am not a stag expert. I liked the classic look of the red stag with the high “cup” of points and not the “squished spider” looking stag with antlers sticking out everywhere. At both places, we climbed to vantage points and glassed large areas looking for stags. I was there after the rut with a few stags still “roaring” but by and large, the rut was over and the stags were more interested in eating and putting weight back on after the fighting during the rut.

At the large sheep station we hunted with Gerald, we spotted a number of good stags but nothing in the “classic” look for the first day or so. We drove the roads and glasses a lot of young stags still looking for love. Finally, we spotted a pair of classic stags at about a mile resting on a hillside. We stalked and got busted but finally outwitted one and made a 200 yard shot as it walked away. This stag was down in weight severely from the rut and was very beat up – just what I was looking for.

Pulled a stalk on these high fence stags –

I could have hunted a high fence stag in a smaller enclosure but chose to chase them up and down the hills to find a classic one. We saw numerous 400” to 600” stags in enclosures and took a lot of pictures.

Red Deer at feeding time on the commercial farm

At Kuranui, the stag hunting was a bit different due to the size of the area. Mort and Mel run a red deer ranching operation for velvet and for meat as well as for hunters. The stags he released into the hunt area were big ones. He had numerous big stags in the area but in the time I was there we only saw about 5 different “shooters”. He had some shed antlers from several that would shock you, but he said that the older stags disappear into the dense cover after the rut.

Anyway, the stag I killed with Mort was one I glimpsed the first day there, then, did not see for a couple days. He was a classic and just what I like. The shot was 140 yards and he went down. I had the jump on him as I was in the dense cover and he had taken a few steps out in the open at dusk to eat. Big mistake.

Typical Red Stag at Kuranui

Fallow Deer

The Fallow deer rut was “on” at both places. We saw more red deer than fallow deer but we did manage to spend a lot of time glassing bucks of various color phases and antler configurations. I ended up taking two bucks with Gerald as we were able to get up on them and get a shot. Hunting the fallow deer, even in the rut, was more difficult that red stags. This was partly due to the numbers of deer out there but also due to the fact they were with does that were wary of us. We were busted several times and had to do some serious stalking to get close. Both shots were under 200 yards. Fallow deer and the stags tended to behave like mule deer. When they were spooked, they ran about fifty to a hundred yards, stopped and looked back. On several, I could have taken shots if they had been what I was after.

I found I really enjoyed hunting fallow deer. They are much like mule deer or even pronghorn antelope. They are wary, but not so difficult to hunt that you never see them. They were fun to hunt.

I did manage to wound one really nice buck at about 100 yards that Gerald and I both thought should have been dead. I had him broadside twice and apparently missed vitals both times as he dodged us and we never saw him again. The good news is that about two weeks after I left, a bow hunter came in and had a shot at the same fallow deer. He never got the shot but came back with a rifle a couple of days later and killed him. It turns out my first shot passed under the spine but above the shoulders as a through and through wound. The second shot grazed the brisket leaving a non-lethal wound. The deer was grazing and moving as if not wound when he was killed. It is unusual but misses like this happen.

Another good thing about hunting in New Zealand is the guides hunt the same property year in and year out. They know the animals and the land. This helps in following up on wounded animals or in trying to locate something unique.

Himalayan Tahr
I did not get a real taste of tahr hunting on this trip. Gerald took me to his tahr camp on a sheep station about two hours from Wanaka and in an area that he has hunted tahr for many years. I thought, before the trip, that tahr would be the hard animal to hunt due to climbing and access issues. I was somewhat right as the tahr live in a tough area and a very steep area. The terrain reminded me of Dall Sheep hunting in Alaska as the mountains were bare and covered with the shingled looking shale/schist type rocks. I brought my Kenetrek mountain boots primarily for this terrain and the hunt.

Gerald told me that tahr are plentiful and getting one was not hard if you could shoot at longer distances and did not mind a climb or two. He said to expect to see ten to fifteen bulls a day while were there but the issue would be getting close enough for a shot and a recovery. In tahr country, a dead tahr will roll down the mountain a long way if you shoot him on a slope. The idea was to find one on a relatively flat spot and drop him there, so the recovery could be simplified. There are times that the recovery is made with a helicopter due to accessibility. I did not want to spend money to do that.

When we drove to the camp, we arrived late in the day and decided to scout until dark before heading to the bunkhouse. We were driving the main access road up to the basins we hoped to glass when Gerald stopped the car and backed off a hill slowly. He had glimpsed a tahr at the transition of the grassy slopes and the rocks above from a long way out. We quickly backed down the hill, and make a slow climb up to a vantage point looking across a forested canyon to the slopes opposite us.

We duck walked up to the edge of a fairly deep, black woods canyon and spotted four tahr on the hillside directly across from us grazing. Ranging them at 300 yards or so, we set up and looked them over closely to see who the big one was. In reality three of four were twelve inches or better so we spent time checking out the manes on each.

Gerald settled on one and told me to take it. I asked if he was sure. He said he was. I was about to squeeze one off and he said, “No, take the other one.” I switched targets. As I was about to squeeze, he said, “No, the other one, he looks longer.” So I switched and shot before he could change his mind again. It was a hit and the tahr wobbled about fifteen yards and I dropped him with a second shot.

The other tahr just stood there looking around, not sure what had happened and unable to pinpoint us. It was windy and they could not source the sound. While standing there, Gerald said, “That other one sure is a big one.” So I said, “Heck, let’s shoot him too. When am I ever going to have a chance to double on tahr?” So I did. At the shot, this tahr sprinted downhill into the black timber. The shot looked good, felt good and appeared to connect, but tahr are like aoudad, thick in the shoulders and tough to bring down.

We backed off the hill and drove around to the other side of the canyon and started to search. We had to side-hill a really steep grassy slope to get to tahr number one. We confirmed he was dead then made a search for number two as it got dark. One of the biggest advantages of using a guide, a very experienced guide is that he knows how the animals react and where they tend to run. We found no blood but followed some torn up ground and found him laying down the slope fifty yards pinned against some trees in the darkest, tangled up mess of timber you can imagine. Only his blond belly was showing when we spotted him. We set him up, took a couple of pictures then left the area as it was getting real dark.

The second tahr in the timber

Next morning we came back and started the all day back out process. Another good thing about New Zealand is that the only predator other than man are pigs. We had no worries that the tahr would be right where we left them.

Double Tahr

We overnighted in a sheep station where Gerald had a rustic but very nice cabin. Sheep stations are large and made for working sheep. This place was ruggedly beautiful and I took a lot of pictures. Gerald uses pictures from this remote area in his promotional material. The terrain is Lord of the Rings beautiful and reminds me of the Scottish Highlands. It is worth the effort to go and see this place.

All in all, I felt a little cheated and relieved on this tahr hunt. Cheated because I had worked to get in climbing shape to hunt them and hoped to spent a couple of days glassing and stalking before ending the hunt. I felt relieved that I did not have to spent a couple of days climbing, climbing, climbing and hopefully stalking to take one. It was fun. I would do it again. I would shoot three if three stood there long enough. Go tahr hunting!!!

Alpine Chamois

For some reason I like chamois. I like their “look”, I like where they hang out, I like how they run and I like the fact they are tough and like high up places. While hunting stag and fallow deer, Gerald and his other guide usually keep an eye out for chamois. Of the animals to hunt in New Zealand, chamois are the most difficult. They are in tough to get to places and there no herds of them. There are plenty to hunt, but taking a nice male is tough and time consuming. Gerald told me sweats each chamois hunt because – 1) is the hunter in shape to get up the hills? And, 2) can he shoot when he gets there? And, 3) can we find a nice male in amongst the rocks and crags? We had seen chamois a couple of times from a long distance while glassing for stags and went back to the general area we saw them. On the ram I killed, we spotted him with four females and fawn at about 300 yards on a high grassy hillside. They were grazing and it took quite a bit of time to see if the male was a male and if he was a shooter. On chamois, the old adage, “the big ones look big” does not hold as both males and females have horns. The males have bigger bodies but not always. Anyway, we studied this one for an hour or so then made a detour to another area to check out. We did not find one in the other area, so we returned to this place and made a stalk.

The shot was 200 yards but the target was small. A chamois may weight seventy pounds and the target area is about six inches in diameter. I made a good shot and got him on the ground. It was really cool to see them up close and I was extremely pleased with the ram.

Rusa Deer
Found only in New Caledonia and Indonesia, this deer was my number one quarry on the North Island. Mort Moon had acquired a small group of what he was told were sika deer and actually turned out to be Rusa Deer. He put them on his place and they have thrived. He has the best quality herd of these deer anywhere in New Zealand. I looked a several YouTube videos of rusa hunts and I believe Mort offers a better hunt than what I saw the videos. They are the size of red deer but have antlers like an Axis deer. They are secretive, hang out only in the edges of dense jungle and are very cautious. We hunted them for a couple of days by glassing clearings early and late before we saw a few. Mort had seen three really nice bucks in the days leading up to my hunt and he was trying to keep track of where they were hanging out, but had lost track of them when I got there.

The one buck he hoped to take was a drop tine that was old and very heavy, so we concentrated on finding this one. After a couple of days and some serious climbs to vantage points, we spotted him about one jump from some really dense cover. We were above him and were able to set up on sticks and make a good shot. He was the heaviest antlers buck Mort has seen on his place. He was a super buck and one I will be proud of.

It was so much fun, I decided to hunt a second one as well. The first one had three other bucks with him, two of which were really nice. We stalked another day and found a rough pattern where they were hanging out. We spotted this second one while glassing some big fallow bucks. Again, this buck was with another one and in dense cover. We got winded and watched both bucks jump into the thickest tangles I have ever seen outside of bongo hunting in Cameroon.

Mort said that we should just sit tight and glass the area as he had seen them poke their heads out of the cover to see if the coast was clear on other occasions. It happened this time as well. We sent my wife up the hill to kind of walk above and around the dense tangled brush hoping they would watch her, then come out of hiding. The plan worked and one of the bucks did stick his head out of the tangles to see what was up. He gave me a shot and I took it. It was quite a feat to get to him even though we were 130 yards away. It was fun and perfect stalk.

Group of Rusa we saw one afternoon

On the Rusa deer – if you go to New Zealand, you really ought to try this out. They are as big a mule deer or red deer hind. They are smart and they are tough to spot. It is a bit like whitetail hunting but a bit tougher due to the terrain. They make a beautiful mount and you will be the only one on your block with one!

Possums were high on my list. First, because I was told there are lot of them. Second, we could hunt them at night with a spotlight. We were regaled with stories of shooting hundreds of possums in an evening and maybe getting fifteen out of one tree. It would literally “rain” possums if we found a tree they liked. These possums look like a cross between a ring tailed cat in the US and house cat. They have claws like a squirrel and teeth like a regular USA possum. Their face resembles a house cat. I guess they looked a bit like the ROUS’s in the movie “The Princess Bride” – Rodents Of Unusual Size.

Anyway, we drove the roads and spotlighted several shoot a few and gathering up one. My bride of thirty two years did the honors and double tapped this one in fine form. I may turn her into a hunter yet.

Pros and Cons of this trip
1. Easy place to get to. No hassles. Great air service.
2. Speak my native language and the water is safe to drink.
3. Plenty of game and is not over regulated.
4. Not a lot of time in the truck. You hunt close to where you stay.
5. Internet and cell phones work.
6. Prices are reasonable and fair.
7. You do not need an agent to do this trip. Go to DSC or SCI shows and book a trip.

1. I missed the red stag “roar” or rut by a week. Was hoping to hear and see this.
2. Did not get the full dose of tahr hunting. My tahr hunt was over too quick. I would still do it again however as you do not get to pick “easy” and “hard”.
3. I did not learn enough New Zealand history prior to the trip and should have so I could hold a conversation at dinner a bit better.
4. None I can think of that were not my fault.

Our Hosts
Gerald Telford is a long time New Zealand hunting and fishing guide. He has been in the business 20+ years along with his wife, Sue. Gerald is a hard core fisherman and a skilled fishing guide. He probably has a stronger passion for fishing than hunting. Another passion is duck hunting. We left just before the duck opener and he was making plans for a big family reunion and duck shoot. His daughters are 15 and 13 and would be shooters for the first time this year. I heard after we got home that they took 375 ducks with 19 shooters on the opening day. Good on them! Both of the young ladies are outdoorswomen and keen to hunt. They are great hostesses and not your typical teenage girls consumed with all things fashion and being “cool”.

Gerald’s Favorite Backpack

Sue Telford is a very accomplished pilot and tour guide. She teaches flying and takes people up in a single engine plane to see New Zealand from the air. My wife took a day trip to Milford, a nice coastal town with shopping and sights to see on the way. Sue is serious about flying and needs no enticement to fly anywhere at anytime. She had won an opportunity to fly in a P-51 Mustang World War II fighter owned by a local enthusiast in a raffle. This area of New Zealand hosts an air show every year with vintage planes and a variety of other aircraft. I am not into planes and such, but this was a pretty cool and Sue got to ride it for an hour over her home turf.

Sue and her daughter just before taking a flight

Sights on the flight

Mort and Mel Moon were/are a delightfully hospitable couple that we connected with right away. They met and married twenty years ago and decided to do something unique with their lives. Both liked ranches and entertaining so they bought the land on which they built the Kuranui Lodge with the dream of red deer farming and hosting events at a lodge they build by hand. Over several gourmet meals, they told us about how they built this secluded getaway by themselves. They started with a small house at the entrance to the deep valley area where the lodge and guest house would eventually be located. They built fencing, bought red deer and started raising them for meat and velvet. From there, they cleared parts of the dense jungle foliage in the valleys on their property as a site for a lodge and guest house. They chose a perfect area with a small stream running through it designing a lodge that looked like it belonged in Archectural Digest or in a ski resort like Vail or Aspen or Innsbruck.

They rough sawed lumber they cut on their own land using 330 tons of logs and timber to build the lodge and guest house. They then used the old method of insulating the place with straw in the walls covered by five layers of hand trowelled plaster. Mel did the plaster work as Mort did the carpentry and finish work. My wife and I have remodeled several homes over the years and found the quality of this work exceptional. The guest house was built the same and even had heated floors in the bathroom. I was blown away by the beauty and quality of the accommodations.

Mel is a super chef as well. Each meal was outstanding. As I mentioned earlier, I delayed starting hunting one morning just to sit and eat.

Mort is a former meat hunter and very skilled. He is a perfectionist with his guns and ammo, reloading exactly what his rifle would shoot well. He knew his animals and how best to approach them. We had the hardest time with the fallow deer as the rut was full on and the females busted us several times. I never took a fallow with Mort but should have. He is personable, knows the history of his country and knows his birds. He is every bit as excellent as Gerald is in his home territory.

I have no negative comments about either guide. They are both professionals and very fun to hunt with.

Summary and Opinion

The big question – Would I do this hunt again? Answer, of course! This was fun and extremely enjoyable. It is very wife friendly and very much a good hunt. If you like sheep or mountain hunting, you will love hunting chamois and tahr. If you like elk hunting, you will like stag hunting. If you like varmint hunting, you will love spot-lighting possums. Getting there is easy. People are friendly. After this hunt, I will struggle to pay for a horseback elk hunt or something that requires sleeping on the ground or eating bad food. For the same hunting dollar, New Zealand offers a lot of fun and relaxation.

The other question is – what would I hunt next time? Answer – all of the same animals. I would likely spend more time after fallow deer as I really like them, but I would hunt any and everything they have… except pigs. I leave the pigs for the local guys that really like them.

The last question is – Would I hunt big or small areas, high or low fence? Yes, all of them. I only ask for fair chase and really do not want to debate what fair chase means. For me, fair chase means the animals are intimately familiar with the terrain, know how to get away and are tough to hunt. I really do not care about the fence aspect of it as the entire country is fenced in one way or another. Would I hunt a monster stag in an enclosure? No. I am not an “inch” guy. I like fair chase and really am not into “gold this” or “silver that”.

I go for fun as does my wife. This is only the second place she said she wants to go back to.


I am an avid bird watcher. Here is a list of what I was able to identify. I did not work hard at this and missed a bunch of the LBJ’s (little brown jobs) that I normally would identify. I was hunting too hard to spend a lot of time on the small birds.

Rosella Parakeet


European Starling
English Sparrow
Paradise Shellduck
Swamp Harrier
New Zealand Gray Fantail –my favorite!
Australian Magpie
India Myna
California Valley Quail
Spurwinged Plover
Grey Warbler
Welcome Swift
Kereru – Wood Pigeon
Mallard Duck
Black Swan
Black-backed Gulls
South Island Tomtit
New Zealand Scaup
Little Black Shag
Pied Shag
Red-billed Gull
Australian Coot
Bush Wren
Bush Falcon
New Zealand Pipit
Hedge Sparrow or Dunnock
Ringneck Pheasant
Morepork Owl
North Island Tomtit
New Zealand Robin
Eastern Rosella Parakeet (stunning!)
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
Picture of Bakes
posted Hide Post
Looks like a great trip mate. Fantastic photo's tu2

A mate of mine has just told me he's shagging his girlfriend and her twin. I said "How can you tell them apart?" He said "Her brother's got a moustache!"
Posts: 7497 | Location: Bloody Queensland where every thing is 20 years behind the rest of Australia! | Registered: 25 January 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of wazza56
posted Hide Post
nice stags and pics Cool

keep your barrell clean and your powder dry
Posts: 374 | Location: NW West Australia / Onepoto NZ | Registered: 09 February 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Fantastic report and photos my friend!!!
Im glad you and your wife had a wonderful time of fun and relaxation!!!
Posts: 3430 | Registered: 24 February 2007Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Singleshot03
posted Hide Post
Enjoyed reading about your hunt and I really liked the format you used to communicate your adventure.

Posts: 1341 | Location: Cincinnati  | Registered: 28 May 2009Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Great read Ross, outstanding hunt.

Doug McMann
ph# 250-476-1288
Fax # 250-476-1288
PO Box 27
Tatlayoko Lake, BC
V0L 1W0
Posts: 1194 | Location:  | Registered: 21 April 2008Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Fabulous report and photos.

Thanks, Chris

Posts: 1590 | Location: Australia | Registered: 25 December 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Nice Fallow tu2

"Never in the field of human conflict
was so much owed by so many to so few." Sir Winston Churchill

Posts: 1827 | Location: Throughout the British Empire | Registered: 08 October 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of buffybr
posted Hide Post
dogcat, Very well written report, and congratulations on your great hunt.

My girlfriend and I were on the South Island this past March and April, and I recognize several of the photos that you posted. We stayed in Wanaka the night of April 2nd. A beautiful little town and area. We left New Zealand on April 16th, just a few days before you got there. The Stags were in full roar while we were there.

I also used I think the same Eberlestock daypack that you mentioned. I made a few modifications to mine: I added a buckled nylon strap to the top of the scabbard to keep my rifle from moving; I bought 2 side pockets and added string closures (like the center section of the pack has) under the top flaps; And I lowered the waist belt so that it rides more on my hips instead of around my waist.

The town of Wanaka has a park along the edge of the lake, and there is about a half mile long trail that runs the length of the park. One side of the trail is lined with about 12"x12" tiles, one for each year from year 0 to the present. Many tiles list important events in world history that happened that year.

We read many of the tiles, and I found this one interesting.

NRA Endowment Life Member
Posts: 1512 | Location: Bozangeles, MT | Registered: 14 February 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
That first tahr is an interesting head. I haven't seen much like it before. Not just the horns, but the nose shape and all looks different.
Posts: 2209 | Location: North Island NZ | Registered: 21 July 2008Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Gerald said the same thing. He and a couple other local seemed very impressed with it. It was a lot older than the other one but I have no frame of reference as this was my first encounter with them.
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of highlander
posted Hide Post
Ross will attest to my indecision when we were all set up on our tahr, absolute perfect set up at 250-290 m and there we were with 4 bulls, 3 of which were trophies.
I kept coming back to the one Bull as there was something different about him ,you know the X factor thing, he just grabbed my attention.
Well the photo shows why, that is the most unique Bull I have ever seen and trust me I've seen a lot.
Kudos to Ross as he PUT up with whim and save me from a certain amount of opps why did I say shoot that one by taking a second bull. I've got a thing about unusual trophies and that tahr is special.
Posts: 263 | Location: New Zealand | Registered: 08 June 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
No regrets. When will I ever get a double chance at tahr! I was thrilled! I would do that everyday and twice on Sunday!

GO Hunting in New Zealand!!!
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Awesome stags!
Posts: 1077 | Location: NT, Australia | Registered: 10 February 2011Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Great hunt report. I will have to come back and read it again in detail. Hunting in New Zealand is on my bucket list!

Be without fear in the face of your enemies. Be brave and upright, that God may love thee. Speak the truth always, even if it leads to your death. Safeguard the helpless and do no wrong;
Posts: 10371 | Location: Jacksonville, Florida | Registered: 09 January 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Nakihunter
posted Hide Post
Great report. Congratulations on some fine animals.

Yes Gerald is a great guide. I hunted with him 20 years ago & my wife went on a flight with Sue!

"When the wind stops....start rowing. When the wind starts, get the sail up quick."
Posts: 10838 | Location: New Zealand | Registered: 02 July 2008Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Great report, photos, and trophies!
Posts: 706 | Location: California | Registered: 26 May 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of FishN4Eyes
posted Hide Post
Awesome report and pics!

Always enjoy your reports, I think NZ is now on the List!
Posts: 733 | Location: Helena, Montana | Registered: 28 October 2009Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Very interesting as I'm hoping to go visit there next year. May not do any hunting, much depends on how my health turns out by then.

Impressive country from what little I've seen of it. Same with their animals, WOW the racks on those stags.

Thanks much for sharing this trip with us and the great pictures.

"Gun Control is NOT about Guns'
"It's about Control!!"
Join the NRA today!"


George L. Dwight
Posts: 5267 | Location: Pueblo, CO | Registered: 31 January 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Simply superb! Hunt has been top of my bucket too long! Thanks for sharingt
Posts: 1308 | Registered: 17 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Highlander7
posted Hide Post
Congrats on a great hunt and sharing the report!

MSG, USA (Ret.) Armor
NRA Life Memeber
Posts: 580 | Location: Chester County, PA. | Registered: 09 February 2011Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Fantastic hunt and report.

You do well!

Posts: 39194 | Location: Crosby and Barksdale, Texas | Registered: 18 September 2006Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Posts: 633 | Location: California | Registered: 25 June 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
My apologies to you as this hunt supplanted my idea of a boat bear hunt in Alaska.

I really liked NZ but hope to do the boat bear someday.
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Wendell Reich
posted Hide Post

Great report. I was wondering how this hunt went. I just love Stag, they are so regal.
Posts: 6032 | Location: Dallas, TX | Registered: 13 July 2001Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
I really like the classic looking stags. The ones that look like porcupines do not do much for me. I like the way they carry themselves and enjoy hunting them. This is the first place my wife has ever said she was going back to. So, I get to go back!
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Greg Brownlee
posted Hide Post
As usual great hunt report, Ross! Well done, love the stag and tahr double!


Greg Brownlee
Neal and Brownlee, LLC
Quality Worldwide Big Game Hunts Since 1975

Instagram: @NealAndBrownleeLLC

Hunt reports:

Botswana 2010

Alaska 2011

Bezoar Ibex, Turkey 2012

Mid Asian Ibex, Kyrgyzstan 2014
Posts: 1136 | Location: Tulsa, OK | Registered: 08 February 2010Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Great hunt report, wonderful reading, excellent photography. I love the addition of the trip list of bird species seen...a nice secondary trophy of any trip.

I'm glad you shot no Hobbits!
Posts: 1028 | Location: Manitoba, Canada | Registered: 01 December 2007Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Just got the call from the trophy preparer, they will be shipped fairly soon. This was a shock as I just got a leopard from Zim that my son shot last June...
Another reason New Zealand is my new favorite place...
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Love this report, especially for the honest report on what you experienced in New Zealand. Seems it`s an easy to enjoy kind of huntSmiler
Posts: 1059 | Location: Norway | Registered: 08 June 2012Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Awesome report - congrats on a wonderful trip! Thanks for sharing.
Posts: 1489 | Location: New York | Registered: 01 January 2010Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of Fjold
posted Hide Post
Great report and beautiful pictures, thanks for posting it.


"I don't know what there is about buffalo that frightens me so.....He looks like he hates you personally. He looks like you owe him money."
- Robert Ruark, Horn of the Hunter, 1953

NRA Life, SAF Life, CRPA Life, DRSS lite

Posts: 12041 | Location: Bakersfield CA. USA | Registered: 30 December 2002Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Sorry for the late response to all of the PM's. In summary, both hunts were fantastic.

Gerald Telford is a pro. He has great areas very close to Wanaka and the hunts are free range/fair chase. There is some high fence hunts for the monster stags, but you can do either. We hunted tahr and chamois on foot. Helicopters are expensive so we opted not to use one for getting up or down from the mountains. Tahr are very plentiful. Chamois are the tough ones to find due the range and their size. You will have fun. This is like a hunt out of the ranchers cabin.

For Kuranui, Mel and Mort Moon are superb hosts. Fantastic accommodations. Excellent hunting. This is high fence, in some serious hills and jungle. Very challenging. You will see plenty of game. The Rusa deer here are unique and I would tell you to go just for that. The stags are excellent, the fallow are excellent. The best part of this hunt is that you hunt out your front door, all on foot, lots of hiking and bird watching. You will love Mel and Mort. You will be the only people there.

Anyway, if you want to hunt NZ, these people are excellent, fun and very skilled.

Hope this helps.
Posts: 9278 | Location: Texas... time to secede!! | Registered: 12 February 2004Reply With Quote
one of us
posted Hide Post
Ross, I am glad this hunt went so well. Awesome Rusa, along with the rest! Congratulations.
Posts: 633 | Location: California | Registered: 25 June 2005Reply With Quote
one of us
Picture of fairgame
posted Hide Post
Outstanding report of what looks to be the most beautiful country.

Email -
Tel/Whatsapp (00260) 975315144
Instagram - kafueroyal
Posts: 8848 | Location: Zambia | Registered: 10 April 2009Reply With Quote
  Powered by Social Strata    The Accurate Reloading Forums    THE ACCURATE RELOADING.COM FORUMS  Hop To Forum Categories  Hunting  Hop To Forums  Australian and New Zealand Hunting    Hobbit Hunt Report - Hunt with Gerald Telford and Mort Moon

Copyright December 1997-2021

Visit our on-line store for AR Memorabilia