The Accurate Reloading Forums
Bullet stability calculator

This topic can be found at:
https://forums.accuratereloading.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/5031007002/m/5081099202

04 August 2014, 14:02
SR4759
Bullet stability calculator
This might help picking bullets for a .50 cal rifle.

Bullet stability calculator
11 August 2014, 06:14
RIP
According to the calculator,
of the cast bullets I can now make,
the NEI .512/780-grainer in soft lead would be best for accuracy in a 1:26" twist 50-90 Sharps,
SF stays between 2.0 and about 1.7 for any muzzle velocity above Mach 1, from about 1150 fps to 4000 fps:



The .512/680-grain Hoch in 30:1 Lead:Tin is runnerup (for 1:26" twist) with SF of about 2.4 to 2.6 for muzzle velocities between Mach 1 and 4000 fps. That is the bigger bullet below.
More practical for hunting accuracy and performance on game with a 50-90 Sharps:







Another champ for "accuracy SF" is the Lee .515"/450-grainer in 30:1 Pb:Sn, the lightweight above,
in a 1:42" twist like my antique Trapdoor 50-70,
SF stays between 2.1 and 2.4 for MV from Mach 1 to 4000 fps.
11 August 2014, 10:23
SR4759
How about a little discussion?
Does anyone here have a lot of experience using the stability factor calculators to chose bullets and design moulds.

I am sure they work well when you know the stability factor that works for your application.

For example at BPCR.net I ran into an old discussion that recommended the improved calculator at
JBM calculator
This is the same calculator shown at Berger's web site though Berger's GUI is simpler.


The BPCR guys said that the best results seen at 1000 yards were with bullet barrel combos that had a stability factor of 2.4.

Generally the calculators state that a stability factor of 1.5 is adequate. However they do not say to what distance 1.5 is adequate. Has anyone played with bullet design out to 1000 yards and compared the results to the SF calculators?
02 October 2014, 07:45
yellowstone
Greenhill's formula states
Twist = 150 * dia.bullet 2/length of bullet
If you measure the bore diameter and know the twist od the barrel, you can start fiddling with the stability factors, especially for long range.
02 October 2014, 08:25
SR4759
The JBM and a few other calculators are far more advanced than Greenhill's formula.
02 October 2014, 19:12
larry bryant
RIP has a key word here when he says mach 1. Not many bp loads can stay above the speed of sound past the chicken line and most calculations were based on super-sonic loads.
03 October 2014, 00:43
SR4759
This calculator recognizes the different conditions between sub sonic and super sonic.

It appears that BPCR projectiles can wind up traveling most of the distance to the target in the transonic region. I am not sure what twist is supposed to be used for that.

The geoffrey-kolbe calculator shows the trans sonic region in the twist plot.

http://www.geoffrey-kolbe.com/barrel_twist.htm